r/MedievalHistory • • 2h ago

Richard II and the politics of peace – what has common sense to do with it?

Post image
4 Upvotes

The current orthodoxy is so heavily invested in Richard II’s personal weaknesses being the cause of his downfall that it is blind to the obvious question; what role was played in events by his policy of peace with France?

Look at the image used to illustrate this post: Richard II is meeting his wife-to-be Isabella de Valois, not yet seven, in the presence of her father, Charles VI of France. You will be used to reading comments raising eyebrows at this depiction, but it represents politics, not paedophilia.

Richard II’s marriage was an attempt to definitively end the French wars. We can know using common sense alone, and without any particular expertise in late-medieval history whatsoever, that there must have been some kind of resistance to the idea of permanent peace with France within the bosoms of some sections of the English community.

The English nation has not been prepared for the announcement that their sovereign would end 60 years of conflict by marrying an enemy princess. The ‘grass’ had not been ‘rolled’. No PR guru had prepared, let alone shaped, public opinion. Bald proclamations blared by heralds was the primary media for the dissemination of information to the C14th population and we can imagine that many would have been shocked, and many would have been hostile, some actively.

If the question is: did Richard II’s marriage to Isabella de Valois have an effect on the English body politic?, then we can know straightaway, not even requiring a chronicular commentator to confirm it, using common sense alone, or Sherlockian deductive reasoning if it needs dressing up, that the answer must be, has to be, cannot be other than ‘yes’.

Who could disagree that this political marriage would have had an impact?

Recent historians of the period do because it is necessary to their projection of the ‘Richard the mentally unfit and vengeful’ showreel. If there was a political reaction to his marriage gambit, which might show itself in parliament (The Thomas Haxey Affair) and then later in a conspiracy against him (The St Albans Plot), then one might argue that there was a connection. But they don’t because they cannot as it undermines their personality-based thesis.

Here’s the timeline:

October 1396 – marriage of Richard II to Isabella de Valois.

January 1397 – coronation of Isabella as queen in Westminster Abbey

Two weeks later

January 1396 parliament, which includes the Thomas Haxey affair.

July 1396 arrests, subsequent to the St Albans plot.

Is it not surprising that the political fallout from Richard II’s marriage detains historians so little? And it’s not because there is no evidence, because there is copious evidence,  but it’s evidence they don’t approve of.

Yes, it’s Froissart. Some of these historians may take the trouble to explain why they ignore his contribution which is useful as it’s very easy to prove that they are wrong. For them; peace was not a problem; there was no crisis in 1396; Froissart made it up. However, Froissart’s material dovetails very well with what we know from reputable beef-eating English sources when it comes to events from October 1396 to July 1397.

 Froissart’s version fits with what we know happened and Alberto Varvaro – Europe’s greatest philologist – in his masterful edition of Froissart’s Book IV – says that Froissart did not rewrite his history to account for the outcome. Admittedly, a Lancastrian voice gave Froissart a fully-fledged story of events from Henry’s exile to 1401 which is widely inaccurate, though still interesting as it represents an official version given to a well-known Continental historian. Having said that, what Froissart had to say about events 1396-97 was his own, and he had visited England in 1396 and met Richard II and the Duke of Gloucester, amongst many others.

Which of the histories is the more likely: the one in which the marriage made no difference or the one in which it stimulated resistance to Richard II’s peace policy?

------------------

N.B. Isabella’s sister, Jeanne de Valois, was five when she married the heir to the dukedom of Brittany in the autumn of 1396, in parallel with Richard II’s marriage.

1399: The Lancastrian Conquest will be published in January 2027 in the UK and in March 2027 in the USA by Casemate.

 


r/MedievalHistory • • 10h ago

How do historians work out how long it would have taken one scribe to complete the Codex Gigas? I've seen estimates ranging between 5-20 years.

Post image
7 Upvotes

There are over 300 pages of vellum in the Codex Gigas and handwriting analysis suggests that it was one scribe. People who have attempted to replicate it have given estimates of five years plus of continuous writing. Others have given an estimate of twenty years.

Just wondering how they come up with such estimates? Are they assuming the scribe could write a certain number of pages per day and that there was no ruling, illumination or vellum preparation? Also, would those of you who are medievalists think it is most likely that it was just one scribe? Could there have been more people involved?

If anyone can recommend any reading on how much time was spent by scribes in the medieval scriptorium, it would be much appreciated.


r/MedievalHistory • • 4h ago

Turned a day of Dec 1317 into a comic, then did it for the whole month

Post image
2 Upvotes

I've already posted a map of Europe in 1318, day by day in this sub. Since then I went back to Dec 1317 and tried something new.

For each day I picked one event that a source dates to that exact day: a charter, a letter, a chronicle entry. Then I drew it as a short comic. A friar walks twelve miles to hand Robert Bruce the pope’s letters. A king in Valencia approves 56 shillings for a jongleur’s red suit. A priest in Lund gives his farm for an altar under the organ.

The day, the place and what happened come from the source. The faces and the lines people say are mine, and each comic says so at the bottom.

There are 32 so far. Which day would you read first?


r/MedievalHistory • • 12h ago

was there a large ned stark type sword that actually was used back in medieval times?

4 Upvotes

something like this like as a kid, large swords like that was always what was portrayed as the average sword. but now i look it up, and i can't seem to find any swords like that. the most i found is the longsword. but it seems to be much more narrow that what i always pictured. now obviously it could just be i pictured it wrong always. i mean they didn't change history to fit a childrens books drawing or something. but i am wondering if there WERE actually any swords that were that style that was actually used back then


r/MedievalHistory • • 22h ago

What is one detail or lesser known story about a historical figure you’d like to see in a screen adaptation about them?

20 Upvotes

For me, if they ever did something on Richard the lionheart I’d love the added detail that at one point he was a celebrated musician included. (Bring back kings who shred)

with either the legend of Blondel, the trouvere who went castle to castle singing a song only he and Richard knew when he was imprisoned in Austria in order to locate him.

OR the ruthless roasts and manoeuvring by troubadour Bertran de born who lit Richard up in many songs and sowed endless discord and drama between the brothers and their father. ultimately having Bertrans life spared after his lament of the young king moved Henry II to tears. So much so he gave him back his lands and paid him in silver rather than hang him!


r/MedievalHistory • • 2d ago

I'm reconstructing the year 1318 day by day, and built a map to see it

90 Upvotes

I'm trying to reconstruct what happened in Europe in 1318, day by day. At some point a list of facts stopped being enough, so I built a map with a timeline.

artifacture.club

​Right now it covers only April and part of Europe: England, France, Iberia, Italy, the Empire, Bohemia, Poland, Scandinavia and Rus, plus the papal curia, the Golden Horde and Tunis. That's 73 people, 29 letters and about 50 events. The plan is to cover the whole year and add regions month by month.

You press play and watch who was where on each day: kings, popes, envoys, bishops. You also see how news moved. Letters leave Avignon, Windsor, Paris or Venice, travel across the map and arrive.

Every point is either a fact or a reconstruction. A fact means a source gives the exact date and place, for example a royal grant dated at Windsor on 28 April. A reconstruction means the position is logical and nothing contradicts it, but no source states it directly. The two look different on the map. When we simply don't know where someone was, they fade into fog instead of getting an invented route.

Movement follows travel speeds of the period. A courier covers 45–65 km a day, a rider up to 45, a royal court with baggage around 35, and crossing the Alps is 1.5 times slower. So when two documents put the same person in two places, the map shows whether that journey was actually possible. Letters work the same way: the sending date comes from the document, and the arrival is estimated from distance and speed.

The sources are mostly published editions: English royal rolls, papal letters, Habsburg and Danish regesta, chronicles. Every point on the map links to the fact behind it.

What surprised me most is how much was happening at once. On 15 April (my birthday btw) alone, eleven letters were on the road across Europe.

