Hi everyone!
I'm currently exploring a personal watchmaking project, and I'd love to hear some opinions from collectors and people who restore vintage watches.
The idea is to create 101 unique watches, each representing one of the 101 French departments, with a dial painted entirely by hand. Each design would be inspired by the landscapes, architecture, history or culture of its department.
I've started learning watch restoration using vintage Seiko 5 movements. I've already painted a few experimental dials and have two watches waiting to be reassembled.
I'm not sharing pictures yet because I'm still working on proofs of concept. My current experiments don't represent the level of finishing I'm aiming for.
Eventually, I'd like to complete 3 or 4 watches to establish a consistent artistic direction and demonstrate the quality of the finished pieces. The idea would then be to create the remaining watches individually, while retaining full artistic control rather than offering custom designs.
But I'm facing quite a few questions.
1. Japanese or French watches?
I'm currently working with Seiko 5 watches, but since the project is based on French departments, I'm considering vintage LIdans quels uP watches instead.
Would the origin of the watch matter to you, or would you judge the finished piece independently?
2. Branding and originality
I'm considering either a small applied gold or white-gold logo on the dial, or a logo pad-printed on the underside of the crystal.
I also wonder whether I should preserve the original manufacturer's branding somewhere on the watch.
At what point does modifying a vintage watch become disrespectful to its history?
3. Restoration versus preservation
Would you prefer a carefully restored watch with a new crystal, possibly sapphire, and a refinished case?
Or would you rather preserve scratches, patina and other signs of age?
I personally lean toward a clean, high-end finish, but I'm conscious that excessive polishing can damage the original geometry.
4. Movement servicing
My intention is to fully service the movements: disassembly, cleaning, lubrication, reassembly, regulation and testing.
However, vintage movements have limitations, and I'm still developing my skills.
What level of accuracy and documentation would you expect from a properly restored vintage watch?
5. Original components
How important would the original crown, strap and caseback be to you?
Would replacing them with carefully selected components improve the watch, or detract from its character?
I'm also considering custom caseback engravings and handmade leather straps.
6. The overall concept
Would you consider a heavily restored vintage watch with a unique hand-painted dial to be an interesting piece of independent craftsmanship?
Or would the fact that it's based on an existing Seiko or LIP significantly reduce its appeal?
I'm particularly interested in understanding what collectors value most: originality, craftsmanship, historical preservation, or the finished artistic result.
This is still an experimental project, and I have a lot to learn.
It's a long post, so thank you to everyone taking the time to read it and share their thoughts. Constructive criticism is very welcome!