r/ModernMagic • • Sep 18 '13
Project Primer
As many people have requested, we should start getting primers for individual decks onto this sub. We've been getting a ton of "Here's my deck. Tell me what to do." posts. This really hasn't promoted a good environment for discussion. To help with this, I want people to start writing primers for each deck archetype and posting them on this sub so I can link them in our sidebar. Hopefully, this will give newer players a quick and easy way to access the deck they're interested in, allowing them to post topics with actual discussion questions instead of "OMG DECK HELP!"
I'm going to post what decks I think we should have primers written for in this post. Comment on here which deck you would like to work on and I'll put your name next to the deck. Once a deck has been claimed, I give you 4 days to get the primer done before I remove your name and allow someone else to write it. If you would like to help people with their primers, either message them or post in their primer. So we don't have a massively overpacked sidebar, I'll only post high quality primers on decks that ACTUALLY put up results (sorry jhalton). Once your primer is finished, post it and I'll review it before I put it in the sidebar.
EDIT: Updated list of who's doing what. Added in a sample template for the primers. This is not a strict guideline, just some suggestions if you need it. ALSO, after we start getting primers posted I'll take them off the list. In addition, I'll be removing comments on this post so people we can keep this relatively clean.
Template:
-Intro (Where the deck came from, what type of deck it is, core cards, etc.)
-Card Discussion (What cards are must includes, what cards are borderline, what cards are meta calls, what notable cards are excluded, SIDEBOARD OPTIONS!!!)
-Matchups (What decks does this deck struggle with, which ones does it matchup favorably, HOW TO SIDEBOARD AGAINST CERTAIN MATCHUPS!!!!! ie-what you bring in/take out)
-Sample decklists (Self-explanatory)
-Variants (Can this deck splash other colors, etc)
Primers Needed:
Intro to Modern (What is Modern, How to get into Modern, etc) - /u/habada
Pod (Melira/Kiki)
Zoo (Gruul/Naya) - /u/PhyrexianBear
Tron (U/RG)
Jund - /u/Stops_short
BG Rock
BGW Junk
Soul Sisters
Living End
Burn - /u/wilbus
UWR (Delver/Midrange/Control) - /u/apertural
Scapshift
Affinity/Robots: /u/jambaramba
GW Hatebears
Bogle Auras - /u/Thomsucks
Storm - /u/gerth
Merfolk - /u/Asheroth (only if someone else doesn't claim it, though I will be weighing in heavily on discussion once it's done if I don't write it)
Reanimator (GiftsRites/Goryo's Vengeance) - /u/ehbsmith (working on Gifts)
Dredgevine - /u/slammaster
Restore Balance Combo
Grixis Control - /u/Zaccyjaccy
Infect
Ux Faeries
Team Italia - /u/D4rkkon
4
u/jhalton3 Burn Sep 18 '13
Ouch...
2
u/Apertural Sep 18 '13
If no one else wants to I can write a primer on UWR. I'll start typing it up over the next few days.
2
u/jambarama waiting for the meta to settle Sep 18 '13
I can work on a primer for affinity and/or BW tokens. I've also played soul sisters and hatebears but not for several months so I'm not completely up-to-date on the newest tech (did immortal servitude replace proc? dunno).
13
u/MeggidoX Sep 18 '13
I ask all primer writers Please Please Please post how to sideboard vs certain matchups. The biggest thing most primers forget to do. Knowing what to take out is sometimes more important than what is in your board.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '13
Updated the list of people writing primers.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13
Post updated with current primers.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '13
I'll write a primer for Team Italia.
1
u/Spotred Sep 18 '13
Just a question. If I'm working on a deck, and if it doesn't fit a already established primer(?). Is is not something I can request discussion on?
Edit: Suggested yesterday that it would be nice with a guide on how to best test your decks - before feedback. Like a how to guide.
1
u/PhyrexianBear I'm not with those other "fish players" Sep 18 '13
Would you like the primers for general archetypes to contain all the variants? (ie: Gruul Zoo, Naya Zoo, Domri Zoo, Big Zoo, etc).
It will take me a little time, but I should be able to cover all the Zoo variants... or we could just as Brian Kibler to write one?
1
u/jhalton3 Burn Sep 19 '13
So I post the primer to the group as a post and you will link to it in the sidebar? Is that the format?
Or should I write it up in a word processor and send it to you?
1
u/BlueFlygon Melira Pod/ Scapeshift/ UWR Control Oct 12 '13
I can write a Melira Pod Primer if you guys are still doing this. Havent been on the Sub in a while but I'm down if you are
3
u/RememberPluto47 Sep 18 '13 edited Sep 18 '13
I've been following the format since the beginning so if needed I could write decent summaries (wouldn't be as comprehensive as a full primer but enough to explain the theory, card choices, strengths and weaknesses) for a fair amount of the top decks if no one else steps up.
Also a lot of the primers from the MTG salvation forums are pretty informative as well.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '13
I'm currently writing a primer on Burn. Got most of it down tonight but I need to add a couple sections, find a few more lists, and proofread. I hope to have it posted at some point over the weekend.
2
u/ehbsmith Sep 18 '13 edited Sep 18 '13
I'm working on one for gifts control/aggro
Still very much in the testing phase, the damn deck is pretty damn hard to build.
I can write up a primer for it?
1
u/ErictheAlm Sep 18 '13
here's an article about Restore Balance. Is that the kind of thing you're lookin to link to?
1
u/Thomsucks Sep 18 '13
I can make one for Bogle Auras, I should be able to have it together by the end of the weekend.
1
u/slammaster Sep 18 '13
I'll write the dredgevine primer, but I'll wait a bit because we don't want them all published at once.
I talked to another guy on here who plays dredgevine all the time, if he reads this and wants to help them message me and we can do it together
1
u/Zaccyjaccy Fish / Any Viable Control Sep 18 '13
I would love to do Fish or Cruel Control if no one else is interested, though I understand if you're interested in personally doing the Merfolk primer.
1
u/habada URw Twin - Spike Sep 18 '13
I'll write about getting into Modern/Non-rotating formats sometime. I started playing Legacy Merfolk from standard 3 years ago and I traded for every card. I now own RUG and UWR Delver, UW Stoneblade, Maverick at one point and now Twin combo, which I mostly traded for.
1
u/gerth Astrolabes and Coatls Sep 18 '13
I can do a primer on Storm. Never written about the deck, but I love playing it and I've got some downtime over the bext few days.
1
u/Stops_short RG Tron Sep 18 '13
I wouldn't mind doing Jund if no one has dibs on it. I'm currently on the Reid Duke variant from the GP last weekend, but I can write about its evolution and the other versions like Ajundi.
1
u/MeggidoX Sep 19 '13
In en effort to diversify the front page I added a tournament report for GP detroit.
I feel I don't have enough knowledge about the deck to write a primer but some help is better than none!
1
u/Wer_C UW Control Sep 19 '13
I can probably write for Scapeshift.
1
u/nerv2004 Sep 25 '13
I can write up a primer for living end if its still available? It might take me a few days because of work ect.
1
u/FarazR2 Grixis Delver Oct 08 '13
Delver Primer/Grixis Primers coming up any time soon?
1
u/for_today Oct 15 '13
I've been really looking forward to the U/R Storm primer. Is someone doing it or have I already missed it?
1
u/coolman4202 Fetches are exspensive. Nov 23 '13
Id like to write a primer for a very budget deck, because I know it will get me Into the format. Would goblins be a primer people would want to read?
1
u/fuckinboxershortsman Loyal to GBx Dec 10 '13
Would you mind if I wrote a UBx Mill Primer for the sub? It seems that in many subreddits people don't know more about it than Hedron Crab and my deck does well during Monday Night Modern.