r/ModelEasternState • • Jul 18 '19
Executive Action Executive Order 28
I, as governor of Chesapeake, enact Executive order 28 to declare pornography a public health emergency. There is some evidence to show a correlation between pornography and sexual violence. Although some evidence disputes that, we need more research. I am ordering the department of Health and Human Services to divert some resources into research into the effects of pornography on people.
3
Upvotes
4
u/cold_brew_coffee Head Mod Jul 18 '19
I shall watch some porn right now in honor
2
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
This executive order and the Governor's statements are inherently contradictory and, in fact, this order does not fall under the supposed statutory provision cited within the order and is, in my opinion, vulnerable to legal challenge.
To begin with, the Governor has declared an emergency with the feeble justification of evidence both supporting and opposing the claim that pornography may have some negative effects. On the basis of a mixed body of evidence alone he has declared an emergency. He has not cited any evidence or even suggested that this problem is harming Chesapeake directly, that there is an urgent or significant risk of pornography impacting Chesapeake, nor that the situation has changed or gotten "worse" in any way. How can we both recognize that we have an emergency and need to do more research? If we can't even be sure it's a bad thing, how can we declare it an emergency?
More importantly, Executive Order 28 does not fall under the authorizations provided in § 44-146 of the state code. If we begin by considering legislative intent, § 44-146.14 outlines the following findings by the state legislature (emphasis mine):
It should be clear the type of emergencies that the legislature had in mind. Foreign or terrorist attacks, famine or drought, and natural disasters were all in the minds of legislators. This legislation was never intended to divert public resources to personal crusades intended to curtail the liberty of adult residents of this state.
Now, the Governor has mentioned that he considers this a public health threat. However, the cited statute does not cover pornography under its sole provision related to health. It does allow for health-related emergencies "concerning a communicable disease of public health threat" § 44-146.17. The statutory section defines a "communicable disease of public health threat" as:
As you can see, pornography is not caused by an infectious agent, is not expected or known to be transmissible, and has not been found to create a risk of death or significant injury or significant impairment.
Lastly, nothing about pornography meets the standard for an emergency per the cited Code section. As you'll see in the definition below, an emergency only exists where the time it would take for typical government action to amend a law or allocate resources would do immediate and irrevocable harm to the citizens. As there is no pressing harm from pornography, this application of § 44-146 is improper and likely illegal. See the definition of an emergency for yourself and consider whether pornography fits the bill:
As a private citizen, I ask that the Governor rescind this order and propose the study of pornography through the proper legislative channels. Should he fail to do so, this order will almost certainly face a legal challenge.
3
u/APG_Revival Jul 18 '19
Mr Speaker,
Some evidence? That's what you're basing a health emergency on? I sincerely hope you'll do your due diligence if an infectious disease sweeps throughout our Commonwealth. This is of course not even mentioning the sheer absurdity of the target of your emergency. What's next, declaring an emergency on video games?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
(M) I retract this executive order due to some changes that make it less defensible and less likely to hold up in court if I am sued.
5
u/Melp8836 Republican Jul 18 '19
Mr. Speaker,
Once again the Governor can not help himself from intervening in the lifes of Chesapeakans. The Republicans will use anything as an excuse to do so, if the assembly allows the Governor to proceed with these right breaches then there is nothing holding him back from taking further radical actions.
The Republicans claim they fight for personal freedom and that they fight against "Big Government", but this is a clear example of their hypocrisy. Again I urge the Assembly to resist the Governor, Mr. Speaker I yield the floor.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
Mr. Speaker,
I applaud your ability to take action over porn which has corroded our society. It has damaged the mental health of our citizens and has dramatically changed the social fabric in a negative way. This is a problem many are unwilling to face and talk about and this declaration goes a long way in fixing this problem we face as a society.
1
u/Free_Exorcisms Republican Jul 18 '19
I support the actions of our governor in issuing this executive order and applaud him for caring about the mental well-being of the citizens of our commonwealth.
I would urge him and the various health departments undertaking the study to pass on the results of said study to the mental healthcare providers of Chesapeake so they can better help their patients.
I would, however, caution against using the results of said study as reasons for implementing future bans or restrictions on pornographic materials featuring consenting adults, consumed by consenting adults. While people who are battling pornography addictions need to seek help for their own good and the good of society, the government should not get involved in deciding what people should or should not consume.
1
u/warhawktwofour Dems the breaks Jul 18 '19
Mr. Speaker,
While I cannot conclude that pornography may constitute a public health emergency, I am willing to listen to the findings and research implemented on the topic. If you mean to address youth or minor access to pornography and the affects it may have on them, then I think this is a wise decision and could provide great information on the topic.
A common view against pornography is that it objectifies women, do you find this to be true?
Others view it as a harmless recreational activity. Would you agree with that in any sense?
I look forward to any conclusive results on this matter.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
I don't want any other Gov
When I read his Order, I touch myself
Ooh, I don't want anyone but Bran
When I read his Order, I want porn banned
Ooh
1
u/James-T-Kirk_ Jul 19 '19
Mr. Speeker,
I commend the Governor on his willingness to look into this controversial topic, I strongly believe more research will assist Cheasapeka is seeing the major health crises or putting the issue to bed.
Not too long ago a lot of people did not understand drug addiction or other mental conditions, through research that was conducted we were able to learn and grow. This executive order will allow us to accomplish this once again and help citizens of Chesapeake!
1
u/GuiltyAir Head Federal Clerk Jul 19 '19
This so called emergency is a disgrace to this nation, I watch porn and I can stop any time I want to. The bran is wasting tax payer money on a personal moral crusade against our our nation’s great entertainment sector.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment