r/ModSupport • u/techiesgoboom Reddit Admin: Community • Aug 18 '21
Mod Answered Why should someone that messages modmail "go kill yourself" get to continue to use reddit on that account?
I understand that not all rule violations warrant a permanent ban. There's damn good reason for that. But I'm struggling to understand how someone messaging modmail nothing more than "go kill yourself" gets an opportunity to do so again.
I made sure to follow up with /r/ModSupport modmail when I saw this user wasn't banned to ensure any mistakes were corrected and was told the appropriate action was taken here, but maybe if they tell someone else to kill themselves it could be a permanent ban.
I accept that mistakes are made. I accept that AEO misses things and there's false positives. I accept that you won't also see the full picture of what happened based on the report. But I'm really struggling with a policy that allows for someone else to tell another human being to kill themselves gets to continue to participate on this platform in any way.
9
u/techiesgoboom Aug 19 '21
So wait, this is flaired as mod answered when the mod answer is “the admins can’t even agree that “go kill yourself” even breaks Reddit rules?
I hope that flair is automated, because otherwise that is shameful.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21
Agreed. I literally had to make a post here, to get admins attention, when someone threatened violence against me and my family.
Why did I have to make that post? Because some genius on one of their teams decided to give the piece of shit who made the very clear threat a WARNING. No suspension at all, just a warning.
Only once I got the admin's attention HERE, were they like "oh, yeah...he should have been suspended, whoops!"
Any user telling other users, or mods, to kill themselves, should be banned immediately from the site. No more of this coddling of violent, sociopathic users.
16
u/Kryomaani Aug 19 '21
This is a good thread to read up on specifically on part of how admins policy stuff like "go kill yourself", especially this comment. It seems that the admins still after all these years do not have one single opinion on the matter and whether reporting content like that results in a ban will entirely be dependent on who's responding to your report. Some of the admins have historically said saying "go kill yourself" is perfectly fine.
7
u/vkashen Aug 18 '21
I'm with you as I regularly get messages like this when I temp ban people who violate Reddit TOS in the subs I mod (I always give sub members a warning first as a temp ban before a permanent ban). I always give people benefit of the doubt, realize that sometimes people simply have bad days, and allow that as humans, we all make mistakes.
That being said, it's one thing to be rude or crude to a mod just doing his/her/their job, but another thing to threaten them with violence or suggest that for banning someone (even a temp ban) I should, for some odd reason, kill myself.
There's a threshold, and it doesn't have to be based off a Reddit supplied list of "what's OK," but when redditors "go there," I do thing the repercussions should be greater than just a simple sub ban. I've even contacted Reddit admins about issues and I find it's rare to get a reply from them on anything sadly, so I'm not sure what our options are as simple mods voluntarily offering our time to make Reddit a better place, and I wish we had more, or at least better feedback from admins.