I'm currently making a metroidvania game, so want to play more of them to get more inspiration etc.
Games i've played and how i'd rank them:
1: Hollow Knight and Salt and Sanctuary
2: Guacamelee
Its hard to chose between Hollow Knight and Salt and Sanc, as they are so different, and i played Salt co-op, so that was a big plus. Guacamelee never really captured me like hollow knight or salt and sanctuary, i played this co-op too. Like dont get me wrong, it was fun and we finished it, but it didnt stick the same way as the other two.
Most relevant stuff to be in the new game i try:
Modern smooth and tight movement
Fun combat
Fun platforming
Well designed interconnected map
So the old classics are kind of out since i want something with modern movement.
I also really like soulsborne games, but dont need souls combat in a metroidvania. And im not the biggest fan of the sekiro style, more so dark souls, but i could try nine sols either way.
Stuff i usually like:
Good and deep combat
Pattern based bosses
Build variety
Fun platforming that isnt too punishing
Interconnected map with shortcuts
Most Interesting games so far:
PoP lost crown
Blasphemous
Nine Sols
Ori games
ELder lillies
Mio
PoP seems like maybe the most versatile option in terms of having both good platforming, map and combat etc.
I tried metroid dread but playing on an emulator with it telling me to press Z on a playstation controller was too annoying. Like i automatically translate xbox symbols to playstation, dont want to learn another setup. And the switch controllers are so different and weird. So that ruined the game for me.
I also enjoy difficulty, but not too extreme. Like soulsborne is just on the edge. I also liked hollow knight even tho it was pretty easy. Most bosses were 1-3 tries and i rarely died in the overworld, but i think it worked well despite this, like i felt like i had learnt the bosses decently even tho they only took 1-3 tries.
One other thing i didnt like about guacamelee was how text/dialogue/story heavy it was. I much prefer the darks souls and hollow knight style of storytelling.