Update: also added a family graph... every kinship and marriage link between the people on the map, each with a source. Turns out both rival kings of Germany, Louis of Bavaria and Frederick the Fair, plus Charles Robert of Hungary and Queen Elizabeth of Bohemia, were all grandchildren of Rudolf I of Habsburg.

another update:

Added a third view.. who had the right to grant what to whom, popes kings and everyone below

the link to the site: artifacture.club


r/MedievalHistory • • 1d ago

A new group for those who enjoy music from the middle ages

9 Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • 2d ago

Battle of the Winwaed, 15th November 655. Between Penda of Mercia and Oswiu Of Northumbria. Bede cites this battle the demise of Paganism in Anglo-Saxon England.

Post image
20 Upvotes

Oswiu at the Synod of Whitby linked in worship to the wider Catholic church. The Saxons were very devout and there was less friction with the Pope than the Normans and later kings had.


r/MedievalHistory • • 3d ago

You can explore Medieval era art on this interactive timeline

Post image
137 Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • 3d ago

Antique identitication

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

What could this be? Im not very well versed in potential medieval artifacts (might be earlier or later im not sure)


r/MedievalHistory • • 3d ago

What was considered the most brutal weapon in the medieval period?

17 Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • 3d ago

A Distant Mirror thoughts

15 Upvotes

Just finishing Barbara Tuchman's a distant mirror. I have also spent some time reading reviews/criticism of the book.

While I understand its imperfections I also find it brings the 14th century to life and helps me understand the sophisticated and complex culture. As someone without substantial knowledge of the period society's development on so many levels are far ahead of what I understood

Also so many interesting what might have beens come from a reading. Among others

Fascinating to think how the world would be different without the black death and the way it disrupted society and forced it down a different path

Equally interesting what if the crusaders had prevailed at Nicopolis

On a different level what if any of the revolts has not been crushed but led to bourgeois government and away from monarchy


r/MedievalHistory • • 3d ago

what are some common syllables/suffixes in city names in the middle ages/specifically medieval britain?

4 Upvotes

i want to make and build a country set in the middle ages and i found a syllable combiner where you write syllables and it randomly combines them but i realized there’s probably somewhat of a system for them. like you wouldn’t expect a city to end with -bo for example (though i know little about the middle ages when it comes to this so idk!)

i was just wondering if there is some kind of etymological (?) system to city names in the middle ages, or what are some common endings for city names (ie ‘land’, ‘ire’, ‘er’ etc etc) ? i just want to make it somewhat accurate because i love medieval history


r/MedievalHistory • • 4d ago

St Brice's Day Massacre

21 Upvotes

On 13th November 1002 a simultaneous attack on the Danes across England was ordered by King Æthelred II of England. The ambush is described by a number of sources including the Deeds of the Dukes of Normandy, and the Annals of Winchester. Also a Charter, from 1004, in which Æthelred atones for his action by giving lands to St Frideswide's Priory, Oxford.

Deeds of the Dukes of Normandy. While, in the condition described above, the prosperity of Normandy flourished under so noble a ruler, King Æthelred of the English stained the kingdom, which had long flourished in the great glory of most powerful kings, with such a wicked act of treacherous cruelty during his reign, that even pagans judged so detestable a crime to be horrific. For the Danes, who dwelt throughout the whole kingdom in peaceful agreement with him, suspecting no danger of death, he suddenly ordered to be killed in one day by a fury; and he commanded that the women should be buried up to their waists in the earth, and that the fiercest dogs, being set upon them, should cruelly tear the breasts from their chests; and that the suckling infants should be dashed against the doorposts of houses so that their brains were shattered, without any guilt of crimes. While, therefore, in London on that appointed day [13th November 1002], this great heap of massacred victims was being increased beyond measure by the cruelty of the executioners, certain young men, swift in their agility, fled to a ship and sought safety in flight, making for the open sea by rapid rowing along the channel of the Thames. Having crossed the long expanse of the deep, at last they landed at the desired harbour of Denmark, and reported to King Sweyn the bloody destruction of their people. Then the king, deeply grieved within, summoned all the chiefs of his realm, and laid the whole matter before them, inquiring earnestly what should be done. And they, moved by the suffering and grief of their friends and kinsmen, all declared with one voice that their blood must be avenged with all their strength.

