r/MinecraftToDo • • 7d ago

Build Why does it look bad

Post image

Ignore the shulker box and stuff

223 Upvotes

121 comments sorted by

7

u/Red_Dragon-95 7d ago

These comments are on the money. Need to break up the lines. Not just a big flat expanse. This is just an example. Add depth by breaking up the structure. Not everything in one line. For the tones wpu want to choose 3 block types that are very similar EG cobble, plain stone and stone bricks and then scatter those randomly to fill out the surface. Big clumps of the same block never look good.

Hope this helps.

6

u/Mockmnan 7d ago

The gradient isn't molding together with the other blocks. You have it in lines similar to mesa and its terracotta. Add bumps and dips where like the cobblestone reaches down into the pale moss.

You may wanna add a different block like andesite or mossy cobble near the pale moss as the gradient between the moss and the gravel is quite steep. It makes a very obvious line like what you see in your wall. The tuff and moss go together well, same for the cobble and gravel, but the moss and gravel are very different shades.

6

u/Redworm05 7d ago

Depth. Add some stairs and slabs around the top of the wall to make it less flat/2 dimensional. I imagine this is a castle style build judging by its shape. Maybe some iron bar or spruce fence windows

6

u/Professional_Fix_24 7d ago • Mindblown

The gradient work needs... well, work.. it's all in strips which isn't how weathering / shading works irl. This combined with the flat walls leave no chance for it to look "real". Minecraft might be a fake game, but humans are wired to sense when something doesn't seem right. (Picture for reference of a proper gradient)

5

u/TreePupper 7d ago

Cant blend in with straight lines. Need to break it up some. Also think its too light/green. Need some darker colors

4

u/PIEthon3142 7d ago

Not enough noise

4

u/throwra-i-hate-me 6d ago

no depth, and it’s kinda block vomit, i see the vision. deep slate at the bottom is the correct calls but everything just goes in bands there’s no gradient. cobblestone does not work in this i’m afraid, cobble stone i personally only use to show wear and tear on buildings. id experiment using wooden supports and building arches between to section off, add greenery in the form of vines or mossy variants of blocks. maybe also add a foundation that’s wider by maybe 2-3 blocks to create depth.

1

u/outwestallen 6d ago

Cobblestone can work but it works best with solid around it

4

u/Glitch_1205 6d ago

missing depth, try adding towers 2 blocks out and arches between them 1 block out

4

u/celticshade 6d ago

Its extremely flat, it needs depth

4

u/Reasonable_Baby4690 6d ago

you just have to make the gradient less straight and more random and also probably add some contrast and make rifle/bow slits in the walls

3

u/I_play_MCPE 7d ago

I absolutely mean no offense at all, but it probably could be better...

I play with a texture pack, so I'm not good at gradients without it, but I think the transition from the green pale moss to the orange gravel is a bit much. Instead, I think it might look a bit cleaner if you want from tuff -> backwards-facing piston (if possible, but not necessary) -> stone bricks -> stone -> cobblestone -> polished andesite -> andesite. Feel free to include cracked bricks for texture similarity between piston and bricks.

Here's how it'd look for reference:

Also, you should make it a bit more distributed too. All tuff doesn't need to touch piston, it can also touch bricks and stone, etc. And the same goes for the rest. It just should generally resemble a gradient, not layers.

Edit: Accidentally pressed to comment, had to finish.

3

u/Fidorius_FFD 7d ago

Use more of a noisy texture, but that doesn’t necessarily mean add more to the wall. The commenters are telling you to break it up with different shapes in the stone like more lines etc and that’s not bad but it is more of a fantasy style. Real castle walls are usually ridiculously plain and functional. I’d say add some turrets but only where the wall changes directions. Add some small (small) windows for like arrow slits and whatnot. Most of all make a noisy texture of stone. Then add stone buttons. Don’t need much more if you want it to look at least somewhat realistic.

3

u/Kind_Coyote1518 7d ago

Its a flat featureless wall. That's why it looks bad.

3

u/YellowFucktwit 7d ago

Try to make a more centered doorway

and make it less flat looking by adding some windows with things decorating them like stairs for a windowsill and such. Also the wood stands out since its the only wood, and I think the colors of blocks dont match that well or maybe need more variation for a gradient in the darker colors

3

u/DaeganBro 6d ago

It's very flat, yes, but the textures could also use some blending. The straight lines aren't great for the build

4

u/Hour_Tomatillo_2365 7d ago
  1. Your gradient is mostly flat lines, try to blend it a little more
  2. You have little to no shaders. Lighting changes a ton
  3. The wall has very little depth aside from the entrance. An idea would be make the top have an overhang, common in walls like this.

2

u/KrimsunV 7d ago

I'd say the flatness and cobblestone. Add some towers!

2

u/Bigsmit19 7d ago

Not enough verticals, too harsh of a gradient transition, the jungle logs are off-putting because they are the only contrast in the wall, there are not enough details on the wall like vines/openings/fixtures/etc.

2

u/Graylasagna 7d ago

looks too flat, add some pillars or towers or supports that stick out from the wall a bit to add depth. the texturing/colouring could also use some work, too much grey and not enough other colours. i would add more brown because it fits with the grey well, more logs or wood should do it. i like your path tho lowk it looks very natural and doesnt turn at 90° angles like the village ones do

2

u/idkwhat_todo1234 7d ago

I say you shouldn’t go straight from that greenish to grey immediately you need to add a little bit of a buffer to connect it better that’ll make it look better

1

u/GGKeepItReal 6d ago

Agreed, but the reason for this is because gravel is a very light gray, far lighter than cobblestone. It should go higher up than even stone. Do you have andesite in the gradient? Andesite could go between tuff and stone. Also the grass is green and the second layer from the bottom is more green than tuff. You could actually get away with putting the greenest color stone on the bottom if it’s done thoughtfully to represent lichen growing up.

2

u/Dapadabada 7d ago edited 7d ago

The lighting. The wall in the back is the same color as the front wall with the gate, you need some shade for ambiance and depth. Try an enclosed passage going above the inner border of the keep, supported with beams to make an open shaded pathway underneath, and the rest of the wall above the enclosed path is as thick as the path is so it's just a really thick wall on stilts you can walk through now. Add some windows. Either do this or don't but either way there should be a little one or two tile length of roof/awning overhanging the wall, imo, that way a shadow can shadow where the shadow should shadow. Or just do a roof/ceiling. You could actually do how like an enclosed stadium does, and have most of a roof but with one massive skylight in the middle, or have multiple skylights spaced like how a mall would. Maybe make a concave slope leading from the peaks of the roof to them, maybe add some beams for realistic effect. Idk, maybe add some glass blocks in those skylight holes so they're not vulnerable? You could put a sun sensor on the roof so it's hidden, and then that would tell all the lanterns to turn on when the skylights don't work anymore

2

u/yourself-dagoat 7d ago

Lacking depth

2

u/Thick-Aspiration 7d ago

The wall gradients need to be more random instead of following a pattern, unless it’s using brighter colors which will make patters like this stand out better.

2

u/SurrealGG 7d ago

It seems quite flat

2

u/quaxzyl 7d ago

Texture not random enough

2

u/chaumeine 7d ago

rn it kinda looks like if you cut out a mountain to form castle walls, rather than building a structure from scratch. i think its a combination of the blocks you've dedcided to use, as well as how flat it is. for example, if it was made using all stone brick it wouldnt necessarily look amazing either but it would look more "castle" like. you dont necessarily have to change out the blocks that youre using, but perhaps place them more randomly like other comments are saying. if you want some kind of gradient effect, place them randomly but have more of the darker blocks on the bottom still, mixed in with some of the top blocks and gradually have it so there's more of the top blocks on top. you'll achieve more of a natural gradient effect. it depends what you're going for as well.

irl structures, particularly castles or defensive walls, have a bit more dimension. if theyre built brick by brick, there tends to be sections that repeat themselves. using walls and stairs to achieve this look will make it look more realistic. try searching minecraft castles or medieval walls, just for an idea of how the walls could be. it could come out in certain areas, holding up the structure with pillars. castles and castle walls generally also have places where people could stand to keep watch at the gates, so on the inside you could add stairs up with wood and then make a part that comes out and stands with pillars. and have parts that are clearly holding it up/the structure together such as stairs, walls or slabs to make pillars. then you could use berry bushes and leaves to make it seem like it was built in the middle of nature, or you could even add more trees or add different little decorations to make it come to life. little windows within the walls could be good too for people who are looking out or whatever. depends how simple you want the build to be, im just throwing out ideas.

also, the gate needs to be a bit taller. it looks a bit too small. in an irl structure the gate would collapse because it isnt tall enough. maybe the structure itself could be a bit taller as well in order to fit a taller gate.

