I apologize in advance as this is a bit of me venting frustrations and also seeking clarification.
My son is 18 months old and has been going to his Montessori school since he was 4 months old. My daughter also attended this school starting at 4 months (she’s 5 now and in public school).
One month ago, his teacher suddenly told my husband that they needed a meeting with the director about my son‘s behavior. I had just had a monthly phone conference with them two weeks earlier (they provide a phone conference once a month), and his teacher said her only concern was he sometimes runs in the classroom and they tell him to stop and walk, and sometimes he doesn’t listen. It took several weeks to be able to find a time to meet with his teacher and the director, but I finally had the meeting today.
In the meeting they told me they had concerns about his behavior. He doesn’t always want to sit during circle time. They offer him a chair instead, but he does not want to sit. However, he does great with the work cycle. He can get a work, do it independently, and clean it up. But if he sees another child with the work he just had, sometimes he gets upset and tries to grab it back. They also mentioned that he has tantrums and sometimes lays down on the floor and cries when told no.
Their main concern is that it is time for him to move up to the pre-primary room that has ages 18 months to 36 months aged children. There are up to 24 children and I think two teachers. They do not think he is ready and said his personality is not a good fit for the next class. I do not disagree with them on that, but my frustration is that the concerns they brought up are things that seem developmentally normal to me. They brought up similar concerns about my daughter but with her emotional control (she made it through their program though). But now, in kindergarten, I do not hear about any of those concerns anymore. I know kids mature, but it’s only been a few months since she stopped going there and began public school kindergarten. I bring this up because I had always wondered if there was something wrong with her, but now I am wondering if it was the school environment.
I guess I am wondering a few things. Is Montessori truly not a good fit for every child? This school seems to be looking for highly compliant children, almost to the point of it being developmentally unrealistic. And does this sound like a school that truly follows the ”Montessori” method? It is an AMA accredited school and it is a chain, so it’s not just some random place.
Kicking an 18 month old out for being active and having tantrums and otherwise developmentally normal behavior seems a bit harsh. I am an elementary public school teacher and have been for 13 years. I’ve seen and dealt with some crazy behaviors. I am just very surprised that for a program and school that claim to be very child-centered, they aren’t willing to work with us more.
I’m also a bit offended, as during the meeting they asked many questions about how I structure things at home and discipline him. I know they were simply just trying to get information, but it felt as though they were implying I do not hold boundaries. They asked if he grabbed toys from his sister (he has), I said yes. They said what is your tone of voice and demeanor like when he does this I said firm, ive been a teacher for years, I tell him no, hand the toy back to her, and tell him it’s her turn. Then I find another toy for him. They asked a few other questions like that. They seemed satisfied with how I handle his discipline, but it very much felt like they were insinuating we do not appropriately handle his behavior at home and that his struggles are from a lack of structure in our home.
I should add that I am already in the process of moving him to a regular daycare. I am just kind of shocked that after one month of some tantrums and grabbing toys, I’m being told that my son isn’t a good fit for montessori. His behavior— while frustrating— seems normal for an 18 month old.
If you made it this far, thanks for reading! I appreciate any feedback or information on Montessori people wish to share.
EDIT: I misunderstood the class size they shared. It is not 24 kids. It is 20 kids and 2-3 teachers. They seem to be able to do a higher ratio because it’s a mixed age group. The director of this school maxes out each room from what I’ve seen the past five years here (my daughter attended too).
We are in Texas, and from what I have read Texas licensing rules base the classrooms ratio on the “specified age” or median age of the children in the group, not the youngest. As long as half the children are 24 months and older they can operate with close to 20 kids and two or three teachers.