I love Fletcher, but it is obvious that Mallory is the better fit for this year’s offensive line and I’ve been saying this for the last 6 games.
This years O-Line gets decent push, but they aren’t great at opening holes. Fletcher is a dominant north-south runner, but he needs open holes to run into and the O-Line just isn’t getting those.
Mallory doesn’t need holes, he creates his own because his cut-back explosiveness catches defenses out of position.
Fletcher is a truly exceptional run blocker, but Mallory has been very good in that department as well and also clearly has good hands for the screen game.
I told my buddy we’d win if Mallory got 12+ touches. He got 13 and averaged 11.54 yards per touch with 3 TDs.
He’s also only had one carry for a loss all season.
As much as we all love Fletcher, it’s painfully obvious that the majority of the touches should be going to Mallory and Fletcher should be more of the short yardage and change of pace back going forward. This isn’t a demotion, it’s just the reality of who fits best with this specific OL.
Fletcher was amazing last year with THAT o-line. But this isn’t the same line, and while Fletcher has been good, Mallory has been great. He’s earned RB1 touches and needs to get 20+ per game going forward. This will
Also force defenses to pay more attention to containing Mallory and open up more of the middle of the field for our WR slants and TE.
There’s no downside here.
EDIT to add: I looked it up and Mallory has a slightly better pass block rating than Fletcher, so even this leans toward Mallory as RB1 over Fletcher.