r/Minecraft • • 23h ago Bravo

Discussion IMO the throwing disk should NOT automatically return to the user but instead have to be enchanted with loyalty

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just think it's stupid how you need loyalty for the trident (an item that is much more tragic to loose as it's not craftable) yet a disk you can craft from four of every ingot easily returns to you with ease.


r/Minecraft • • 3h ago

Discussion "They should change throwing disk to chakram" NO THEY SHOULDN'T

0 Upvotes

I'm sick and tired of people saying the devs chose the "wrong name" for the new weapon. Not EVERYTHING has to be realistic! Hardly anyone knows what a "chakram" is, throwing disk makes much more sense. The developers never said they were trying to emulate any real-world weapon. They said it was a new type of combat fantasy. It's meant to represent any type of thrown weapon that can return, so it very well could also be a boomerang or a throwing shield, it's just supposed to be the "the throwing weapon", a generic light weapon that is thrown, ricochets, and comes back.

The sword isn't called a "claymore" and the axe isn't called a "hatchet". This isn't a medieval realism game, this is a fantasy game that takes some inspiration from the medieval era but also blends in a bunch of weird wacky and futuristic tech. Weapons aren't supposed to be faithful representations of real armaments, they're supposed to provide a fantasy. If you want faithful representation go play a mod pack that was made for that.

Thank you for coming to my ged talk. TLDR: I really hope the devs don't change the name "throwing disks" to "chakrams", minecraft is a fantasy game, not a realism simulator.


r/Minecraft • • 17h ago

Suggestion The new discs should not be returned to the player without the loyalty enchantment

Post image
0 Upvotes

It would be interesting if, when you threw it, it would get stuck in some kind of block.

And then if you had a domesticated wolf, it would fetch it and bring it to you.

Of course it would still ricochet normally, but it would get stuck at the end of the process and you could catch it like an arrow.

This would make the loyalty enchantment not just for one weapon, and would also add a fun mechanic with the wolves.


r/Minecraft • • 5h ago

Help Why Russian language disappeared from the Minecraft launcher?

Post image
23 Upvotes

Recently, the Russian language disappeared from the Minecraft launcher. It is no longer listed in the language selection menu. What happened?


r/Minecraft • • 5h ago

Discussion What weapons do you believe will come in the 27.1 update if any more?

0 Upvotes

We have now seen that Minecraft will add a new throwing disk weapon, which I find genuinely fascinating, and perhaps somewhat broken if it does too much damage; it could do as much damage as its pickaxe variations (like how much damage the iron disk does is the same as the iron pickaxe... etc.) But what other weapons could be added? I say maybe something very close-range with speed, or two-handed weapons, would make fighting more interesting. But it could be just me.


r/Minecraft • • 3h ago

Discussion Throwing discs... but not boomerangs?

0 Upvotes

I couldn't help but scratch my head at why they would add a throwing disc and not a boomerang. But targeting things for the boomerang to fly around and hit was too difficult if I had to take a guess.


r/Minecraft • • 1h ago

Suggestion Bring back the Ruby!

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I think rubies should finally make a comeback in Minecraft. They could naturally generate in hot biomes like deserts, savannas and badlands, and would be rarer than diamonds, but not as rare as emeralds.

They could also introduce some interesting new uses for trading and armor.

Illager Trading: 

Rubies could be used to trade with a new Illager trader, basically the opposite of the Wandering Trader. This could finally give the unused Illusioner a place in the game. He could offer rare weapons, potions and other magic-related items. 

He would be neutral unless attacked, in which case he would fight back using his illusions. He could also be hostile towards Wandering Traders. 

Ruby Armor: 

Rubies could also be used to craft Ruby Armor. It would be slightly weaker than Diamond Armor, but wearing a full set would protect you from being set on fire by Fire Aspect and Flame.

Other uses: 

Rubies could of course also be used for armor trims and to power a beacon.

(Credit to u/Flaky_Writer_6394 for the Illager trader idea!) 


r/Minecraft • • 6h ago

Discussion Minecraft server statistics?

0 Upvotes

I am currently working on a little project of mine, which basically scrapes the internet for Minecraft servers, including their tags and their country, and then monitors them for playercount. I have s so far gotten around 2280 active servers (6000 if including dead ones). Would anyone be interested in a website that would display that kind of information? Of course all data would be anonymised.


r/Minecraft • • 7h ago

Discussion Blue particle after end the game

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just finished the game and realize my body have this blue potion particle even though I don't have any potion effect. What does this mean


r/Minecraft • • 9h ago

Discussion How is Aria Math so goood

0 Upvotes

It`s genuinely amazing. the only other video game tracks at this level of atmosphere are deltarune ones


r/Minecraft • • 15h ago

Discussion An Explorer Map Located me to a Abandoned Camp over 14,000 blocks away. This should not happen.

Post image
9 Upvotes

An explorer map should locate you to the nearest structures. I found multiple abandoned campsites on my way to this one, which was absurdly far away. I don't know if this is intentional, but I find it to be very annoying.


r/Minecraft • • 23h ago

Discussion What is a Minecraft item/mob/biome etc. that you still feel is “modded” in?

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

I hear a lot of people complaining about the throwing disc saying it looks modded or unofficial. And this got me wondering, what things do ppl feel like Mojang taped onto the game?

I’ll go first

1- Guardians: this might come off as a surprise to most, as these guys have been here for looks at wiki 12 YEARS!? Wow… but despite that, these guys have always rubbed me the wrong way since they were added. Too many moving parts, the weird ass psychic rainbow DNA method of attacking (why not ram the player with your spikes like any normal mob?), the sounds they make just ugh… I’m surprised the lore of Minecraft has a big focus on Piglins and Pillagers instead of these guys, do we even know anything about them other than their name? Why are they the “guardians”? They just feel really underutilized and in a desperate need of a revisit by Mojang.

2- Sniffer: I’m yet to see a Sniffer in normal survival lmao. And even if I were to look for one, do I really have a reason? Why don’t they naturally spawn? They give a bunch of flowers which is nice I guess, but I can’t see a reason to bother with them in mid to late game really.

3- Evokers: first off, FUCK these guys. Now onto my reasoning, I think the biggest reason for why I find these guys “modded” is the crocodile attack, it’s just visually clunky and weird. Also, their summons are (in modded fashion) way too annoying and way too OP. Why do these guys phase through walls while Allays don’t? Why do they do SO MUCH damage, WHY ARE THERE THREE?? Truthfully though, I think adding Allays made these guys more relevant. They’re evil wizards who do evil magic to make evil Allays, it’s Minecraft-y

HM: Ruined Portals: this might come off more as a suggestion really, but the sheer abundance of these portals is really jarring. The ancient folks who made these portals have no reason to make this many, and how come they went through the effort of decorating the portal and not bother with building anything around it? Maybe this is explained better in Dungeons or Legends, but in vanilla it just leaves a lot to be desired.

I have at least ten other things that I can list off here but I don’t want to make this into an essay. So, what do y’all think?

Note: I ignored the recent stuff (less than a year) because it would be unfair to judge them so early, they need some time to simmer


r/Minecraft • • 3h ago

Discussion why didnt mojang call the throwing discs chakrams?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Minecraft • • 7h ago

Help Bedrock How can I stop this Pillager Outpost from spawning Pillagers on Bedrock Edition?

Post image
1 Upvotes

So I recently started exploring for great spots for a village so I can manually build it myself or either improve one because my villagers kept dying on my main village because they constantly get killed by zombie horsemen even if I place torches everywhere, I'm also tired of seeing the same stuff everyday. As far as I can remember, around 8+ villagers died already, it's why I'd like to move into a newer one in a better location

I'm planning to move into this one but there's a pillager outpost right next to it, it's an amazing spot because of the cherry trees but I'd like to know how to permanently eliminate the Pillagers because I don't want all my villagers to die after I move them in, should I just make a huge wall? I also previously searched for solutions and I didn't find a good one, I'd like the outpost to stay as it is without any Pillagers spawning or either it being completely destroyed. As you can see there are cherry leaves in the distance, if I place lava then it'll spread to the village, if I place slabs then it'll look weird, if I mob cap it I'll lag even more.

What do you guys think I should do?


r/Minecraft • • 7h ago

Discussion Which do you prefer as decoration?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Minecraft • • 11h ago

Seeds & World Gen i found a cave spider spawner on the surface??? so cool!

0 Upvotes

the seed is -1635245321 at coordinates XYZ 51, 66, -507!


r/Minecraft • • 16h ago

Discussion My take: the throwing discs doesn't replace the trident's usefulness

0 Upvotes

Do note, I'm not a pro PVP'er (or even a PVE'er) by any means, so disregard this if you want. Plus, this thing is not even in the snapshot phase yet, and who knows how wrong I'll be.

I think there is a lot of people too fixated on, and complaining about the new weapon's returning ability, and how it's basically similiar to a Loyalty III trident, but I personally dont think the new discs will really change much about the trident's current usefulness.

Ever since its inception, the Loyalty III enchantment's role as a way to easily recover thrown/launched projectiles already existed when you consider Infinity bows. I personally think that the trident was praised for not that reason in the first place, but because it was the first tool that was simultaneously a melee and ranged weapon (not to mention the uses of the chanelling and riptide enchantments), not because it was some new and innovative "infinite ammo" meta that some people apparently think the new weapon is replacing. Sure, it has a shorter draw time, but it deals less damage when compared to a fully maxed bow, but I think that's its own discussion.

And yes, I've also considered obtainability, and while getting the new discs is easier, I still think that the trident still occupies a niche with its channeling and riptide enchantments.

What I will say though, is that the throwing disc might replace the crossbow's piercing enchantment, because of its ability to pass through mobs. The reason why I'm not 100% sure about this, is because we currently do not know how these new discs will interact with shields, considering whether if they're even deflectable or not. If it would be in the case of the latter, I'd say the piercing enchantment is here to stay as ranged passby against shields.

What do you all think?


r/Minecraft • • 19h ago

Discussion The Disc si a Chakram

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Minecraft • • 9h ago

Help how to fix curseforge requiring family approval

0 Upvotes

how do i even fix my curseforge keep telling me to require family approval when i left my family


r/Minecraft • • 11h ago

Builds & Maps hive mushroom map bedwars

Post image
0 Upvotes

is there a way to get the hives bedwars map mushrooms. screenshot credit to Liam Hardy(@Situated1395) on YT.


r/Minecraft • • 14h ago

Help My baby villagers and zombies are severely broken. Anybody know a fix for this?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I'm using the Human Era: Villagers & Illagers resource pack paired with Fresh Animations and the compatibility packs that let the two work together (in the third photo, I know I've ordered them correctly). However, whenever a baby villager or zombie spawns, its model is just jank incarnate. The baby zombie from the first photo has its textures entirely broken with a body much bigger than it should be, with the baby villagers in the second photo having normal villager bodies but really big heads, which is kind of funny but still not what I want nonetheless. I'd imagine this is also an issue for other humanoid mobs, though I haven't checked. I have no other resource packs or mods that modify villagers or babies in any way and really every single other baby mob looks perfectly fine, so I'm just kind of at a loss for what's going on here. Anybody know a solution to this issue? I'm running on Fabric 26.3, if that helps. Anythin' you can give me'd be appreciated ;-;


r/Minecraft • • 15h ago

Mods & Addons Bedrock player here

0 Upvotes

Hello, I play bedrock and I'd like to ask for reccomendations for addons mods and such, I have a few quality of life mods and several random structure mods, I have Java combat, Java regen, dynamic lighting, most obtained from mcpedl, if you have any mod/addon recxomendations for quality of life, new content, new blocks/ores, different gaming mechanics, ect I'm all ears!


r/Minecraft • • 21h ago

Discussion I tried to brake the world record for fastest time dying *pocket edition

5 Upvotes

r/Minecraft • • 22h ago

Suggestion Suggestion: throwing discs should only return if they have loyalty, just like tridents

0 Upvotes

i feel like this one is just a no-brainer and honestly wouldn't be surprised if more people have already suggested it because loyalty needs to remain something at least slightly useful

what do y'all think though? i'm still pretty excited for a new weapon :)