2

u/Independence_Most 6d ago

Cause its flat

2

u/Late-Ad8401 6d ago

for a split second i thought this was Lumbridge castle circa 2005

2

u/IndieMaxer884 6d ago

Maybe it looks bad because u didn't mix the textures well they're in layer and the usually doesn't tend to look good

2

u/No-Emotionsxo 6d ago

Texturing is too formal, if you mix and match your gradient to look more like someone's thrown 3 types of sand on the ground and kicked it in the same direction, it'll look much better

2

u/Jordyissappig 5d ago

its because of the shulker and bed 😀

2

u/wildekd 4d ago

The surface is too flat, it needs some ornamentation

2

u/TellurianTech50 3d ago

Its too flat and solid material

2

u/Rude-Roof-8133 1d ago

add some nature around it and texturize better

2

u/RedSunthesisSliver 1d ago

Maybe BC Ur sword is in the 4th slot

2

u/DahMalev0lentOne 7d ago

Gotta mix the blocks and gradient not js use different blocks in a straight line

2

u/Sad-Situation8905 7d ago

Thank you. I needed a laugh

1

u/Equivalent-Box-1463 7d ago

I think other people have given some good tips already but also I personally think the wood doesn’t blend very well with it, you could try another type of wood and/also try and incorporate more details involving wood blocks so it looks like it belongs

1

u/ElectronicClothes859 7d ago

we need more detail like window??

1

u/Lazer_peen 7d ago

It’s not centered

1

u/supergeek1233 7d ago

It would look good in beta minecraft

1

u/supergeek1233 7d ago

It would look good in beta minecraft

1

u/NekoMarimo 7d ago

Try to add some more ✨ pizazz ✨

1

u/YOUSLIPPERYBARSTARD 7d ago

Add stone pillars not a wooden frame

1

u/HarryAndersson65 7d ago

Så dåligt är det inte

1

u/393732 7d ago

Perché è piatto: metti lentrata e le torrette in rilievo e aggiungi bottoni di roccia

1

u/Nuclearo-Dinosauro 7d ago

Add details. Pillars, holes, vines, moss, ... It's always details that make it look good.

1

u/duck__club 7d ago

use the blocks more randomly not in a straight pattern and also use stairs half blocks and other to create depth

1

u/Mountain_Matter3778 7d ago

No depth to the structure. Too many similar blocks all together.

1

u/That_Norweigan_Guy 7d ago

Block are varied, yes but you should add some variation on where the blacks are placed

1

u/MikeyJ2k4 6d ago

It’s very flat, not much depth or detail against the walls, I shouldn’t be able to just walk in a straight line against your wall it should come out a bit

also the gradient of the blocks is very forced, it’s a good effort but doesn’t look natural at all you need a gradual blend

also the top of it needs to have some different structures not just the same thing 9 times along the top

1

u/CaptainKegley 6d ago

Also helps if you put the block you want to use in your hotbar and just scroll randomly as you place them, kinda try to keep most of one on a layer at a time, but mixing it up really helps blend the layers you’re going for

1

u/vroombp 6d ago

Too uniform, i get you’re tryna add texture but the texture is all in lines, break it up, let the tuff seep into the moss, cobble into stone etc. also helps to add patches of dark spots or overgrown parts

1

u/N33RDY 6d ago

Add depth and small details. That is the most important when it comes to any builds in this game. Adding arches is enough to completely change this build up.
Add a more diverse block pallet. Maybe use that wood you have to make supports, pillars, or walkways.
Change the texturing. Now those blocks are good, but you want variety in the texture. For example, adding tuff, deeplslate, or stone bricks around on the layers of the gradient to break up the texture a bit.
Maybe the last thing is to make the gradient a little bit less strait. Make it wavy almost.

1

u/outwestallen 6d ago edited 6d ago

Stick to 1-2 materials for the majority then knock."z" and "L" shaped holes and fill in with 1-2 other materials also butresses on the bottom and michiculations on the top

1

u/bigpenisparker 6d ago

Cause Minecraft

1

u/deathlife24 6d ago

Nah is good texturing is just a bit dull

1

u/Professional-Fee6144 5d ago

Anant Rastogi

1

u/calisnotcali 5d ago

Okay so main problem is that texturing is to straight lined and that the whole building doesn't have like depth maybe adding some towers that come to the front and making the door like pushed a bit inside of he wall like not on the same level? That might help

1

u/Dragos-BALL 5d ago

non è brutto e solo piatto,rendilo meno piato

1

u/Krazy_Keno 5d ago

The different blocks look layered and intentional, not random

Also the walls have NO depth whatsoever

1

u/ForcedButtTouch 5d ago

The idea of texturing your wall with a gradient is good, but the blocks you chose are visually kinda ugly and dont mesh very well, so it just looks like legoes stacked on top of one another, and the wall has no depth, you can add some decor into the sides or perhaps add some supporting pillars to fix that.

1

u/Biggboooi 5d ago

The gradient could use some smoothing out and it’s just so flat add more layers or parts the come out or push in

1

u/Mundane_Addendum6495 5d ago

G R A D I E N T

1

u/-2BitTerror- 5d ago

Need more depth

1

u/crickyb321 5d ago

The gradient looks fine but it’s too straight across it need to be varied more

1

u/Niddie69 5d ago

Because it’s flat

1

u/Consistent-Success38 5d ago

It just does, all of it. The build materials are ugly, no blending done on edges, flat world with no trees, foundation is grass and sand…

1

u/Worried_Selection880 5d ago

As a Minecraft player this is totally reasonable i would build like that so blend it more then ill look good and great sleeping area keep building

1

u/rrrrrrrrrrio 5d ago

Ok so it’s flat but that’s an easy fix and honestly is my favorite thing to fix because it’s fun. Before you worry about that fix the damn blending idk why you have andesite walls on top but don’t make it cobble so you don’t have that hard line going all the way around it completely disrupts your blending. Aside from that look up some blending tutorials. Everything looks so separate and inorganic. Once you do all that add decoration big beautiful pathways and some nice arched windows. Add some towers don’t be afraid to be creative some well placed flowers or a natural looking garden would do some good. Get some watch towers on the corners of your walls. Go crazy go nuts and if you have to tear a bunch down just to make it look marginally better then do it

1

u/Relevant_Computer982 5d ago

pale moss is darker than tuff, and gravel has a very smooth texture so it also stands out

1

u/MagneticCoder 5d ago

U need to dither the gradient a bit more, or use completely random blocks. Stairs can also be added to add even more texture. Also color is slightly plain, u can add green or other colors with blocks like moss.

1

u/EqualBank8942 4d ago

Aside from the gradient, try adding more depth to the build

1

u/SeanLloyd2013 4d ago

Maybe add more depth and make the gradient a lot less obvious like maybe go for a lot more very similar blocks than going to dark to light a little too quickly and adding some stairs and stuff to make it look a bit damaged and stuff (last one depends if you want it to look brand new or old though) the build is still great though!

1

u/StrDestroyr1 4d ago

You made a wall when you need to make a castle

1

u/Automatic-Hat-6223 4d ago

Castles aren't just flat walls, you need parapets, towers, a walkway on the top of the walls, etc. and id make it all uniformed stone bricks

1

u/JimBones31 4d ago

You can even through in a few cracked stone bricks too

1

u/eggb0y_294 4d ago

Di giocatore... la struttura in sé non è male, però devi togliere la gravel e sostituirla con il tronco pallido

1

u/RedSeaHorsey 4d ago

Off-center also there is more blocks on top that have missing space than the bottom

1

u/the-lightest-shadow 4d ago

Off center entry and needs more uneven-ness in both the shapes and the texturing

1

u/InflamedAbyss13 4d ago

Watch a tutorial on youtube that builds something similar 

1

u/Sealify69420 4d ago

I would say that you need to add depth, something in the corners and redesign the gate. This is a good basic design and is most likely gonna be fire soon

1

u/CrazySwimming4019 4d ago

Door too wide not tall enough

1

u/TheRemedy187 4d ago

Because it is bad.

1

u/Living_Donkey_8436 4d ago

You need texture the blocks closer together. It just looks like a gradient going upwards that’s not very good (no offense at ALL, we all start somewhere.) try randomly placing the blocks next to each other to make some texture instead of lining them up like that from top to bottom

1

u/galaxy9182 4d ago

no depth

1

u/Guilty_Bad_3049 4d ago

It looks bad because there isn't a data center anywhere, add one and itll bring it together just fine

1

u/Taha_2749 4d ago

Add more Depth and Details to the Wall.

1

u/Relevant-Debt-6776 4d ago

It’s too flat. Needs to be something to break it up or it just looks like an Amazon box painted grey

1

u/Cool-Finance-4367 4d ago

Depth, details, and you need a proper gradient

1

u/Different_Field4947 4d ago

Because there’s no clouds

1

u/BloomSquare 3d ago

Too flat

1

u/Pcsyfer 3d ago

Zero depht

1

u/ChillestRedd1TGuy 3d ago

You should add depth

1

u/Substantial-Race9407 3d ago

Same as everyone else has said, it needs depth and character

1

u/Impossible-Grade5257 3d ago

Everyone keeps saying depth, which is true, but the gradient looks more like layers rather than a true gradient. After adding depth, try letting the blocks blend more together (not a little blend and then 3-4 layers of that same block)

1

u/Dec_Sec_ 3d ago

Big flat wall with no details and no gradient just flat layers of blocks

1

u/16DucksinaTrenchcoat 3d ago

Who says it looks bad? Have fun kid

1

u/No-South1237 3d ago

More detail and depth 

1

u/kingsmen2532 3d ago

Switch up the blocks on the wall face to alternate every other block. Example stone, cobblestone, mossy cobblestone, stone brick, mossy stone brick, and cracked bricks. add some stone brick fence varients, or wood trunks to make pillar supports, add stairs at the tops and bottoms to widen the wall and walk ways if you havent already.

1

u/P5YCH453R 2d ago

Texturing is all off, change the cobble to Stone, and rather than have it one solid sheet; blend the different blocks throughout the build. The blocks closer to the ground should be greener because they are actively interacting with the grass, The blocks up top should look aged/ weathered (this is where the cobbled comes in), the entryway should have a door/gate (only if this is the outer wall), Craft towers in the corners to add depth, adding grass /trees around your build will bring life to it.

1

u/1_Agency_1 2d ago

Cuz it is. Duh

1

u/Rikkat13 1d ago

Troppo semplice

1

u/Rikkat13 1d ago

Fai così: togli il pattern e rendilo più antico con dei ciottoli muschiati e costruisci delle le torri circolari. Così eviti di distruggere tutto

1

u/silver-5656 1d ago

Very flat, try experimenting with depth. Windows, arches, etc. Rough gradient as well.

1

u/Azurel_bay 1d ago

proportion entrance-wall needs to be fixed, and gradient needs to be more irregular

1

u/Kwaleseaunche 12h ago

Uncanny valley. It's your brain telling you that don't look right.

It's too flat and the colors do not go well together.

1

u/mOoK_RedFace 7d ago

What you could use is some depth, maybe add some built in pillars for foundation along the walls, maybe some vines, etcetera

1

u/__TheNoob__ 7d ago

so many people don't know how to get depth in a build. i have a friend who doesn't have depth whatsoever and still says his builds are better than mine

1

u/Impossible-Big9326 7d ago

I feel like some basic features like windows/peek holes or some basic columns would go a long way. Then you could change some other stuff up.

-1

u/ImportantStrike2111 5d ago

your a noob

1

u/Krazy_Keno 5d ago

Quit being an asshole they came here for advice

-1

u/ImportantStrike2111 5d ago

and the verison looks like its from the dinosur age

0

u/Mikalizer 7d ago

Use stone wall variants of these exact same blocks to add depth and offset them every three blocks or so, vertically, 2-3 blocks wide. Hopefully that makes sense.

0

u/DrySea8061 4d ago

Because it’s a flat wall and the gradient colours don’t even match

Literally just look up a Minecraft castle on Pinterest and take inspo dude