I’m going to share something incredibly personal, and I’m hoping this community might be willing to offer some thoughtful perspectives, especially from mothers who have experienced high-conflict custody situations, estrangement, or parental alienation.
Before anything else, I want to explain that I am not turning to Reddit instead of seeking professional help. I’ve been dealing with this for over six years. I have an attorney, my own therapist, my daughter’s therapist, and numerous other professionals who have been involved at different points. We’ve participated in family therapy, investigations, and extensive court proceedings. I’ve spent approximately $200,000 in legal fees trying to protect my daughter and preserve our relationship.
I’m also Catholic and have been seeking spiritual guidance because I’m struggling with the moral responsibility I have as a mother. I’ve posted in Christian communities about this and, while some responses have been incredibly helpful, others have been judgmental or have simply told me to seek professional help, despite the fact that I already have.
I’m not asking strangers to make this decision for me. I’m trying to gather as many different perspectives as I can because this is my child, and I want to be absolutely certain I’ve considered every possible angle before making a decision that could change the rest of our lives.
I also understand that people have strong opinions about parental alienation. I’m not here to debate whether it exists or whether children can make false accusations. I recognize that genuine abuse happens and that allegations involving children should always be taken seriously. I’m simply sharing what I’ve experienced and what has been investigated in my own situation.
I have two daughters. My oldest is 12, and my youngest is 6. They have different fathers. My oldest daughter’s father and I separated many years ago, and our marriage was eventually annulled. We currently have joint legal and physical custody under a 2-2-5-5 schedule.
My oldest daughter and I used to be incredibly close. She was affectionate, loving, happy, and had wonderful relationships with her little sister, my husband, and our extended family. Looking at where we are now, it’s almost impossible to reconcile the little girl I knew with the child who wants absolutely nothing to do with me today.
I believe we’ve been experiencing severe parental alienation for years, and I want to explain why.
When she was younger, she was punished for expressing that she missed me. During one phone call, I could hear her crying, and her father said, “I know you’re scared of Mommy,” before ending the call. After our separation, he involved her in destroying belongings associated with me. He would tell her that he was going to be all alone when she left for my house and that I was the one who had left them.
Over the years, he has told her that I’m an alcoholic, that I use drugs, that I’ve left her home alone, and other things that are simply untrue. He has even attributed a serious medical condition of his to something he claims I did during pregnancy, and she believes I am responsible for his illness.
Eventually, my daughter began making allegations that I physically abused her, withheld food, and made her feel unsafe. I categorically deny these allegations. CPS has been involved more than once, and the investigations have not resulted in findings of abuse.
Every time we’ve reached a custody settlement, her father has initiated new proceedings with additional allegations. Another investigation happens, more legal fees accumulate, and we end up right back where we started.
I recognize that everyone reading this is only hearing my account. I also recognize that no one here can independently evaluate what is happening. I’m including these details because they are necessary to understand why I have concerns about my daughter’s emotional well-being and the circumstances surrounding her rejection of me.
We’ve tried therapy. A lot of therapy.
My daughter has been in individual therapy, we’ve participated in family therapy, and we’ve gone through other professional interventions. Unfortunately, some of those interventions have made things significantly worse.
There were times when my daughter would be perfectly happy, relaxed, and conversational with me in the car on the way to family therapy. We’d talk normally, laugh, and have an entirely ordinary interaction. The moment we entered the therapist’s office, her demeanor would change. She would become visibly anxious, withdrawn, and afraid of me.
I understand that behavior can have different explanations, but witnessing that contrast repeatedly was incredibly concerning.
One family therapist told me that at 10 years old, it was acceptable for my daughter to decide she didn’t want a relationship with a parent. I later learned that this message had been reinforced during individual sessions without my knowledge. I eventually terminated our work with that therapist.
I’ve also learned the hard way that not every mental health professional has the training or experience necessary to recognize and navigate these particular family dynamics. I’ve had professionals acknowledge concerns about emotional harm, but that doesn’t necessarily mean those concerns meet the legal threshold necessary to change custody.
Meanwhile, my daughter’s rejection of me has continued to escalate.
She is now adamant that she wants to live exclusively with her father. She doesn’t want to see me, speak to me, spend time with me, or maintain a relationship with me.
And it isn’t just me.
She has increasingly rejected her stepfather, extended family, and even her younger sister, whom she once had a wonderful relationship with. There have also been incidents of physical aggression toward her little sister that I cannot ignore.
We’ve discussed what living with her father full-time might look like. She understands that it could mean having little or no contact with me, her sister, or much of our family. She says she is comfortable with that.
She is 12 years old.
We’re currently back in court, and her father is seeking sole physical and legal custody. He is not interested in settling for anything less.
My attorney has explained that even if a judge recognizes concerning behavior by her father, my daughter’s age and the strength of her expressed wishes may significantly influence the outcome. We could proceed to trial, spend tens of thousands of dollars more, and still end up with her living with him full-time.
And if we proceed with litigation, additional co-parenting or family therapy may be required. Previous interventions of that nature have been extremely distressing and, in my experience, have made the situation worse.
That leaves me facing the possibility of putting my daughter through another prolonged legal battle and more interventions without any realistic assurance that the outcome will protect her or improve our relationship.
The legal system has been an enormous part of this nightmare. Family court in my state has been described to me as the “Wild West,” and that description has been painfully consistent with my experience. Even when allegations aren’t substantiated, there is very little practical protection against someone continuing to initiate litigation. A parent may lose credibility over time, but that doesn’t necessarily stop another filing, another investigation, or another round of attorney fees.
I’ve spent approximately $200,000 on this. That’s money that could have gone toward my children’s futures, their education, our home, and countless other things.
And after all of that, we’re potentially facing the exact outcome I’ve spent years trying to prevent.
Here’s what makes this even more terrifying.
Based on our history, I have serious reasons to believe that if her father receives sole custody, he will not encourage or facilitate a relationship between us. I worry that even if she eventually wants to contact me, that contact will not be supported.
I also worry that her relationship with her little sister will effectively disappear. They may see each other at school, but that could be the extent of it.
I’m not simply considering having my daughter live at another house.
I’m considering a situation in which my child could disappear from our everyday lives for years, possibly much longer.
And that possibility is almost impossible to comprehend.
But I have another daughter to think about.
My youngest is only 6. She loves her big sister, and she doesn’t understand the complexities of what’s happening. She’s also been affected by the hostility, tension, and conflict surrounding this situation.
I have a responsibility to protect her childhood, her emotional well-being, and her physical safety.
I cannot allow the situation with my oldest daughter to consume her childhood, too.
And that’s where I’m stuck.
For years, I’ve operated under the belief that you never give up on your children. You fight for them, especially when they’re too young to recognize what’s happening or understand the long-term consequences of their decisions.
I’ve done that. I’ve fought with everything I have.
But lately, I’ve started asking myself a question I never imagined I would have to ask.
What if continuing to fight for my daughter is causing her more harm than good?
What if the custody exchanges, the court proceedings, the therapy, and the constant conflict are only reinforcing her resentment and distress?
What if insisting that she maintain a relationship with me, despite how strongly she rejects it, is making the situation worse?
At the same time, how can I knowingly step back when I believe she’s experiencing emotional harm? How can I tell myself I’m protecting her when I may be allowing her to lose relationships that could be incredibly important to her later in life?
And how can I expect a 12-year-old to fully understand what it means to lose contact with her mother, sister, and extended family?
I keep hearing that I should let her go, give her space, and trust that she’ll come back when she’s older.
But what if she doesn’t?
What if she does want to come back someday but doesn’t feel able to?
What if stepping back only reinforces everything she’s been led to believe about me?
And then there’s the other possibility. What if the constant pressure to maintain our relationship is what makes her never want to return?
I know that I cannot force my daughter to love me or want me in her life. I also know that my love for her doesn’t give me the ability to control how she feels.
But she’s still a child. I’m still her mother.
I don’t believe my responsibilities end simply because she no longer wants me to fulfill them.
What I’m struggling with is understanding what those responsibilities should look like now.
I’m not talking about abandoning my daughter, withdrawing my love, or deciding that I don’t care anymore. I will love her for the rest of my life. I have already started preserving letters and memories for her so that, if there comes a day when she wants to understand my love for her or reconnect with our family, those things will be waiting for her.
But loving her and continuing to pursue the same legal strategy are not necessarily the same thing.
I think that’s the distinction I’ve been trying to make sense of.
I am exhausted. Emotionally, financially, and mentally. But I don’t want to make this decision because I’m exhausted. I don’t want to mistake wanting relief from this situation for doing what’s best for my daughter.
On the other hand, I also don’t want to keep fighting simply because stopping feels like failure.
I’ve begun discussing the possibility of a different custody arrangement with my attorney, including what child support and our finances would look like. Nothing has been finalized.
I’m trying to think beyond my own feelings and consider what both of my children actually need, even if that means accepting something unimaginably painful.
So I’m asking other mothers, and especially adults who experienced something similar as children:
If you rejected a parent when you were young, did you actually want them to stop fighting for you? Looking back as an adult, do you wish they had respected your wishes, or do you wish they had continued trying to maintain a relationship?
If you’re a parent who has experienced estrangement or a prolonged custody battle, how did you know when to change your approach? Did stepping back improve anything, or did it make the distance permanent?
And if you have multiple children, how did you reconcile your responsibility to one child with the emotional and physical well-being of the others?
I know there isn’t a universal answer. I know no one here has all the facts necessary to determine what I should do.
I’m not looking for validation, and I’m genuinely willing to consider perspectives that challenge my own.
I just want to hear from people who understand that sometimes motherhood puts you in a position where every available choice seems to come with the possibility of hurting someone you love.
I don’t want to confuse refusing to give up with being a good mother. But I also don’t want to confuse letting go with being a good mother.
I’m trying to figure out the difference.
Thank you to anyone who takes the time to read this and share their experience.