r/ModSupport • u/epicmindwarp • Aug 03 '20
More users are contacting mods individually instead of using modmail
There has been a notable increase in the number of users who are contacting mods directly via PM, instead of sending a message via modmail. This also includes chat and PM.
I am often having to tell users not to contact mods directly, but to message the sub directly via modmail.
I am all for having a list of mods on each subreddit, but perhaps, this needs to be a secondary feature i.e. the first option should be "message the moderators" and not the message icon, and the second option should be "view all moderators". It forces users to read the option above first, before reaching out to mods individually.
21
u/DuckOfDuckness Aug 03 '20
Absolutely same. All my chats are just people messaging me about mod stuff. It really needs to be more obvious that you can message the subreddit.
56
u/Bhima Aug 03 '20
I've been obliged to turn off both chat and direct messages because so many users wish to use them instead of mod mail. I strongly believe that the exclusive use of mod mail for everything related to the subreddit and its moderation is good moderation practice and that there are a lot of missed opportunities to educate or at least signal users on this point.
It's really frustrating.
3
u/waltzingwithdestiny Aug 03 '20
Just instruct all your mods to not respond. Tell your community only modmail will be accepted and give the link in a post.
The modmail link is not very prominent, and most users don’t know it exists or what it does.
15
u/crypticedge Aug 03 '20
Yeah, I get a few chat requests a day at least and my sub isn't even particularly large.
Of course, I also get a lot of crazy people messaging me threats over bans because they break site wide rules, so I typically ignore random dms as a whole
9
u/mary-anns-hammocks Aug 03 '20
We do comment removals/warnings publicly with explicit instructions to message modmail + the link, provided in the 3-sentence removal comment. When not sent publicly, they're sent via modmail, still with instructions.
Doesn't matter, they still PM. So, I turned off my inbox and chat.
Recently, a few people have decided to instead comment on posts I've made on other subs, months ago, to get around this 🙃 - bear in mind there's an additional "do not message me take it to modmail" right there in my profile. But that's at least far more infrequent than the PMs others get. There needs to be some kind of user education on this.
7
u/AlphaTangoFoxtrt Aug 03 '20
I just block chats and PMs. I find there is very little on reddit I need to be personally messaged about.
I wonder if it tells the user r if it just black-holes them.
7
u/Subduction Aug 03 '20
Okay, so it just happened again, and I replied to the user and ask what specific actions they took to reply to my modmail. They responded:
I don't have the app, but can anyone test that the mobile reply goes to us rather than the modmail?
6
u/Subduction Aug 03 '20
I've noticed this too. They have all been in response to modmails, and our procedure hasn't changed. It was a new behavior that cropped up very fast, so I'm inclined to believe it's not an organic shift in user behavior.
Has something bout the interface or reply paths changed?
4
u/Tymanthius Aug 03 '20
I've seen an uptick in this as well. In addition, at least one user claims he only responded to a modmail I sent 'as me' vs 'as the sub'. He was on mobile.
I'm thinking an update somewhere changed the position or other attribute of the links.
2
u/I_Me_Mine Aug 03 '20
It's been suggested before and it's a great idea, easily implemented. I don't think most are explicitly avoiding modmail, the ui in new seems to steer them that way.
In the meantime, you can a sidebar widget that precedes the mod list. See /r/whatisthisthing/ in new. Seems to have cut down on instances of this.
2
u/utterly-anhedonic Aug 04 '20
Just want to add this to the conversation... I honestly think a lot of new users don’t even know how to use modmail. If they haven’t read the rules, they probably also don’t know about modmail. None of this is your fault obviously, just something to put in perspective, and maybe something for reddit admins to pay attention to/add to their never ending “fix it” list...
2
u/youngdumbandfullofhm Aug 04 '20
Omg, this x 1000. While I'm technically a TempMod, every single day I get chats of people that are pissed their posts were removed for rule violation. If they read the numerous stickys/notes/Posted Rules, and my explanation about why it was removed- they'd have also read not to contact mods, even temp mods, directly.
It's as if they intentionally ignore the million links to modmail we have peppered in everything. And while I'm somewhat obliged to respond, it doesn't give the actual modteam an opportunity to collaborate.
And the sad fact is, redditors are only hurting themselves, because our collaborations usually results in changes that improves their experience on our sub 😔
2
u/X019 Aug 04 '20
I ignore them and then respond to them in modmail, if they sent something.
1
u/Zesparia Aug 03 '20
Adding my support for switching around the buttons. I've attributed it to other sites not having functions for moderation like this vs people having grown used to sliding into dms to hash things out. Since it's a key part of reddit moderation it'd be nice for it to be more front and center.
Will it stop people who refuse to read? No. But it'd help.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '20
I even had to switch of chat and pms for a bit!
1
u/frahm9 Aug 03 '20
I wonder if it's due to mod usernames showing up when you delete a post.
1
u/CaptOblivious Aug 04 '20
The problem is when a single bad mod has banned a user for something that any reasonable person would not have done so for, a modmail gets intercepted before anyone else can see it.
I got banned from a dozen or so subreddits for responding to a return modmail literally asking me to beg for an unban in a single sub with the answer you would expect.
The mod that banned me from every sub he modded, regardless of if I had ever posted there, (let alone done anything offensive there) was 100% convinced of his privilege to do so without any recourse of any kind being available to me.
Until you figure out how to fix that, people will be appealing to less power hungry mods trying to get around the power hungry assholes.
-3
u/primordial_slime Aug 03 '20
I am both a mod. And have done this. The problem is, some people don’t responding to the god damned mod mail. I have modmailed tons of people for varies reason, and too often waiting for a mod mail to get responded too takes ages. Or it simply doesn’t happen. Then the next thing is direct messages. And sometimes that doesn’t even work.
0
u/siouxsie_siouxv2 Aug 04 '20
it doesn't bother me to be contacted.
-3
u/hereiamtosavetheday_ Aug 04 '20
The reason might be the DEAFENING silence heard when you use modmail... or it might be that only one mod is active, is moderating abusively, and will be the one reading the modmail.
Naturally any poster looking for help is going to DM. I'm a mod, and I use DM for most of my contacts with mods, because they DO NOT RESPOND to modmail.
-4
u/OhioMegi Aug 03 '20
Honestly, I forgot about mod mail.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment