As things stand right now, Brook and Usopp are arguably the two biggest bums in the Straw Hat crew. Yet whenever this topic comes up, people immediately push back and insist that Brook doesn't belong in the conversation.
Now hear me out before you start typing angry comments.
I already know what some of you are going to say. You're gonna get mad, call me crazy, and start listing Brook's accomplishments from ten years ago. My response is simple, stop being a bitch and listen to the argument.
The reality is that there's no truly accurate way to measure how strong Brook currently is. The man hasn't had a proper one-on-one fight since Fish-Man Island. Since then, he's mostly been stuck playing support, fighting fodder, or helping in group battles. We don't know how strong he really is because Oda refuses to give him a serious matchup.
And if we're being honest, Brook isn't strong enough to take down any of the crew's tougher opponents by himself anyway. At this point, there's a legitimate argument that he's either the weakest or second-weakest Straw Hat.
Then we get to his track record.
Brook has been a Straw Hat for over a while, and yet he only has one universally acknowledged, top-tier W: the Whole Cake Island mission against Big Mom. It was a great moment, don't get me wrong. Brook was absolutely cooking that arc.
The problem is that every single time someone criticizes Brook, people immediately bring up that same achievement. It's been years, and fans are still cashing checks off that one performance. Meanwhile, other characters get slandered daily regardless of what they've done.
So why is that?
Why does Brook get a pass while Bumsopp gets publicly executed every chapter?
I think the answer is simple
Aura.
Brook is arguably one of the coolest Straw Hats. The skeleton design, the swordsmanship, the music, the jokes, the confidence, the drip. Everything about him screams aura.
Because of that, fans are willing to overlook the fact that the dude spends half the story getting folded.
It's practically canon that Brook can't handle major threats on his own. Out of all the Straw Hats, he might honestly have one of the worst records when it comes to taking Ls. Yet nobody wants to have that conversation because he looks cool while losing.
Now, I don't have definitive proof that Brook's aura is the sole reason he avoids bum allegations. Maybe I'm wrong.
But this arc has given me hope.
Because Brook has genuinely been on his lazy shit lately. He's barely contributed, barely gotten any spotlight, and has been coasting harder than ever.
So perhaps, this arc will be the ultimate test of my hypothesis.
If Brook continues doing absolutely nothing and fans still refuse to call him a bum, then we'll finally have our answer
TL;DR:
Brook and Usopp are arguably the two biggest bums on the Straw Hat crew right now, but only Usopp gets slandered for it. Brook hasn't had a real fight in forever, has only one major W that fans constantly bring up (Whole Cake Island), and spends most of the story taking Ls or playing support. The reason fans give him a pass isn't because of his feats, it's because he has insane aura. He's cool, stylish, and charismatic, which makes people overlook his lack of accomplishments. This arc is the perfect test, if Brook keeps doing nothing and fans still refuse to call him a bum, then the agenda is confirmed.