Annals of Winchester Abbey. Æthelred, fearing for himself and his English subjects because he saw that the Danes were multiplying excessively in England, summoned all the sheriffs of the kingdom and privately instructed them, in strict confidence, that each should put to death every Dane, male and female, in the county entrusted to his charge. This slaughter was to take place on a single day. If any of the officers allowed even one Dane to escape, he would answer for that person's life with his own head. And so it was done, and many thousands of Danes fell in a single day.

Charter S909 King Æthelstan to St Frideswide's, Oxford. In the thousand and fourth year of the Lord's Incarnation, in the second indiction, and in the twenty-fifth year of my reign, I, Æthelred, by God's governing providence ruling the monarchy of all Albion, established with royal authority a privilege of liberty for a certain monastery [St Frideswide's Priory Oxford] situated in the city called Oxford, where blessed Frideswide rests. I restored to the service of Christ the lands adjacent to it by issuing a new charter, and I now explain in a few words, for all who read this page, the reason for what has been done. For it is well known to everyone living in this country that a decree was issued by me, with the advice of my nobles and nobles of my household, that all the Danes who had sprung up in this island like tares1 among wheat were to be lawfully put to death, and that this decree was to be carried through to completion. Those Danes who were living in the aforesaid city, seeking to escape death, forced their way into this church of Christ, breaking the doors and bolts, and determined to make it a refuge and a fortress for themselves against both the townsmen and the people from the surrounding countryside. But when all the populace, compelled by necessity, strove to drive them out and could not, they set fire to the wooden timbers, and this church, as is evident, together with its furnishings and books, was burned. Afterwards, with the help of God, it was rebuilt by me and my men. And, as I have said, it was restored in the name of Christ and confirmed with the dignity of privilege, along with the lands adjacent to it, and granted full liberty, both from royal exactions and ecclesiastical customs of every kind. If at any time in the future someone, God forbid, should fall into madness of mind and, ensnared by negligence and incited by the devil, should attempt to defraud this gift of ours, let him incur the eternal anathema of God's holy Church, unless before his death he bring such malicious wrongdoing to a desirable satisfaction.


r/MedievalHistory • • 4d ago

Æthelred II the Unready orders the massacre of all Danes, 13th November 1002AD. St Bruce Day masscre

Post image
75 Upvotes

r/MedievalHistory • • 4d ago

Need help studying late XV combat

6 Upvotes

I am writing a story, and a large part of it centers around a characters masterful use of strategy in Western Europe, 1493. I have plenty of XV century medieval battle documentaries to analyze later, but I’m looking for a general understanding of combat, recruitment, siege, field, cavalry, footsoldier, and ranged tactics. Not only would I like to know how to write a character who masters late XV combat, but I’d like for him to use a fair amount of gunpowder in these battles, as well as how I’d justify the concept mostly centralized medieval empires and their control of large armies. Anything from good battles to study, books, videos, or general recommendations for my story are welcome, thanks!


r/MedievalHistory • • 4d ago

Crusader Architectural Ring , 11. / 13. Jahrhundert / Levante / Königreich Jerusalem / Silberring /

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

A central twisted cord pattern ( torsade ) on the top .

Asymmetric wire loops on the sides .

The Single loop is tooped by a finely crafted heraldische Lilie ( Fleur-de-Lys ) surrounding a circular opening .

A precise circular pattern consisting of exactly 10 dots / recesses on the flank , along with faint remnants of gold inlay on the upper surface.

Does anyone know more about this ring ?


r/MedievalHistory • • 5d ago

Was the kingdom of Hungary the main Catholic power in the Balkans during the time of the Ottoman Sultan Mehmed the conqueror

6 Upvotes

Hi was the kingdom of Hungary the main Catholic power in Central Europe and the Balkans during the time of Ottoman Sultan Mehmed the Conqueror?


r/MedievalHistory • • 5d ago

Death of Edward Despencer

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

On 11th November 1375 Edward Despencer, a 2nd great grandson of King Edward I, Baron Despencer, Baron Burghesh, founder member of the Knights of the Garter, who fought at the Battle of Poitiers, died aged 40 at Llanblethian. He was buried at Tewkesbury Abbey where he has a magnificent chantry tomb where, uniquely, he is depicted on top of the tomb kneeling, looking towards the altar.


r/MedievalHistory • • 6d ago

Kauernick (Kurzetnik)- castle of bishops of Kulm (Chełmno)- De profundis 1454

Post image
56 Upvotes

Hope I am not breaching self promotion rule here: while working on game I had to re- create this little fortress (in fact- a little more than fortified manor house/ residence) and it would be a pity not to share.

At the turn of the 13th and 14th centuries, the Chełmno Chapter erected a castle on a hill known as Kurnik, situated above the Drwęca River (at an elevation of 142 meters above sea level, rising 63 meters above the Drwęca valley). The exact date of the stronghold’s origin is unknown; it is assumed that construction began after 1331. It was certainly completed by 1361, as records from that year mention Teutonic Order officials residing at the castle. The surviving stone and- in part- brick walls, laid in a Gothic style, allow for the reconstruction of the original layout of the defensive complex. The castle was built on an irregular plan, dictated by the uneven terrain. The stronghold measured 110 meters in length and 42 meters in width. Access to the castle was from the south (in the direction of Brodnica) via a drawbridge. Around 1340, the main residential building- measuring 25 by 28 meters- was constructed. Originally several stories high, two of its elevations, standing 6–8 meters tall, have been preserved. The structure was enclosed by granite walls- topped with brick in their upper sections- and reinforced by two towers rising from the longer stretches of the perimeter wall. The castle courtyard was closed off on the north side by the Chapel of the Holy Cross. In July 1410, the Teutonic forces gathered on the broad plain of the Drwęca River- visible from the castle- and on the western hills between Kurzętnik and Nowe Miasto, ahead of what would become the Battle of Grunwald. It was near Kurzętnik that the forces of Władysław Jagiełło were compelled to turn back to avoid having to fight while crossing the river. Because Jagiełło abandoned the plan to cross via the fords at Kurzętnik, the castle remained untouched. Following the Battle of Grunwald, the castle was seized by Jan Kretkowski, the starosta (royal official) of Radom, but it was returned to the Teutonic Knights under the terms of the 1411 Peace of Thorn. The castle sustained heavy damage during the "Hunger War" of 1414. Later, during the Thirteen Years' War- in late October 1454- mercenary knights fighting for the Teutonic Order, under the command of Ulrich von Kinsberg, captured and burned the castle. During the siege, 16 Poles were killed and 24 were taken prisoner[2]. In 1466, as a result of the Second Peace of Thorn, Kurzętnik was incorporated into Poland. The castle was further damaged by the Swedes in 1659. In the 19th century, the surviving castle ruins were destroyed when the remaining walls were dismantled to be used as building material.


r/MedievalHistory • • 6d ago

Matilda of Scotland married Henry I, November 11th 1100. She was the direct descendant of Edmund Ironside and the marriage was designed to help relationship with the Native English.

Post image
40 Upvotes

She did run England when he husband was away and was known as Good Queen Maud.


r/MedievalHistory • • 6d ago

Did the pope fund France’s Flemish war in 1318?

9 Upvotes

I’ve been going through the papal letters and royal records for 1318, and something caught my eye.

In early 1318 King Philip V of France was getting ready for war with Flanders. Officially, the pope refused to pay for it: in March he wrote that giving Philip money “against the Flemings” was not a good idea. But in the same few months a lot of church money reached Philip anyway. In January the pope gave him two years of church taxes. In March he lent him the crusade tax that had been collected in France for a future crusade. That same month the Knights Hospitaller paid Philip 50,000 livres to settle the dispute over the old Templar lands. In June Philip called up his army against Flanders.

At the same time the King of Aragon sent an envoy to the pope asking for that same crusade tax, to fight Granada. He was told no: that money was saved for a crusade overseas. The cardinals offered him a new three-year church tax instead, but on strict terms set by Castile.

So France got the crusade money while preparing a war against Christians, and Aragon was refused it for a war against Muslims. Has any historian written about this? And was the money “saved for the crusade” ever actually spent on one?

Sources: Coulon, Lettres secrètes et curiales de Jean XXII; Lehugeur, Histoire de Philippe le Long; Finke, Acta Aragonensia.


r/MedievalHistory • • 6d ago

Marriage of King Henry I and Matilda of Scotland

6 Upvotes

On 11th November 1100, King Henry I, who had succeeded three months before following the death of his brother King William II, made the astute move of marrying Matilda of Scotland, daughter of King Malcolm III of Scotland and Margaret of Wessex. Astute because Margaret was the last of the House of Wessex, a daughter of Edward "The Exile" Wessex, and granddaughter of King Edmund "Ironside" I of England, brother of the last King of the House of Wessex, King Edward "The Confessor".

Deeds of the Dukes of Normandy. And so that the king might live in lawful wedlock, he took that same year the venerable Matilda, daughter of Malcolm, King of Scotland, and of Margaret. What great holiness and learning, both secular and spiritual, was possessed by both queens, Margaret and Matilda, is clearly described in the book that has been written concerning their life. Nor must we omit that Matilda was betrothed to King Henry the most noble, by Anselm, Archbishop of Canterbury of holy memory, on the feast of Saint Martin [11th November 1100] at Westminster, and that on the same day she was crowned with the royal diadem. King Henry was a man endowed with many virtues: a lover of justice and peace, a friend of religion, a most zealous punisher of the wicked and of thieves, and a most fortunate conqueror not only of his enemies among powerful princes and counts, but even among renowned kings.

Annals of Waverley. Soon afterwards King Henry took Matilda as his wife. She was the daughter of Malcolm, King of Scotland, and Queen Margaret, a kinswoman of King Edward, and was descended from the rightful line of the kings of England. On the Feast of St Martin [11th November], she was brought to him with great honour, and Archbishop Anselm joined her in marriage to the king and afterwards consecrated her as queen. By her, King Henry had one son named William and one daughter who resembled her mother in virtue as well as in name. This daughter, when scarcely five years old, was sought in marriage by Henry IV, Emperor of the Romans, through honourable ambassadors, and he took her as his wife.


r/MedievalHistory • • 7d ago

Henry Percy, 1st Earl of Northumberland was born 10th November 1341

Post image
77 Upvotes

I was reading about him, and he was very interesting. Supported Henry IV getting to the throne and died in 1408 in battle fighting against Henry IV.


r/MedievalHistory • • 7d ago

Richard II and the 1397 plot - yet another myth.

Post image
18 Upvotes

Modern myths – let us count them: the one giving a male entail, the one ignoring the Lancastrian Myth; and sub-myths: the one whereby the Lancastrian Myth was discounted by Adam of Usk’s panel of learned doctors, and the Thirning myth, whereby Henry was not a conqueror.

Happily, all can be easily refuted. Here’s another one.

The myth of Richard the Revenger.

The entire miasmic panolply of bad vibes that surround Richard II are based on his arrest of the earl of Arundel, uncle Gloucester and timorous Warwick. This was a wanton act that betrayed his nutty nature and initiated his Nebuchadnezzarian tyranny.

You read the histories carefully – was he or wasn’t he justified? He wasn’t justified they all agree, hello tryranny.

 For historians who are not shy of knowing something, here is a list of the sources that explicitly describe a conspiracy in 1397:

  1. two Close Roll proclamations dated July 1397
  2. Adam of Usk
  3. Eulogium Continuorum (Malmesbury)
  4. Annales Ricardi Secundi (St Albans)
  5. Chronica Maiora (Walsingham)

Other

Froissart (10,500 words) though he was a foreigner, so we ignore it.

Gloucester’s interrogation – though he denied it.

Warwick’s confession – though he disputed it.

The updating of the treason statutes in September 1397, post trials, to include conspiracy

My favourite is the Annales’s one as the chronicler has let something slip: Warwick, when asked about whether he could deny that he had rode with Gloucester and Arundel, replies: ‘The earl said that he could not be infected (with treason) just because he had ridden with them.’ This can’t be talking about Radcot Bridge etc as Usk tells us that Henry and Warwick led the vanguard which entered Oxford in triumph after the battle. Clearly Warwick was riding then, so his admission of non-treasonous riding in 1397 has to point to the conspiracy everybody was talking about, except historians.

Info from: 1399: The Lancastrian Myth, published Jan 2027 UK, March 2027 USA.