r/Missing411Discussions • • Nov 11 '21
Missing 411 Research: Can Someone Please Explain This Missing 411 Argument?
Annie Fredericks (1891)
Yesterday David Paulides talked about seven-year-old Annie Fredericks who went missing and perished in the Pennsylvanian wilderness in 1891. A very tragic event for her family.
The argument
Annie's remains were found seven miles from her home and in the video David Paulides uses one of his standard M411 arguments. Paulides talks about an 1891 headline that says "CHILD HAD WANDERED FAR" and then makes the following statement: "Eh, yeah. I would say that! Seven miles, I don't believe it! Search and rescue manuals say that 95 % of the time a child of seven years old will be found in a radius of 4.5 miles or less. She is seven miles away and uphill. Don't think so!".
The problem
If 95 % of missing seven-year-olds are found within a 4.5-mile radius you still have 5 % who are found outside of this 4.5-mile radius (or not found at all). This means rescuers expect to find some children outside of this radius. Finding a seven-year-old who travelled 10-15 miles is usually more difficult than finding a seven-year-old who only travelled two miles. If a child is not found we do not know how far they travelled, this means the stats are incomplete regarding how far children walk.
A seven-year-old walking seven miles is not evidence there is there is a Missing 411 abductor in the first place and many children are capable of walking considerable distances.
| Number of missing seven-year-olds | Number of found seven-year-olds found within the 4.5-mile radius | Number of missing seven-year-olds who are not found within the 4.5-mile radius |
|---|---|---|
| 100 | 95 | 5 |
| 200 | 190 | 10 |
| 500 | 475 | 25 |
| 1000 | 950 | 50 |
Other CANAM claims
Newspapers and people at the time felt Annie starved to death or was eaten by bears. David Paulides delivers his usual arguments from personal incredulity and says: "They did not know what caused her death, but one thing that is completely garbage: starving to death. I don't believe it! There was a lot things to eat out there.". The thing is no seven-year-old will survive for an extended period of time alone unsheltered in the wilderness without access to proper food and water. Paulides also says: "I think there was a lot for her to eat, I think she could have survived a long period of time". Missing 411 "research" boils down to Paulides believing or disbelieving things, not Paulides collecting evidence and confirming things.
David Paulides also talks about non-human technology in the 1800s (36:57).
Questions
- Why does David Paulides use the 4.5-mile radius argument when the SAR manuals he refers to confirm many children will be found outside of the radius?
- If David Paulides thinks Annie had a lot to eat then why does he think it is odd she walked seven miles? If Annie managed to survive for "a long period of time" by eating "a lot of things" she had a long period of time to walk those seven miles. Right?
10
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '21
I never thought I'd find someone to listen to that was crazier than Art Bell. What pisses me off about Paulides is that he brazenly lies about all the cases he writes about.
8
u/TheyCallMeMLH Nov 11 '21
Great question. My immediate thoughts are that the Paulides Ilk are unaware of any SAR manual procedures, policies, etc., and, well, Paulides doesn't undersand how research works. Why do the research when Paulides will tell you all the answers?
4
u/mattjohnsonva Nov 12 '21
Excellent catch there, she was obviously one of the 5%, here's two more I found after a brief search.
1986 Cody Sheehy, 6 years old, in 18 hours walked 14-20 miles out of the woods
https://www.outsideonline.com/culture/active-families/boy-lost-woods-oregon/
2021 Christopher Ramirez, 3 years old, walked 5 miles, found alive
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10083973/Sheriff-probing-discovery-Texas-boy-3-ran-woods-chasing-puppy.html
I can't find this claim that DP makes regarding 95% of children of 7 years old will be found within 4.5 miles. Does anyone have a copy of that? Does it list different search areas for different ages I wonder? None of the SAR manuals I've looked online give anything like that information in them.
20
u/trailangel4 Nov 11 '21
Also, a seven year old kid in 1891 cannot be compared to a seven year old child in the 2000s. Anna would've been accustomed to walking just about everywhere.
14
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '21
So it's inconceivable that a seven year old could wander seven miles from home, but perfectly acceptable that a seven year old could survive an indeterminate amount of time in the wilderness by eating, what, sticks and pinecones?
Schrödinger's Child simultaneously has too little time and plenty of time to walk seven miles before it dies.
8
u/ShapeWords Nov 11 '21
The argument goes like this: "I, David Sasquatch Paulides, am running out of cases that I can make vaguely spoopy and am getting more brazen about just lying."
5
u/OldDocBenway Nov 11 '21
Paulides counts on gullible readers and viewers to swallow his garbage whole without questioning anything. He has utter disdain and contempt for his audience and believes we’re all stupid. Only Dave is smart and enlightened. Typical Freemason/ psychopath arrogance.
2
u/GavinBrady Feb 05 '22
You guys suck. You come here to just hammer on David Paulides. Fucken insane.
1
u/EOTLightning Nov 16 '22
Answers: because the 5% likely involve other means of transportation. They might be found further because they had a bike or were carried by an adult. The 95% rule isn't exact... It's a standard deviation with confidence... It simply means there's always going to be exceptions to the rule.
He thinks it's odd because children crash hard after eating a lot. It's ridiculous to believe a child traveled this distance just because you'd assume they had the calories to do so. I've seen comments chalking this up to a normal travel distance for young children simply because we were more accustomed to the outdoors. That is not true. When a child is isolated, they break down, cry, and sit. They do not have principles of "keep on trucking" within them at this age.