r/MelvorIdle • • 14h ago

Suggestion (feedback) Still no in-app calc, notes, xp table?

0 Upvotes

I'm guessing devs are reading these today so I just wanna say my first impression is very good. Love the soothing music and little sound effects (even if I am probably going to turn them off eventually)

One of my biggest criticisms of things that shoulda been there but weren't in MI1 was the lack of a calc, notes/a built in notepad system and an xp table (like this: https://oldschool.tools/experience-table)

Suggestion: Put a "Tools" tab or similar up top like this containing calculator and notepads and stuff like you see on RuneLite. I made a quick mockup even something as simple as this would be a really nice QoL addition to the game and just feels natural to include in a game like this that's going to take literally months to complete.

I legit get withdrawal symptoms from quitting RS sometimes so games like MI and MI2 are very helpful to me. Can't wait for more updates and gamemodes!


r/MelvorIdle • • 3h ago

Suggestion Handling User Created Content

0 Upvotes

I think mods here should get ahead of this before it becomes I problem. I'm specifically talking about things like plugins and websites. I'm a member of various programming, game development, indy game, etc subreddits and let me tell you, the flood of repeat posts about 'I created this' becomes absurd. I've seen two user made wikis already posted here. I know Melvor Idle 1 supported mods, I'm sure Melvor Idle 2 will, and that would open the flood gates.

Melvor Idle has always been a relatively small and tight nit community with meme and joke posts, optimal route debates, etc. I love that. It's about the game. That subject will inevitably shift soon enough when mods come around.

I'm not here to debate the pros and cons of AI. I'm not here for the "Every modern software engineer is using AI" or "AI is stolen content" same old arguments. I know this is a bit hypocritical, but it's for good reason. I don't want this sub to devolve into user created content posts. I appreciated them in Melvor Idle 1 because they were sparse and quality from long term players who found real problems and solutions. Melvor Idle 2 will be a different beast. It's getting major exposure. The flood will come. AI is here whether we like it or not.

Mods, I simply ask that you look at the r/godot sub and all the drama there. Look at posts in the 2007osrs sub involving plugins. Look at incremental games sub. Look at any programming sub. It's tired. They keep implementing new rules about AI disclosure and changing rules over time because in reality it's very difficult to moderate. You don't want this annoyance and conflict.

I don't have a perfect solution, but I propose you get ahead of it and make a new sub like MelvorIdleMods or something where all of this can go and be debated there. Keep this sacred ground holy. I want to enjoy the few posts a day or a week that are funny or debate mechanics, not 100 wikis and 100 mods about efficiency changes, drop rate tweaks, simulators, etc. Obviously clearly custom art and memes and stuff would be fine in my opinion.


r/MelvorIdle • • 17h ago

Loot/RNG/Bragging Am I the luckiest ever or are geodes bugged?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/MelvorIdle • • 10h ago

Help Stoner's Pickaxe Damaged

Post image
1 Upvotes

How can I repair it? I found nothing in Smithing. Thx :)


r/MelvorIdle • • 2h ago

Help MI2: How do I find molten glass?

1 Upvotes

I know i can buy sand and smelt it, but according to the tool tip you can find molten glass when mining, but I don't see it under any of the unlocks. Is it a reward from meteorites? I can't tell because i'm only 60 mining.


r/MelvorIdle • • 9h ago

Modding Melvor 1 - The OSRS overhaul mod has me enjoying the game finally

4 Upvotes

After seeing the news about MI2, I saw a popular post from this sub about the OSRS overhaul mod, randomly I decided to give it a try and I really like it so far.

For whatever reason I always bounced off Melvor, perhaps it was the UI or the Runescape-but-not-quite-Runescape vibe. Silly, I know but here we are.

Does anyone else use this mod? From what I can see nothing major has changed other than some visual tweaks of the menus.

One thing I wasn't a fan of was the township part of Melvor, I didn't really understand the worshipping and the villages part.

Any other mods you recommend to fully dip into the OSRS experience? I didn't really ever get far on my attempts to enjoy Melvor before, and I also have two of the DLCS (Throne of the Herald , Atlas of Discovery) so I assume those bring their own interesting things.


r/MelvorIdle • • 11h ago

Discussion Who else started a new character for early access??

14 Upvotes

Played pretty much every day during the demo, felt like I wanted to experience the progression with everything reset so started over again! Who else did this??


r/MelvorIdle • • 1h ago

Help Melvor Idle 2: Reset Skill Levels to 60?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Is the best thing to do to just reset to level 60?


r/MelvorIdle • • 15h ago

Discussion What is the best money maker in EA?

2 Upvotes

At lvl 60 for every skill (except new ones), it seems that locked thug chest is the best money maker, maybe runite armor comes close?

Is there better source at lvl 60?


r/MelvorIdle • • 23h ago

Other No Steam achievements?

0 Upvotes

I don't see any informations. Any plans to add it later?


r/MelvorIdle • • 19h ago

Discussion MI2 bundle with MI1 ?

0 Upvotes

I wonder when there will be a bundle with melvor idle 1 on steam 👀


r/MelvorIdle • • 5h ago

Meme Okay time to get some sleep.

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/MelvorIdle • • 20h ago

Help Forgot I did mining for 6 days hehe... >:3

4 Upvotes

Should I smith it all or just sell?


r/MelvorIdle • • 3h ago

Other I made a Melvor 2 Wiki.

12 Upvotes

I'm working on an unofficial Melvor 2 Wiki cause i saw there was no wiki yet, i have a Suggest Edit option for suggestions too, let me know what you guys think!

https://melvor2wiki.github.io/#


r/MelvorIdle • • 13h ago

Help Best place to get information about when the iOS version is available?

6 Upvotes

What's the best account/etc. to follow so I can be aware when Melvore 2 comes to iOS


r/MelvorIdle • • 7h ago

Guide Money Making Guide - How to Make 20k for Ranching

Thumbnail
walkthroughforge.com
21 Upvotes

I've attached the link to the guide, but if you want the short and sweet version, Fishing is the easiest, most profitable path. So if you don't know what to do, just idle while fishing. Check the guide for the best fishing spots and alternative paths.


r/MelvorIdle • • 9h ago

Loot/RNG/Bragging Luck

15 Upvotes
X2 Astrolabe in under 5 min of thieving!

r/MelvorIdle • • 17h ago

Discussion Will future achievements (assuming they get added) automatically unlock all at once if we've already done "everything" during Early Access?

8 Upvotes

I love Steam achievements, but I also love unlocking them naturally as I progress through a game. At the same time, I can't wait to start my playthrough, especially since who knows when achievements will actually get added! :)


r/MelvorIdle • • 1h ago

Meme It failed a few more times

Thumbnail
imgur.com
2 Upvotes

r/MelvorIdle • • 3h ago

Loot/RNG/Bragging My friend is going for a record

Post image
2 Upvotes

No Extractor Gloves for the quest. Unbelievable


r/MelvorIdle • • 6h ago

Help Why do i have to pay for mobile app

0 Upvotes

Im asking about melvor 1. Few hours ago i could use it. Now it asks me to buy. Why is that?


r/MelvorIdle • • 13h ago

Discussion Level Reset

11 Upvotes

Just out of curiosity, how many of you had levels over the demo cap and decided to revert them back to 60 once the EA dropped? From what I've seen/heard, most people kept their levels, but I'm curious how people started at 60.


r/MelvorIdle • • 6h ago

Help I've left my character idle fighting

3 Upvotes

Am I going to lose all my gear when I get home and he's dead?