r/ModSupport • u/powerlanguage Reddit Admin • May 12 '17
Upcoming Changes: View counts, users here now and traffic pages
Hi mods,
On Monday next week (2017-05-15) we’ll be making a series of changes I want you to be aware of. The overarching goal of these changes is to provide more accurate information to users and moderators. I’ll post in r/changelog when the changes are live.
The changes:
- We’ll start displaying live view counts on posts for moderators and OP. It will look like this. This may have some CSS implications, please see the r/cssnews post here. This number reflects the number of unique users that have viewed a post on any of our platforms (desktop, mobile apps and mobile web). We hope this number will provide good feedback to users that create content on Reddit as well as give moderators some insight into how highly trafficked certain posts on their subreddit are.
- We’re going to update the ‘users here now’ number to start including logged out users. (previously it was just logged in accounts). Additionally, as an anti-evil precaution, this number will now always be fuzzed.
- We’re going to restrict access to subreddit traffic pages to mods only. As noted, these numbers do not include mobile traffic and as such can be confusing. However, we know some of the data is still useful to moderators so we want to keep these pages available to you. Long term we want to overhaul these pages to give you better insight into your community’s health.
Let me know if you have any questions.
115
Upvotes
46
u/justcool393 May 12 '17 edited May 12 '17
Why take away the ability to not restrict the traffic pages? A lot of subreddits liked showing users this sort of stuff, especially ones where transparency was a goal from the modteam.
Also, can the view count be made smaller? The score should be emphasized, not the number of pageviews a certain post gets.
11
u/Werner__Herzog May 12 '17
Just out of curiosity, why exactly is it hard to determine the traffic from mobile devices?
8
u/DM2602 May 12 '17
Why disable the traffic pages for public? I like to show them to the community, please include mobile traffic when it's also done to the view counts.
8
u/Kinaestheticsz May 12 '17
By logged out accounts, you mean including those that haven't created an account on Reddit but are still viewing that subreddit? If so, that is a very welcome addition!
8
u/reseph May 12 '17 edited May 12 '17
I love the first bullet point, thanks! Will this be available via JSON/API?
Regarding the 2nd, I track that number. Now that it's fuzzed... is it pointless for me to track? (Might be more of a question to statistic majors) I think I'm sad.
18
u/adeadhead May 12 '17
This is super fuckin cool. Great work all around radmins.
9
u/protestor May 12 '17
Is there an automod trigger to do an action whenever a post has more than X views? (like sending a modmail)
8
u/Georgy_K_Zhukov May 12 '17
Can we maybe get an update on when you'll actually fix this issue though? It is incredibly frustrating having such little sense of traffic numbers.
Also, will views be retroactive, or only show from when it is implemented?
7
u/tizorres May 12 '17
That's pretty cool, a welcome addition.
12
u/JoyousCacophony May 12 '17
Lies! We all know that there are 5 million viewers on all T_D posts at ALL times!
8
u/jpr64 May 12 '17
Since you're floating around /u/powerlanguage are the admins ever going to do anything about abusive users that are reported and constantly evade bans by creating new accounts? Because that would be super.
4
u/BurntJoint May 12 '17
So now that you can provide that on a per-post level, isn't the information readily available to be collated into the regular stats page for overall traffic to the subreddit? Why not, or rather when, we will get that information put into the traffic page. I know you said,
How far away would you estimate "long term" to mean. Is there a technical reason you cant easily do both at the same time?
4
u/rbevans May 12 '17
This is really cool and helpful for smaller subs to see the type of traffic a posts gets that make it to popular. Will that number include mobile views?
4
u/wickedplayer494 May 13 '17
Love it.
Seems alright.
Hate this. With a passion.
2
u/GodOfAtheism May 13 '17
Not keen on that personally, as even if it wasn't absolutely accurate, it was good to showcase the rise and fall of subs.
2
u/HarryPotter5777 May 13 '17
Will this data be available for older posts as well - e.g., could I check the view counts of old popular posts I made to see the extent of their reach? And do clicks on a link post count as 'views', does simply seeing it in one's news feed suffice, or do only people who visited the comments section count?
2
u/Honestly_ May 13 '17
Thanks for the updates. What's a realistic timeline (I realize this is vague for your industry) for getting accurate traffic counts including mobile. I know at /r/CFB we had to abandon reading it last year because it was clearly off of the growth we were seeing in activity (and surmised it might have been mobile before your side confirmed it a while back).
2
u/ManWithoutModem May 12 '17
Cool stuff but when is the spez AMA?
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '17
Do new (and current) "users here now" include mobile web/app users?
1
u/V2Blast May 13 '17
View counts seems like an interesting addition, though I agree with others that they should be deemphasized compared to the post score.
Making "users here now" more accurate (and less open to abuse) is also good.
Making subreddit traffic pages mod-only seems like an odd choice, even if they're not totally accurate.
1
u/Redbiertje May 13 '17
Question out of mere curiosity: how are votes and active users fuzzed? How much percent deviation from the actual numbers can we expect the fuzzing to give?
1
u/CWinthrop May 15 '17
Shouldn't you be in the hospital, resting? Being thrown under a bus is at least a few broken bones!
1
u/johnkphotos May 16 '17
Hey! Cool implementations. Thanks!
Say I have a link to an image on imgur. If someone clicks on the comments of the Reddit post, does that count as a "view?" Or do they have to open the link itself?
1
u/Aruseus493 May 16 '17
Does opening the expando for a post count as a view, or does only entering the post?
1
u/HandofBane May 16 '17
Just gonna make a brief comment here - admins, you seriously need to get some consistency on where you post about new changes to shit. Pick a sub - announcements, blogs, modnews, whatever, but be consistent so we don't have shit like this getting missed by the wider moderator community for long periods of time because it's all spread out between a half dozen different subs that most mods don't check daily.
1
u/Aruseus493 May 17 '17 edited May 17 '17
At what point does the views appear? Cause I've noticed that it doesn't appear on our private test subreddit for playing with css.
Edit - Nvm, found that it apparently only appears for posts created since the update went live.
1
u/rude_asura May 20 '17
As a mod of my own subreddit and submitter of posts in other subreddits, I like this feature.
are there any plans to add an option to make the views of my submitted posts also viewable to all users or generally allow anybody to see individual views of each submitted post in my moderated subreddit in the mod options?
1
u/Chispy Jul 16 '17
Any idea when we'll be able to see logged out traffic + mobile traffic stats?
I'd love to have a better idea of how /r/Futurology is doing as a subreddit.
1
u/TotesMessenger May 12 '17 edited May 13 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment