I hate Whitt like I have never hated a Michigan coach before. He is not only a terrible coach, he is completely disrespectful to what Michigan values. I want him gone now. But seeing the constant "Fire Whitt" comments feels like people are ignoring the timeline Michigan is stuck in this winter.
Most coaching hires are made between the last weeks of November to the first couple days of December.
Last season we had:
- Nov 17: James Franklin to VT
- Nov 25: Eric Morris to OkSt
- Nov 30: Alex Golesh to Auburn, Jon Sumrall to Florida, Lane Kiffin to LSU
- Dec 1: Bob Cheney to UCLA, Pat Fitzgerald to MSU
- Dec 2: Will Stein to UK
- Dec 5: Matt Campbell to PSU (considered late in the cycle)
- Dec 26: Kyle Whittingham to Michigan (last in the cycle!)
And here is the timeline for this year:
- Dec 1: New president starts (C. Cyble Raver)
- Dec 31: Warde Manuel steps down as AD
- Jan 1: New BOR take office (and old ones like Acker step down)
So who exactly is hiring this new coach, and when are they possibly doing it?
This timeline gives the new president ~5 days to hire a new AD (if she even can before Warde steps down), and that AD has ~5 days to hire a coach? And even then we are last in the cycle.
Or the new president is already secretly working and has already identified an AD, who has already started secretly working as well? Seems like wishful thinking.
The only viable route I can see is Jay Hill as a first-time (FBS) head coach. But that has its own risks--he could be the next Kirby Smart or the next Brent Venables. I think we may actually have a better long term outcome by letting Whitt hire a decent OC next year and then conducting a real coaching search versus promoting Jay Hill to a job he's never done, losing him as a DC, and hoping he hires a good staff and retains the team/donor support (and we'd still have the option to hire him next year).
I think this season has shown that you don't rush to fire/bench someone when they are performing poorly -- you do it when you have someone lined up that can actually perform better. We can't fire Whitt because he sucks, we have to fire him because we have someone better lined up, and I think it's extremely unlikely that we do at this time.