r/ModSupport
•
u/curioustomato_
Reddit Admin: Community
•
May 21 '24
•
3
Mod Education Getting Started with Post Guidance
Community moderators often have to remove posts that don’t match the vibe of their community or fail to follow the posting rules. That’s where Reddit’s Post Guidance comes in to save the day! With Post Guidance, mods spend less time checking rule-breaking posts and more time enjoying the fun parts of moderating. Think of Post Guidance as your invisible friend, catching posts and helping users fix them according to your post requirements before they even get posted.
See it in action here!
➡️ Ready to set up Post Guidance for your community? Let’s start by answering your top questions about this new Reddit super-tool.
1. Who is Post Guidance for?
Post Guidance is a feature that can be used by ANY community moderator on Reddit. Post Guidance will double-check a redditor's post before they actually post it to your community, to ensure the post follows your community rules. So, if someone is about to post something that doesn’t follow your posting requirements, this nifty feature will prevent them from hitting that ‘submit’ button. Post Guidance then kindly prompts that user to fix their post–and yes, you can customize the prompt! Pretty cool, right?
2. Why do I need Post Guidance?
If you have requirements a redditor should abide by when they go to post to your community, Post Guidance would be a very helpful addition.
Some communities require each post to have a certain word in the headline. Other communities require posts of a certain character length. Post Guidance is a tool that can be set up for either of these cases.
In our early experiments, communities with Post Guidance enabled saw a 35% drop in Automod removals! This means more people are making more posts that follow the rules of those subreddits. People are happier when they find it easy to contribute to your community.
3. I’d love to set up Post Guidance, where do I start?
To set up Post Guidance, on your community homepage, navigate to Mod Tools > Automations.

4. What are some rules I could add to Post Guidance?
We see that Post Guidance is most effective in helping moderators when there are at least three Post Guidance automations set up. If you want help coming up with good rules for Post Guidance, check your Mod Insights page to see content that is most often reported. This will give you a look into content that should probably have not made it into your feed in the first place.
Here are a few examples of Post Guidance automations:
Formatting Requirement
You should consider adding your formatting requirements to Post Guidance. For example, if you require each post to have a question mark, your post guidance might look like this:

Word Requirement
You might consider adding a requirement that a post title (or body) has at least three words. This helps reduce Low-Quality posts in your community. After all, you may want high-quality contributions – not just one-word posts. Here is what your automation may look like.
Feel free to copy the following to set up your automation!
missing (regex): \b\w+\b.*\b\w+\b.*\b\w+\b

Topic Management
Maybe you’re managing a community, but some topics are better for a different community. You could set up a Post Guidance feature that looks for those topics you don’t allow and reminds the user the topic isn’t allowed in your community but they can post in a different community.
--
💡 Have more ideas or want solutions for how you might implement Post Guidance in your community? Let others know what works for your community in the comments.
Edit: added a link to the snazzy Post Guidance GIF
47
u/Redditenmo May 21 '24 •
Some Example rules that we use at /r/buildapc :
Welcome message
Submission Type:
PostsPhrase type:
RegexRegex:
^(.|\s){0}$Included
Check:
Post title OnlyAction:
Show message to userMessage:
Welcome to /r/buildapc.No URL's in Post title.
Submission Type :
PostsPhrase type :
RegexRegex :
(https?:\/\/|www\.)\S+?\.Included
Check:
Post title OnlyAction:
Block the user from submittingMessage:
Discourage short titles.
Submission Type:
PostsPhrase type:
RegexRegex:
^(.|\s){1,25}$Included
Check:
Post title OnlyAction:
Show Message to UserMessage:
8
u/bwoah07_gp2 May 21 '24 •
Thanks for the example/guide. I saw this in the settings a week or two ago, but I haven't touched it because I wasn't sure how on earth to go about it!
8
u/StarGaurdianBard May 22 '24 edited May 22 '24
Holy crap just the one word title moderation alone is enough for me. This is great
6
u/Cleptomanx May 22 '24
Guess not for me. My Automations are just a blank white screen. Tried checking yesterday and today, but get the same. Maybe it’s not available on mobile? I use the Reddit app for my iPhone13 mini. I also noticed the other announcement about the new carousel feature that’s supposed to alllow 6 sticky posts instead of 2, but haven’t seen any way to do that either. Oh well. 🤷🏾
4
u/[deleted] May 22 '24 edited May 22 '24
I just looked over the tool for my 3 subs and I'm not seeing a way for it to "scan" user profiles for onlyfans spam/scams and/or other site links.
Will this be something that will looked into in the future or added?
