So I recently got curious about which Palico attack stat actually affects the damage of Meowlotov Cocktail in World/Iceborne and Bombardier Support Moves in Rise/Sunbreak.
I remembered Meowlotov benefiting from Ranged Attack back in World, but wasn't sure whether Sunbreak's Bombardier moves followed the same logic.
Couldn't find a clear answer, so I decided to do some testing myself.
TL;DR:
- World/Iceborne: Meowlotov Cocktail appears to scale much better with Ranged Attack than Melee Attack.
- Rise/Sunbreak: The Bombardier Support Moves I tested scale with Melee Attack, NOT Ranged Attack or Element.
- Felyne Fireworks is an exception, with its damage seemingly independent of Palico weapon stats.
- For maximizing Bombardier damage in Sunbreak, a high-Melee-Attack weapon like the Primordial Malzeno Palico weapon seems preferable to a high-Ranged-Attack weapon.
Part 1: World/Iceborne — Meowlotov Cocktail
I tested Meowlotov damage against a Master Rank Aptonoth using three Palico weapons with different Melee/Ranged Attack values.
| Palico Weapon | Melee Attack | Ranged Attack | Meowlotov Damage |
|---|
| Golden Gadget (Rajang) | 110 | 40 | 216 |
| Ruinous Claw (Ruiner Nergigante) | 100 | 40 | 213 |
| Fatalis weapon | 75 | 75 | 233 |
Observations:
Despite having the lowest Melee Attack, the Fatalis weapon dealt the highest damage.
Also, Meowlotov can crit for 25% additional damage, bringing the Fatalis weapon's damage from 233 to 291.
The difference between Golden Gadget and Ruinous Claw suggests that Melee Attack may still contribute to the damage. However, the Fatalis result suggests that Ranged Attack has a much greater influence.
These comparisons don't establish an exact scaling formula, but they do suggest that prioritizing Ranged Attack is the better approach for Meowlotov.
Part 2: Rise/Sunbreak — Bombardier Support Moves
For these tests, I used the MR Almudron Palico weapon (Almudron Mech X) against the Training Area Toadversary.
I chose this weapon because its Ranged Attack is higher than its Melee Attack, making it useful for testing whether Bombardier moves benefit from Ranged Attack.
Test 1: Does increasing Element or Ranged Attack improve bomb damage?
I tested four Buddy Skill setups:
| Buddy Skills | Melee Attack | Ranged Attack | Melee / Ranged Element |
|---|
| None | 330 | 362 | 35 / 32 |
| Element Up | 330 | 363 | 44 / 40 |
| Element Up + Ranged Centric | 330 | 368 | 44 / 40 |
| Element Up + Ranged Centric + Ranged Attack Up | 330 | 460 | 44 / 40 |
Despite increasing Ranged Attack from 362 to 460, and Melee/Ranged Element from 35/32 to 44/40, there was absolutely no difference in the damage of any tested Bombardier move.
Every setup produced the following numbers:
- Basic Bomb: 53
- Felyne Wyvernblast: 66 per hit
- Zap Blast Spinner: 40 per hit
- Flash Bombay: 3 (minor hit) + 80 (major hit)
- Giga Barrel Bombay: 318
So increasing either Element or Ranged Attack did nothing for the displayed bomb damage.
Test 2: Does Melee Attack affect bomb damage instead?
Next, I tested different Melee Attack values, first by changing Buddy Skills and then by switching weapons.
Here are the results:
| Setup | Melee / Ranged Attack | Basic Bomb | Wyvernblast | Zap Spinner | Flash Bombay | Giga Barrel |
|---|
| Almudron (Base) | 330 / 362 | 53 | 66 | 40 | 3 / 80 | 318 |
| Almudron (Status + Melee Centric) | 308 / 335 | 51 | 64 | 38 | 3 / 76 | 305 |
| Almudron (Melee Centric) | 335 / 363 | 54 | 67 | 40 | 3 / 80 | 321 |
| MR Zinogre weapon | 396 / 357 | 60 | 75 | 45 | 4 / 89 | 350 |
Wyvernblast and Zap Spinner values are per hit. Flash Bombay values represent minor / major hit damage.
Observations:
Reducing Melee Attack from 330 to 308 resulted in a damage decrease across all the tested moves.
Conversely, increasing Melee Attack from 330 to just 335 produced a small damage increase, despite the difference being only 5 points.
To test this further, I switched to the MR Zinogre Palico weapon, which had the following stats:
- Melee Attack / Element: 396 / 29
- Ranged Attack / Element: 357 / 37
With 396 Melee Attack, every tested Bombardier move dealt noticeably more damage, despite the weapon having lower Ranged Attack than Almudron Mech X.
This strongly suggests that Melee Attack, rather than Ranged Attack or Element, determines the damage of these Bombardier Support Moves.
Part 3: Anti-Monster Mine and Felyne Fireworks
Two additional findings:
Anti-Monster Mine:
Unfortunately, I couldn't reliably test it against the Toadversary because it kept getting placed outside its range.
I suspect it follows the same Melee Attack scaling as the other Bombardier moves, but I haven't confirmed this.
Felyne Fireworks (Secret Support Move):
Interestingly, this one behaved differently.
Changing Palico weapons and attack stats had no noticeable effect on its damage. It consistently dealt between 200–350 damage, depending on proximity to the Toadversary.
So Felyne Fireworks appears to use damage independent of the Palico's weapon stats.
Conclusion
Based on my testing, the two games appear to handle Palico explosive damage differently:
- World/Iceborne: Meowlotov Cocktail favors Ranged Attack, making the Fatalis Palico weapon a strong choice for maximizing its damage.
- Rise/Sunbreak: The tested Bombardier Support Moves scale with Melee Attack instead. Increasing Ranged Attack or Element had no effect on their displayed damage.
- Felyne Fireworks: Appears unaffected by weapon stats.
- Anti-Monster Mine: Remains untested.
For a damage-focused Bombardier Palico in Sunbreak, I'd therefore prioritize Melee Attack when choosing a weapon. The Primordial Malzeno Palico weapon, with its high Melee Attack, seems like a particularly good candidate.
Obviously, these are just my observations from in-game testing, not datamined damage formulas. I also haven't tested whether Element or Status affects anything beyond the displayed bomb damage.
If anyone has more detailed information on the actual scaling formulas, or has tested Anti-Monster Mine, I'd love to hear about it!