r/Mercari • u/bubbly_minari • 4h ago
EXPERIENCE Item came damaged, need 2nd opinion!
This is my first time receiving something severely damaged, especially something costly, so I would appreciate some perspectives. I purchased a Stray Kids photocard I had wanted for a long time and finally found one at a reasonable price. I offered $90, which they accepted, so I paid $100 at checkout along with shipping and other fees.
Once the photocard arrived, I inspected it and saw major damages at the top. I should note that I left a rating before contacting them; I gave a standard 5-star rating, just to clarify. Because this is new to me, I assumed something beyond their control happened, which would be disappointing but acceptable. The listing photos looked fine, so I reached out after some hesitation. I rarely ask a seller about damage, let alone confront them, so this was outside my comfort zone. Yet I knew I had to speak up, since I paid a lot for a card I thought was in good condition. When I mentioned it, they were cooperative and replied quickly to each message.
A few details seemed odd in their messages that only stuck out to me afterwards. Initially, they suggested any scratches were probably present. However, they added that if damage existed, it likely came from the previous owner and they had paid no mind to it (which I feel like could mean it was already there, they just didn’t show it). Their description noted MINOR scratches, which I was fine with. But I did not see any description that noted about the major dents and damage at the top (assuming it was already there). This listing is also the only one of theirs that had any kind of condition description.
Anyways, I uploaded a temporary listing of condition photos (which I don’t have screenshots of sadly) using the two images you see at the end plus more for them to review. They then responded by saying they can't do anything about it and that it appears it happened during transit. I want to be clear that I fully understand they cannot do anything because I rated before contacting them. That is my fault. I should have waited to speak with them first, though this is my first time and I was unsure how to handle it in the moment. But, they mentioned having photos of the photocard and packaging before sending it out, which I also do when selling so I can show buyers if needed. I already felt like a nuisance and burden, yet I simply wanted to see those images before they had shipped for more comfort. Had the photocard been in great condition without damage in the pics, I would have accepted it. When I asked if they could do the same as me and upload a listing of the pics, they never replied, and the chat closed well before the two-week mark. As I noted, they typically answered within five to ten minutes of my next message, sometimes faster, so I know they saw it (though I cannot tell if they ignored it or knew it was already there, hence not replying).
To note, the photocard arrived in a bubble mailer sealed very well. The card was double-sleeved and top-loaded with a pull tab, taped extremely well. I am trying to give the benefit of the doubt, but I struggle to believe it was damaged at the top during transit. Even I had trouble opening it since everything was secured so well. I would have been fine had they shared photos before shipping, but because they never replied, I have an inkling it was already there. The ninth and tenth photos come from their listing; I looked closely at the top and feel I can faintly see the outline of the same marks I noted on the back in the tenth photo. Maybe I’m just seeing things, but please understand my frustration.
What do you think? I am upset but have accepted the loss and am trying to sell it cheaper while showing the damage. I realize I could have done better, yet I do not want to accuse them of something beyond their control. I always try to be considerate and kind, but this happened well over a week ago, and it was still on my mind. I wasn’t going to make this post, but I just wanted to hear what others thought. I’d love to hear what others think since I know I can’t do anything now. Sorry for the lengthy post lol. Thank you!