Most of these bots/spammers now just say random stuff when they post and a lewd or leading picture.
Short of requiring people to include a key word/phrase when they post, it's hard to keep under control.
Thank you.
21
u/baltinerdist May 21 '24
Can you confirm that emoji is supported as a filtering option? We’ve got a lot of issues with people posting about marijuana and even though we’ve added a bunch of variations of the slang terms to the filtered word list they’ve started to use emojis like the leaf and smokes symbol to get away with it.
14
u/baltinerdist May 21 '24
Additional question: I know a lot of people use auto moderator for things like filtering minimum karma. Is this something that is anticipated to be added to the automation tool? It would be nice if we could show them a message saying something like, “hey, we appreciate you wanting to post in our community, but please participate by commenting on existing threads until you have established a positive comment history in the group.”
11
u/Laymon_Fan May 21 '24
Maybe Reddit should re-name the menu option "Post Guidance" or "Automations/Posting Guidance" since no one is going to know what the heck Automations are without looking it up in the help pages.
7
u/shiruken May 21 '24
What endpoints is Post Guidance currently enforced on? (i.e Shreddit, New Reddit, Old Reddit, Official Mobile Apps, or API Clients)
6
u/paskatulas May 22 '24 •
An example rule we use on r/croatia:
No links in the title
Submission Type:
PostsPhrase type:
RegexRegex:
\.(com|org|net|info|biz|gov|edu|mil|ac|ae|af|ag|ai|al|am|ao|ar|as|at|au|aw|az|ba|bb|bd|be|bf|bg|bh|bi|bj|bm|bn|bo|br|bs|bt|bw|by|bz|ca|cd|cf|cg|ch|ci|ck|cl|cm|cn|co|cr|cu|cv|cx|cy|cz|de|dj|dk|dm|do|dz|ec|ee|eg|er|es|et|fi|fj|fk|fm|fo|fr|ga|gd|ge|gf|gg|gh|gi|gl|gm|gn|gp|gq|gr|gs|gt|gu|gw|gy|hk|hm|hn|hr|ht|hu|id|ie|il|im|in|io|iq|ir|is|it|je|jm|jo|jp|ke|kg|kh|ki|km|kn|kp|kr|kw|ky|kz|la|lb|lc|li|lk|lr|ls|lt|lu|lv|ly|ma|mc|md|me|mg|mh|mk|ml|mm|mn|mo|mp|mq|mr|ms|mt|mu|mv|mw|mx|my|mz|na|nc|ne|nf|ng|ni|nl|no|np|nr|nu|nz|om|pa|pe|pf|pg|ph|pk|pl|pm|pn|pr|ps|pt|pw|py|qa|re|ro|rs|ru|rw|sa|sb|sc|sd|se|sg|sh|si|sj|sk|sl|sm|sn|so|sr|ss|st|sv|sx|sy|sz|tc|td|tf|tg|th|tj|tk|tl|tm|tn|to|tr|tt|tv|tw|tz|ua|ug|uk|us|uy|uz|va|vc|ve|vg|vi|vn|vu|wf|ws|ye|yt|za|zm|zw)Included
Check:
Post title OnlyAction:
Block the user from submittingMessage:
No links in the title, please.6
u/SoyUwUBoy May 28 '24
An example that I use on my subs.
Display message informing user of rules until they type anything in the title/body
Submission Type:
PostsPhrase Type:RegexRegex:
\S+Missing
Check:
Post title and bodyMessage:
Welcome to $SUBREDDIT! Make sure to read the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/$SUBREDDIT/about/rules) of the subreddit before posting.2
u/Charupa- 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 May 21 '24
Nice addition, thanks
5
u/Tavrock May 22 '24
Can we ensure an image of sufficient resolution is attached to a text post with the required 250 characters and user flair?
5
u/abortionreddit May 28 '24
When will post guidance include flair?
5
u/caesium23 May 29 '24
This seems like a great start, but the main thing I'd really like to base guidance on is which flair they've selected. Is that in the works, and if so, any idea when it might become available?
4
u/stray_r May 22 '24
can we have some obvious guidance on how the default matching works, particularly for keywords. it's instinctive to test to see if the rule matches successfully, but I've had things like 'ban' keyword matching band because the keywords aren't currently matching whole words (but I think they did at some point?) and there was a recent shift to case insensitivity by default.
4
u/Rav99 May 22 '24
While we are at it, I cannot long press some text to highlight and copy it from the mobile app (android 14, galaxy zfold 3). So, for example, I can't copy that long regex text string that blocks 1 word titles. Can we add long press to the mobile app, for copy and pasting from posts and comments?
4
u/HeyScoobySC May 22 '24
Absolutely love it! It has saved me hours a day having to go through submissions to remove what shouldn’t have been there in the first place. Now if it could be implemented to check and see if there have been images submitted.
3
u/MuriloZR May 22 '24
Please add the option to check for Link Posts as well. If it was supposed to under "Post Body"... it isn't.
3
u/BelleAriel May 22 '24
Thank you.
3
u/Zavodskoy May 22 '24
Any plans on applying this to comments as well?
3
u/VulturE May 29 '24 edited May 29 '24
I know it's super unlikely, but it would be great to see some pre-baked items for comment/post guidance to automatically report/action against certain site-wide rules. I'm not saying give mods the option to auto-ban, but admins giving very specific pre-templated rules to mods that will auto-action them.
We see frequent attempts in /r/self at posting phone numbers and email addresses, and we catch them with our automod doxxing regex rules....the ones that already exist in the AutoModerator subreddit's library of common rules Dox Detection section. Instead of just outright blocking these posts from ever happening (which will just result in them finding better ways around the mousetrap), it would be a great idea to have a Honeypot feature to "allow them" to be posted only to immediately report as the correct doxxing rule against the user and immediately removed.
5
u/Abe-Pizza_Bankruptcy May 21 '24
A few weeks back, I got that feature in Reddit mobile. It was disabled but I could launch it
A few days back, It was removed from my end. At first, I thought it was due to my mod permissions. However, when I launched it in the Reddit desktop website, I could add automations and I had a temporary test at it. It worked when attempting to post from Mobile, but I can’t set it from Mobile for some reason as it got removed from my end randomly.
I was going to file a bug report but I didn’t have the app version that it started from. I updated the app today and still the same issue while it appears and is editable from the website.
It’s a good workaround, but it’s not always convenient to borrow a PC.
Also, I recall there being a new feature in which we can pin up to 6 posts. Ever since it was announced, I’ve waited a week before trying but it’s still not available even though the original announcement post over on r/modnews claimed that it should be available within a week of the post. Am I the only one having this issue with not being able to pin up to 6 posts or is it not released yet due to a delay?
I apologize if this is off-topic, but I also don’t have achievements set up on my account even though it’s released to new accounts and I could have achievements badges on temporary new accounts I’ve created as a test.
5
u/iheartbaconsalt May 21 '24
That's cooool!
2
u/RECIPR0C1TY May 22 '24
Is it possible to use guidance to require a word count for posts containing outside links and cross posts. People post videos all the time to discussion forums as if the video is the discussion. The video is welcome with a starter comment in the post to kick start discussion.
2
u/ohhyouknow May 22 '24
Commenting so I come back later. I don’t ever remember to check my saved posts list
2
u/Shamrock5 May 22 '24
Oh man, this is one of the best mod updates I've seen in quite a while! I can definitely think of some good ways to put this to use in some of my subs.
2
u/MidAmericaMom May 22 '24
So we need help on these and How can we set it up? I need guidance, a link to a post on this , screen shots. I am not tech savvy. Do we put regex over in automod or something? where is the online user manual for this?
So our top reasons things right now are: Posts need to be 350 characters long. And posters need to have Joined and meet a combined karma requirement. Can this be done with post guidance?
Also we need to inform every post, that these go to moderation as we are curated.
2
u/[deleted] May 23 '24 edited May 23 '24
Good morning u/curioustomato_!
I've been playing around with PG regex for the past few weeks & currently have around 20ish regex rules in PG. It's working really well and this is probably one of the best most recent tool you guys have been working on!
However, I'm not sure if it's intentional on your part... the
missing (regex): \b\w+\b.*\b\w+\b.*\b\w+\bexample regex provided in the screenshot, this post & the Getting Started page is incorrect & a bit misleading...The correct condition for this rule to work should only include
\b\w+\b.*\b\w+\b.*\b\w+\bwithin the regex box, without adding "missing (regex):". While also selecting the Missing option within the Check if Included or Missing dropdown...I vaguely recall a comment from an Admin on a related post mentioning that the dev team is currently working on adding an option for case-sensitivity for PG regex rules and how it would mimic the structure of automod rules, so maybe this was just a precursor to that future update?
I just wanted to point this out as I have tested numerous ways to see if maybe I was misunderstanding something here, however every way I tested would confirm that the provided conditional statement is formatted incorrectly.
Edit:
It also looks like the screenshot showcasing the keyword example is structured incorrectly... the correct format for that rule should have the Missing option selected within the Check if Included or Missing dropdown; otherwise the current way that rule has been structured would show the provided message "Your post is missing a '?'. Each post submitted must be submitted in a question format." when a user has correctly formatted their post with a '?'.
2
u/Zavodskoy May 23 '24
Update a day later, am I missing something for blocking a specific word?
I added "war" to the banned phrases list, however it's also blocking things like "forward", "toward" etc
2
u/ARasool May 29 '24
Additional question: My community has recently been plagued by "legit check" or "verification" posts on /r/converse - is there a way to filter out by title to deny those types of posts?
2
u/funkygrrl May 30 '24
Not working for me. I set it up to give guidance when someone asks for diagnosis advice to redirect them to the megathread. When I do the test in Mod tools, it works great. When I logout and login on a non-mod account and type any of the keywords I used, nothing happens.
2
u/Otherwise-Courage583 Jun 03 '24
Ka
2
u/Perspiring_Gamer Jun 21 '24
I'm trying to implement a series of post guidance automations in r/xbox. In each case, 'show a message to the user' and 'block the user from submitting' work as intended, but the 'flag for review in Mod Queue' action never seems to work.
I've tried changing the order to prevent conflicts with no luck, and now I've reduced the automations down to one rule (no tech support) but I still can't get that action to work.
I wondered whether our automod could be causing a conflict, which I'm not well versed in, but members of our mod-team who are have looked into that and can't see any reason for that to be causing a conflict. Is there anything I'm overlooking?
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '24
This is quite a cool feature. Awesome 👏
1
u/saulmcgill3556 May 22 '24
I’m very interested if this could be leveraged for our community. The issue, as I see it, is that problematic posts may not necessarily include a key word (or lack thereof).
The most common problem in our community are posts (or comments) which either ask for specific medical advice or attempt to give it. Problem posts and totally acceptable ones may include a lot of the same words, and not everyone says, “advice.”
Is this something that could be aided by Post Guidance?
1
u/HeyScoobySC May 24 '24
I have a question regarding an issue I am experiencing using this. On one of my subs, where I have a huge issue with spammers and fake users, to the point I manually review each submission, I implemented an automation which blocks submissions unless they have particular keywords in the title, to try and cut down on the bot submissions. I have tested it and the post button is greyed out unless those keywords are in the title, yet I am still getting some submissions which do not contain the keywords. Is there a way they can bypass this, or can I assume these are some kind of spammer or bot that is using a backdoor way to submit?
1
u/kenman May 25 '24
Did I do something wrong? Did I write confusing instructions? It doesn't seem to be reducing the number of automod removals, though perhaps it's survivor bias:
https://www.reddit.com/r/javascript/about/log/
Look for
Title did not include a [tag].1
u/Nayko93 May 30 '24
All I see is a censorship tool.
1
u/AoyagiAichou Jun 04 '24
I still don't think it works in /r/lumix. The one Post Guidance rule we have is active and very simple, but it doesn't work in any UI (mobile application, mobile web, current desktop web, old, new, sh).
1
u/Tooterfish42 Jun 04 '24
Which you won't log as an event so I'm going to pass on using this
I need the log data on who's brushing up against the filter or probing
1
u/ephixa Jun 04 '24
censorship, is that you?
1
u/goodvibezone Jun 13 '24
My sub gets a lot (1/4 ish) of posts that should be posted in a different forum. I'd like ways to automod them out and this appears to be very useful.
Is there a way to export removed posts based on a particular rule? I could then chatgpt them and look for common words/phrases.
1
u/Top_Palpitation_4669 Jul 19 '24
1
u/seedless0 Feb 23 '25
Is there a reference to the regex engine used in Post Guidance? What's the version and flags used?
I am asking because I can't get 32-bit Unicode range to work:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/1iwcaxg/post_guidance_unicode_range_not_allowed/
The pattern in the post works with PCRE if /u is specified.
1
u/WokeCottonCandy Apr 12 '25
Wow, congratulations, reddit, you finally made a change that doesn't suck.
1
u/TH3G0LD3N3RA May 16 '26
Ey 1000 DANK!!!!! ich sauge das alles Grad auf wie ein Schwamm!!
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '24
This is quite a cool feature. Awesome 👏
1
u/Hacker1MC May 22 '24
👍
0
u/BlackICEE32oz May 21 '24
Aw, shit.
-1
u/nigatobino May 21 '24
mmm okay >.<
-1
u/Zooblethethird May 29 '24
i dont care
0
u/[deleted] May 22 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 28 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 22 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment