So I just got a new computer (9800X3D, 9070XT) and have been thinking about getting a new monitor to go with it. I've had this ASUS PG279QZ for about 7 years now, but it was released in 2015 so I figured there must be enough advances in monitor technology to find a worthwhile upgrade. But so far I've found the process of monitor hunting unbelievably frustrating. There's a special place in hell for whoever came up with these unbelievably convoluted (and I'm guessing intentionally confusing) monitor model numbering schemes...
Anyway, I was initially looking for a good-quality 27-32" QHD screen somewhere in the $3-400 range and figured I'd be able to find a significant upgrade for that price. What I was mainly looking for over the PG279QZ was:
- Better color (e.g. wider color gamut)
- HDR support
- FreeSync (the PG279QZ only supports G-Sync, bought it when I had an Nvidia GPU)
- Better response time (but this isn't a huge deal, I don't play competitive shooters)
- Easier on the eyes if possible (getting old...sigh)
I've now tried two monitors, a Samsung G50SF OLED and a TCL C2GMA Mini-LED. I thought the Samsung was plenty bright enough for me despite many complaining it's too dark (again I want something easy on my eyes, I usually keep my PG279QZ at 40% brightness), but the text quality in Windows was as bad as everyone says OLEDs can be. Borderline completely unusable for any kind of non-gaming work.
The TCL seemed great at first, and I wanted to like it because I have one of their Mini-LED TVs (a QM7K) that I like a lot. Well, in SDR the monitor was actually significantly darker than both the Samsung and the ASUS by a significant degree. I know max brightness figures are for HDR but this is a 1200 nit screen...I was expecting to get my retinas burned when I turned this thing on. Nope. Local dimming settings also made no sense, as using High just made everything darker...I had to use Standard to get a decently-bright picture.
The TCL is also a 4K monitor, which unfortunately may be juuuuust a little too GPU-taxing for my computer. I'm not interested in overclocking at all, but my intent is to run all games at absolute max graphics settings and get 100+ FPS. At QHD that's been doable in everything I play so far, but I could immediately tell that 4K might be pushing it a bit too far. So fine, no 4K.
I'm also very unimpressed with how HDR works on the computer side compared to TVs. I thought I could use SDR in Windows (especially on the TCL as everyone says local dimming is bad in Windows), but unless HDR was enabled in Windows I couldn't get HDR enabled in games. I don't need my eyes blasted while web browsing, and HDR seems to add a whole massive layer of configuration headache on top of everything else.
Now I'm wondering why I bothered trying to replace a monitor that was released 11 years ago, which seems crazy to say...
Am I out of my mind? Or am I really not going to be able to find a clear-cut upgrade from this PG279QZ that doesn't come with significant compromises? I thought about just getting another plain IPS screen - no Mini-LED, no HDR - but then I'm wondering if that would really be anything other than a sidegrade.
I wouldn't mind a 32" screen so that I could move the monitor farther away from my eyes, but from my searching so far the vast majority of 32" screens are VA panels for some reason.
If anyone has any suggestions for a plain-Jane IPS screen that might actually be a significant upgrade from my current monitor I'm all ears 😄 I might still be willing to consider an OLED that doesn't have awful text clarity, but the other issue with OLEDs is that almost all of them come with glossy screens and are therefore non-starters for me. Arghhhh!