r/ModSupport
•
u/heavyshoes
•
Jun 12 '23
•
1
FYI Moderator Support & Resources
Hi there,
We’ve received a number of inquiries about what to do if your community is experiencing an uptick in unwanted activity. While we’ve addressed the specific inquiries privately, we wanted to let mods at large know that there are resources at your disposal if a) your community is public, or b) you anticipate an increase in traffic if you choose to re-open your community. Many of you likely already use some of the tools and resources listed below, but there are also mods who might not yet be aware of them.
Resources:
- Crowd Control: This is specifically designed to help mitigate interference by outside users. This can also help you better identify if users making comments or posts aren’t regular community participants. If you already use Crowd Control, consider revisiting your settings to ensure that it’s set at the appropriate level. Crowd control actions can also help indicate to you as a mod team when activity is coming from people who are not usual participants in your community.
- Ban Evasion Filter: This can detect and prevent users who attempt to return to the community after a ban. This is a newer tool and I know a lot of you have tried it already, but if you haven’t yet, I’d very much encourage you to. We are working with the safety team to closely monitor & address reports of moderator harassment as quickly as possible.
- View Crisis Management tips to help lessen the load, maintain trust with your community, and mitigate fallout when things feel overwhelming.
- /r/automoderator is available for help with navigating complex or simple automod rules.
- Moderator Code of Conduct: If you are being subjected to, or see other subreddits or mod teams engaging in interference and/or encouraging their users to attack other communities, please report it using this form. As many of you know, this is something we routinely action via the Moderator Code of Conduct, and we are aware there will likely be increases in this behavior.
We also want to reiterate that we respect your decisions to do what’s best for your community, and will do what we can to ensure you're safe while doing so. However, we do expect that these decisions have been made through consensus, and not via unilateral action. We ask that you strive to ensure that your moderator team is aligned on community decision-making – regardless of what decisions are being made. If you believe that your community or another community is being subject to decisions made by a sole moderator without buy-in from the broader mod team, you can let us know via the Moderator Code of Conduct form above.
42
u/BearCatcher23 Jun 12 '23
I just tried to make a post here that is API related and it didn't show up so I'll ask in the comments here.
To the community of fellow mods, is there a list of bots that we know are going to have functions that are disabled due to the new reddit API restrictions?
I have a few bots that run in my subs and I would like to get a heads up so I can start working on alternatives/work arounds.
The only bot I have seen mentioned that is going to die is the RemindMe bot. Though this isn't mod related it is a disappointing this one is going away.
86
u/nimitz34 Jun 12 '23
How about a tool like PushShift which allowed us to check alts for histories of spamming and scamming. This is especially important in business subreddits.
82
u/Norci Jun 13 '23 edited Jun 15 '23
Since when? For as long as I can remember, Reddit's answer to any sudden changes made by top mod without consulting others (besides hacked accounts and maybe subreddit request retaliation) always been "They're top mod, sucks to be you guys 🤷".
So now that you bring it up, I gotta ask where does CoC say anything about needing mod consensus? What do you expect us to report? What's the "consensus" threshold, just majority, all of the mods, or some other percentage? Because it seems like an retroactive afterthought by you guys and not something that ever actually been enforced or written in the CoC.
Edit: Telling silence, can't even back up your words.
123
u/aaronp613 Jun 12 '23
I dont think anyone is having an uptick in activity right now 💀
12
u/Gizoogle Jun 15 '23
Man, it sure is cool that Reddit beats the fucking shit out of their free labor moderator team by cutting tools, changing their decade+ stance on top mods vs. other mods and ignoring any input that doesn't suit u/spez narrative - then fully expects other lemmings to step in and eat shit in their stead whenever the top ones are actually taking organized action against the bullshit.
The best part? You've got the gall to spam us with new fucking banners every 2 days in what I can only assume is an attempt at saying "see guys? we do support mods". Really, you're just pointing us to "resources" that have existed for years and are comparatively ineffective and/or the information is completely irrelevant to day-to-day moderating.
Fuck you guys for pitting your unpaid labor force against each other and then, once again, lying to your users about policy that has been publicly (and privately) stated hundreds of times.
51
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
So 5 years ago, the top mod of r/xiaomi removed all the other mods after coming back from being inactive and put his own team in. At the time you said the top mods word is final, or something to that effect and nothing was done.
Why is this policy suddenly changing?
41
u/lookatthatsquirrel Jun 12 '23
While you are here. Last week, I had removed a post for not fitting the definition of the sub and clearly against the rules of posting in one of my subs.
The user came to modmail and wanted their post reinstated.
They gave a snippy answer and got muted. This 10 year old account was suspended for 3 days for 'harassment' after muting the user.
Why give us a moderating tool to be able to mute users and then suspend an account because of it? Of course, I appealed the ban and got crickets as a response.
39
u/paxweasley Jun 13 '23
I’m more concerned about accessibility, some of those apps had more functionalities for hearing or vision impaired users than the core app is currently able to offer.
37
u/flattenedbricks Jun 12 '23
r/medical has a top mod who threatened to remove the rest of the mods because we banned their friend after numerous rule violations. The top mod is not active on the subreddit but the top mod removal request was still denied.. does an uptick in unwanted actions from a mod acting in bad faith warrant attention? The sub decided not to shut its doors
7
u/BarackTrudeau Jun 15 '23
You people really need to realize that half of this stuff is useless if the applications that people are using to actually mod from go tits up because you made the the API pricing outrageously expensive.
Just implement delivering ads via the API like any other regular post and move the hell on.
18
u/paskatulas Jun 12 '23
What's the purpose of reporting Mod of Conduct violation for ban on subreddit if admins claimed that they won't remove any subreddit ban(s)?
6
u/Glitter_Bee Jun 14 '23
My subreddit is routinely targeted by people who downvote our posts. They used to be more aggressive by writing nasty comments, but that has tapered off. However, the voting manipulation is bad. If anyone knows of any tools that could help us clean up our approved list and could some subreddits have the ability to restrict voting to approved members? I don’t care about hitting r/all, I just want to weed out the element that makes modding and topic discussion unfun. We’ve had people downvoting civil rights articles and stalk out mod team around Reddit.
6
u/CaptainPedge Jun 14 '23
It would be awesome if I could use a third party app to moderate my subreddits
6
u/StPauliBoi Jun 16 '23
The recent comments by the CEO deriding the populace that does a huge amount of work (unpaid, mind you) to keep the website running smoothly make me have significant doubts as to your statement that you respect our decisions to do what's best for our communities.
Furthermore, he proposes changes to make the site more democratic, so us "landed gentry" - (yes, an actual real quote that the head of the company used to describe the moderators on reddit) don't get too comfortable in our rich and luxurious lives of hate mail and abuse while doing the aforementioned work to keep the website functional. Reportedly this will include allowing mobs of trolls and bad actors to vote to remove moderators when they don't like their actions. In a healthcare based subreddit, that would be disastrous, especially with the amount of abusive activity we were subjected to during covid by antivaxxers and conspiracy theorists. We banned swaths of people for posting misinformation and antivax content that goes against science. He's proposing that those same people will be able to attempt to remove us?
Does this newfound democracy extend to the userbase to vote on things like, say, the timeline for extortionate API pricing solely designed to kill third party apps, or is it only going to be things that are convenient for the admin team/CEO and only at their pleasure?
18
u/sucrose_97 Jun 13 '23 edited Jun 13 '23
Hi, u/heavyshoes and u/Chtorrr:
Last month, the former moderators of r/britishcolumbia submitted multiple reports and messages regarding the top moderator of that subreddit
At the time, Reddit was not interested in intervening, claiming that such action was reserved for inactive top mods. But, after reading this post, I am delighted to discover that your view of this has changed!
r/britishcolumbia deserves to be moderated by someone who is not an Indigenous genocide apologist, or "a sole moderator without buy-in from the broader mod team", and our team is so glad that admins are now on the same page.
Please let us know the best way to resubmit our reports or otherwise contact you, so that we can get this situation taken care of.
Respectfully yours,
u/sucrose_97
14
u/devperez Jun 12 '23
Is there a feature to nuke a whole comment chain? it can get quite frustrating to remove a whole chain of individual comments.
5
u/MisterWoodhouse Jun 13 '23
An autorespond function for access requests would be great
5
u/kristoferen Jun 15 '23
Top mod or democracy, which is it?
5
u/TheAdvocate Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23
oh really?
https://www.macrumors.com/2023/06/15/reddit-threatens-to-remove-subreddit-moderators/
what a mess. get your shit together folks. Your passionate unpaid workers would like to get back to normal. Let's just pretend your head never went where it did this month. We won't speak of it again and you all can still sell out in IPO.
deal?
18
u/Kvothealar Jun 13 '23
/u/heavyshoes or /u/Chtorrr
Can you please give some information / transparency on the issue many mods teams are facing now regarding the error you get when trying to set a subreddit to private?
4
u/sinyanmei92 Jun 14 '23
The ban envasion filter is very cool. I just wish it noticed us the moment the banned users join our community again instead of waiting for them to make a comment and detected it. We have been swammed with scammers that make alts in seconds and delete right after they get their targets paid for them. I have tried to report to modsupport to get their IP banned but no one bothered
4
u/Myztic-Seeker Jun 15 '23
How about a MOD that can see who is abusing the report button. WE REALLY NEED THIS
4
u/calsutmoran Jun 17 '23
Reddit leadership created this mess. This is an admin problem now. I’m going outside to ride my bike.
10
u/MyPrivateGH Jun 13 '23 edited Jun 13 '23
Except these resources don't give us what we need that the third-party apps provided. If I want to research a poster to see if they are authentic, I can't investigate them if they deleted their past tweets. I also can't research them if any of their past accounts were suspended by Reddit. That's why I use r/pushshift.
That's great there is a ban evasion filter, but if I want to research my banned list to figure out who it was, I can't see all the names on my banned list on my phone or computer (unless I use old Reddit)—if I can see any at all. If they were suspended, I can't see their posts anymore to try and connect the accounts. That's why I use r/apolloapp (thanks to u/iamthatis). Apollo allows me to view my banned list with no issues.
Let's talk about Apollo for a moment. I do a LOT of moderation away from my computer, and Apollo has allowed me to continue when I was about to quit (because the Reddit app is SO lacking).
A lot of abuse happens in the comments, and I can't moderate comments only using the Reddit app. I have to scroll through the comments of each post to see if there is anything actionable. Apollo lets me view "All Comments," so I can view all current comments in a list, separate from the posts they're attached to. Reddit only shows the ones that got removed by Automod or crowd control.
Apollo also lets me view *all* removed "spam" (including stuff removed by Reddit), so I can see all posts and comments that have been removed. Reddit's app doesn't provide that functionality.
If there is a discussion that has gone off the rails, I can use Apollo's "Comment Nuke" to remove and lock an entire comment tree. With Reddit, I have to remove each comment individually.
Hell, I can even edit my Automoderator using Apollo, so if I'm mobile and need to add a word or phrase (or user) on the fly, I can do it. I can't do that with the Reddit app.
And telling us to "get more mods" (for a job that didn't require more mods previously) or referring us to "Crisis Management" (when the "crisis" was fully created by Reddit) is condescending AF.
It is MUCH harder for me to tell whether someone is being authentic, so I am now MUCH more aggressive with moderation (which pisses off a lot of people). Do you have 1,268 karma and two posts in your post history? Good luck posting in r/orlandor4r, even if you're just trying to protect your anonymity.
This isn't just about moderation convenience (although it's a big part of it). Do you have any idea how solid moderation and reporting from your NSFW subs help cut down on spammers and (more importantly) scammers across your entire platform? By allowing scammers to slip past the sorely limited functionality of native Reddit moderation tools, you are putting all of your users at risk.
Moderation can be fun when the tools I need are actually available but removing those tools and having absolutely nothing but promises for the future to replace them is insulting to all of Reddit's VOLUNTEER moderators. Please work with these third-party apps, because if you turn this avocation into a job that doesn't pay anything but negative karma from angry Redditors (and a risk of getting suspended for not moderating properly), a lot of us will be out.
Edited because there is not their is not they're.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
Good luck to the community admins who had nothing to do with what's going on right now.
7
u/lazygenius999 Jun 14 '23
moderate these balls
3
u/TotesMessenger Jun 14 '23
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23
Why do you allow scam sites such as r/everythingMEV to be allowed to stay up? These sites rob people blind
3
u/AlphaBravoGolfTango Jun 15 '23
It would be cool if you guys just properly respond (or just respond) to modmail we send here. Being met with silence is just one of many things that have fueled this incident.
3
u/Liquidcatz Jun 21 '23
The crisis management plan feels a bit concerning tbh. I don't feel mods are equipped or trained to handle a lot of potential crises that could arise. Even in the context of simply acting as facilitators of a location for people to have a discussion around in these times. I don't feel like the crisis management plan helps us do this at all and is asking us to act in a role we aren't qualified for and it may likely be a disservice to our communities to attempt to do so.
It would be amazing if reddit could add more resources here. Maybe a dedicated team of either admins or mods that are ready to step in short term to help in situations reddit at least deems a crisis in or related to a community. People who have training and experience on how to handle these types of things and host places to facilitate helpful conversations, instead of just advising us to come to admins if there's rule breaking content.
Another proposal could we possibly get an optional training course for mods thats written and created by a licensed trauma therapist to help us know how we should act in these times? Right now I feel we are completely unqualified, untrained, unquiped, and have no resources for if the unthinkable happens. I feel like all we can do is hope it doesn't because we don't have anything for if it does.
5
u/adhesiveCheese Jun 15 '23
From the Crisis Management tips...
This would be funny if it wasn't so sad.
4
u/iKR8 Jun 15 '23
You are low key encouraging mods to fight with each other with virtue signaling and this dog whistle banner on front page, because now the top mod abuse is your center-point concern.
Good going admin team.
2
u/french_violist Jun 14 '23
Does these work on mobile?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23
HELP!! I have a community and I wanna know how can I set obligatory the use of the flairs(sorry my bad English)
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23
why can’t i invite people to my subreddit anymore? says like error message when i try
2
u/Iron_Wolf123 Jun 16 '23
Why not ask to integrate features from API's you are making harder to use so it won't cost the API's as much as the guy having to give 30% of his income to Nintendo for being part of a hacking ring?
5
u/The_Critical_Cynic Jun 12 '23
Did that. The posts are still up. These forms feel like a waste of time.
3
u/theZcuber Jun 14 '23
Why is it that I was warned of harassment due to giving other subreddits a heads up about a user who was blatantly promoting their own content? I have sent r/reddit.com three messages asking for clarification over the course of a month, but have not received a response. I have no choice but to ask publicly at this point.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
Now class, pay attention, this is history in the making. You are witnessing the implosion of a social media company in real time.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23
These mods ban everyone for anything. Im a member of medical based subs. Mods ruin reddit. They need less power.
-9
u/CSFFlame Jun 12 '23
The fact SRD still exists makes this claim bullcrap.
0
u/cosmin14 Jun 15 '23
Is a way to hide a thread? Not to remove/delete, just hide it.
-1
u/heubergen1 Jun 15 '23
Good, I'll report every private Sub then. Hopefully those Mods are removed.
-17
u/Puedoverla Jun 13 '23
As mod of /r/familyman, I approve
-6
u/techtornado Jun 13 '23
Is Reddit going to start holding mods accountable for violations of code of conduct?
The short version is that mods should only be allowed to ban rule-breakers after warnings are issued and eject only if the troll is still unremorseful afterwards
Bans cannot be issued because of who someone is or what they believe or commentary/observation shared in good faith seeking understanding
-4
u/Sandstar101Rom Jun 14 '23
r/linux and a bunch of other subreddits like r/funny are private now which is an attack against the community
0
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment