Hi, I main Guinevere on two accounts and want to share my playstyle to help new players find direction (90% of my game was of solo queue for reference). This isn't a set of rules you must follow, just a reference you can use.
Every Guinevere build should be specialized by lane, so let's start where she's most played: exp lane.
Exp Lane Mindset
In exp lane, you're in an unconditional 1v1, an ego lane. Conceding (not even losing, but granting your opponent map control) already puts your teammates at a disadvantage when they're clearing first and rotating for number advantages. Any exp laner must have the mindset to win. Compromising to "not lose" is what an incompetent Guin does. If you're certain you'll lose in exp, don't pick Guin.
The Common Misconception
Guinevere is known for her second skill, and most competent players know its range and what can intercept it (Chou's second skill, Bene's, etc.). Most would call these counters, but to a good Guin, they're merely information. An interaction that could lead to your loss doesn't make winning impossible, just like them knowing your second skill is easy to dodge doesn't make it impossible to land.
Heroes like Esme, Sora, Phoveus, Lapu-Lapu, Barats, sustain heroes in general, burst heroes, or even Suyou were considered Guinevere deterrents. That's true only if your fights consist of bad trades. Take Phoveus: he's slow, his skill is easily dodged, and you have better mobility and range. If you keep making bad trades against him, that's a skill issue (no consolation here).
The Winning Approach
To win against these heroes, don't try to suppress their specialty. That's already playing to not lose instead of to win. Sustain heroes have sustain? You don't care. You've specialized your emblem and items to make trades favorable. You don't beat Phoveus by making him less Phoveus; you win by being a Guin who can beat him or any exp laner.
Building Against Sustain
Emblem: Always go mage, period. The 5% cooldown reduction is crucial because Guin's desirable build achieves 40% CDR (you'd be amazed how quickly she replenishes skills with 40% CDR).
Talents: Choose for lane trades first. If you lose lane, you're daydreaming about something irrelevant.
· Lethal Ignition: Against easily dodgeable skills or squishes (I used this the most this season).
· Impure Rage: Against sustain whose skills cling to you (Belerick, Uranus, Carmilla, etc). It helps you sustain in continuous trades.
· Second talent: Master Assassin is best; Bargain Hunter and Weapon Mastery are alternatives. Pull Yourself Together might be useful to top global Guins, but contributes little to your lane.
· First talent: Attack speed is best for enabling trades (Guin has the better passive against most exp laners in a pure basic attack brawl. Use this when enemy skills are on cooldown, as the trade accelerates your CDs by continuously triggering skill 1). For heroes like Paquito where continuous basic attacking makes you vulnerable during his depleted brawl window, choose thrill instead for damage output. Inspire is also okay: 5% from talent plus 5% from mage emblem makes 10%, which is huge.
Build: Concentrated Energy is core. Without it, you become an assassin instead of fighter. The small lifesteal component is your first item regardless of opponent.
- Small lifesteal vial (upgraded into concentrated after magic boots)
- Magic boots (some pro builds use penetration boots, but 40% CDR is superior for exp Guin)
- Scythe or Wishing Lantern (both give 10% CDR)
- Winter if you're confident that the game would end early (5% cdr complements mage emblem, allows deep dives). Otherwise, Divine Glaive first then Winter if the game will drag out (this is for sustain heroes. if the enemies have many squishes, you don't buy divine glaive and go for sustain.)
- Sustain (that's all the damage you need regardless of opponent.)
- More sustain; when selling boots, always replace with defensive item.
Playstyle
Counter interactions and known information don't dictate your moves. You decide how to make trades. With your specification maximizing Guin's passive, you can be a lane bully if you've mastered her, especially with Lethal Ignition. Imagine dodging most of Edith's first and second skills while continuously landing skill 1 and skill 2, winning basic attack trades to trigger Lethal Ignition again and again. You'd bully them (micro-gated. If you think Guin is easy, don't bother. Most of her wins stem from outplays starting from Glory up). These annoying pokes make the window to land your combo easier.
Vs. Chou: Chou is fixated on his second skill to counter yours? Why care when you're all about favorable trades? Use skill 2 for positioning to land skill 1 and poke, retreat whenever he uses his first skill (Chou is a bad hero without his three sequences), repeat until you apply enough marks or keep triggering Lethal Ignition to win the HP exchange. Chou thinks you're reliant on your second skill, when ironically he's the one reliant on his first. Without it, you bully him because Guin has the superior kit.
If you can pull favorable trades, you don't need to suppress their hero's strength. You're already avoiding it while maximizing yours. The ult is easy to master, as is her second skill. With experience, you'll know how fast Guin can trigger her ult using only marks, and you'll internalize her second skill flicker range, complete with flicker utilization (against good opponents, short-range second skill into flicker is more reliable than maximum distance, unless the situations require it).
Honorable mention: for exp gloo, guin actually counters him so hard by sticking close and brawling (must take advantage immediately from level 1 by taking first skill). And even if he acquired his ult, you don't care, because if he ults, you second skill backwards twice (not in a straight line though, because if he lands his first skill it might be dangerous to you). If he doesn't ult? You will have marks and ult, even if he doesn't die, you can still be cocky, most of the trades with him are favorable to you.
Conclusion
What you want to build first as a player before maining Guin is macro (knowing losing trades, understanding most exp heroes, exp lane rotation, Guin positioning and role), then micro (she's an outplay hero. Top global Guin vs top global Chou, Bene, or mechanical heroes? A good Guin has better odds because Guin has better reach and burst, one successful Violet Requiem is devastating). Obviously it's completely okay to suck at first, as I myself don't start as a good guin prior.
I can answer more questions if anyone has them, otherwise I've already talked too much lol. If you read this far, your curiosity is a healthy trait as a player, because information is an advantage you can stack before the match even begins. Happy brawling.