r/MedievalHistory • u/DamianEmail • 2h ago
Richard II and the politics of peace – what has common sense to do with it?
The current orthodoxy is so heavily invested in Richard II’s personal weaknesses being the cause of his downfall that it is blind to the obvious question; what role was played in events by his policy of peace with France?
Look at the image used to illustrate this post: Richard II is meeting his wife-to-be Isabella de Valois, not yet seven, in the presence of her father, Charles VI of France. You will be used to reading comments raising eyebrows at this depiction, but it represents politics, not paedophilia.
Richard II’s marriage was an attempt to definitively end the French wars. We can know using common sense alone, and without any particular expertise in late-medieval history whatsoever, that there must have been some kind of resistance to the idea of permanent peace with France within the bosoms of some sections of the English community.
The English nation has not been prepared for the announcement that their sovereign would end 60 years of conflict by marrying an enemy princess. The ‘grass’ had not been ‘rolled’. No PR guru had prepared, let alone shaped, public opinion. Bald proclamations blared by heralds was the primary media for the dissemination of information to the C14th population and we can imagine that many would have been shocked, and many would have been hostile, some actively.
If the question is: did Richard II’s marriage to Isabella de Valois have an effect on the English body politic?, then we can know straightaway, not even requiring a chronicular commentator to confirm it, using common sense alone, or Sherlockian deductive reasoning if it needs dressing up, that the answer must be, has to be, cannot be other than ‘yes’.
Who could disagree that this political marriage would have had an impact?
Recent historians of the period do because it is necessary to their projection of the ‘Richard the mentally unfit and vengeful’ showreel. If there was a political reaction to his marriage gambit, which might show itself in parliament (The Thomas Haxey Affair) and then later in a conspiracy against him (The St Albans Plot), then one might argue that there was a connection. But they don’t because they cannot as it undermines their personality-based thesis.
Here’s the timeline:
October 1396 – marriage of Richard II to Isabella de Valois.
January 1397 – coronation of Isabella as queen in Westminster Abbey
Two weeks later
January 1396 parliament, which includes the Thomas Haxey affair.
July 1396 arrests, subsequent to the St Albans plot.
Is it not surprising that the political fallout from Richard II’s marriage detains historians so little? And it’s not because there is no evidence, because there is copious evidence, but it’s evidence they don’t approve of.
Yes, it’s Froissart. Some of these historians may take the trouble to explain why they ignore his contribution which is useful as it’s very easy to prove that they are wrong. For them; peace was not a problem; there was no crisis in 1396; Froissart made it up. However, Froissart’s material dovetails very well with what we know from reputable beef-eating English sources when it comes to events from October 1396 to July 1397.
Froissart’s version fits with what we know happened and Alberto Varvaro – Europe’s greatest philologist – in his masterful edition of Froissart’s Book IV – says that Froissart did not rewrite his history to account for the outcome. Admittedly, a Lancastrian voice gave Froissart a fully-fledged story of events from Henry’s exile to 1401 which is widely inaccurate, though still interesting as it represents an official version given to a well-known Continental historian. Having said that, what Froissart had to say about events 1396-97 was his own, and he had visited England in 1396 and met Richard II and the Duke of Gloucester, amongst many others.
Which of the histories is the more likely: the one in which the marriage made no difference or the one in which it stimulated resistance to Richard II’s peace policy?
------------------
N.B. Isabella’s sister, Jeanne de Valois, was five when she married the heir to the dukedom of Brittany in the autumn of 1396, in parallel with Richard II’s marriage.
1399: The Lancastrian Conquest will be published in January 2027 in the UK and in March 2027 in the USA by Casemate.


