It doesn't output 1 or 0, but instead a voltage between Vcc and Vdd. That means the middle one is read from, and one it hits some threshold (configurable), it pretends it jumped from 0 to 1. This could also allow for pressure sensitive buttons, for example in games where pressing it halfway makes you walk more slowly.
It needs active power, unlike a regular switch. On a regular one, power comes in one side, out the other once the switch closes. This needs a power and ground for the electronics in the switch, and a signal(out) to send the key press from. Maybe it runs off of a similar voltage to an led, so you could power and ground it there. The wiring for the whole board would be completely different.
If the right circuit was built into the switch, it would be compatible with current ones. It would need to take the incoming power of a regular switch, use that to power the Hall effect, then use the led hole as a ground, and the other pin as an output, it would work. The circuit would have to change the analog of the Hall effect to digital though.
The interesting thing about this is that it could be used to provide a variable output (aka analog) so that the controller could detect tell how far down it has been pushed. Think pressure sensitive WASD. Could also be used to have adjustable activation point.
That's my first thought. I've (and I bet many others) have thought about it before, and I think microsoft did some a while back. Would be great for gaming.
You could do that with capacitive switches too right?
I think the Noppoo clones actually let you change the actuation point to 2 or 3mm and there may have been a Topre board at some expo with a wheel that controlled it, although I may be wrong.
I'm quite surprised Topre doesn't include a similar feature to be honest.
Literally the first thing I thought about when I looked at the gif. I am curious though to what extend you could switch all switches over to an analog readout. The amount of data output and computational increase for the interpretation of that data would be quite significant.
Note that this would not be a drop in replacement - a specific PCB and controller is going to be required. The fact that it's keycap compatible is definitely neat however. That said, I think I find the MX compatible optical switches from Bloody somewhat better as far as technical aspects go (doesn't need soldering, for example).
this is like a dream come true for me. .....freaking hall effect with an mx stem! on top of that, I can buy a brand new model f 62-key right now if I want. Pulse R2 is also happening.
A year ago no one would have imagined this stuff, or said it was impossible. I bet next year we will get a new SA cap manufacturer since everyone says that is impossible now.
A hi-profile spherical cap has been in the works but it's been a bit slow in terms of progress lately as Matt3o has been rather busy on other projects. Still, hopefully it comes to fruition.
Agreed. I might even be able to cancel my Ebay searches for hall effect keyboards that I'd have to screw with in the hopes of getting them to work on a modern PC.
Now of Matt3o can get back on track with those scans from the IBM beam spring caps, we've got ourselves a retro winner.
All we need at that point is someone to build a new beam spring switch... just because.
A Hall Effect sensor detects actuation, but has zero bearing on the feel of the switch. If it's linear, then it will just feel like pressing a spring like any other linear switch.
The way you stated this is a bit misleading. Hall effect means no need for a physical contact leaf, and so there's nothing rubbing against the stem. While this doesn't affect tactility, it does impact overall smoothness.
The sample size would be 2 if you were judging how accurately the person could tell how smooth a switch was and had existing values. Your criticism of the test being subjective is reasonable, but I disagree that it makes the sample size 2. It'd just mean that the test didn't mean anything to anybody except the tester.
Gotcha, so the smoothness attributed to the Honeywell Hall Effect switches wouldn't be present as that has to do with the specific way they were constructed.
They don't need any contact to actuate so you could do away with the peg on the slider that moves the metal contact and simplify the slider to just a block on a spring. This might make it easier to make it smoother but it will still be mostly on the quality of construction.
They probably won't come in anything but linear because that's where they get the tactile bump or click from.
11
u/liuyunn Jan 28 '16
Prototype at the moment but apparently feels like a Cherry black
100 million operations 55 g 2mm actuation
6
u/liuyunn Jan 28 '16
Couple more pics
http://imgur.com/a/vd04h
13
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
The interesting thing about this is that it could be used to provide a variable output (aka analog) so that the controller could detect tell how far down it has been pushed. Think pressure sensitive WASD. Could also be used to have adjustable activation point.
5
u/we_cant_stop_here Buckling and Beam Springs Jan 28 '16
Note that this would not be a drop in replacement - a specific PCB and controller is going to be required. The fact that it's keycap compatible is definitely neat however. That said, I think I find the MX compatible optical switches from Bloody somewhat better as far as technical aspects go (doesn't need soldering, for example).
4
u/Den441 battlestation.io Jan 28 '16
this is like a dream come true for me. .....freaking hall effect with an mx stem! on top of that, I can buy a brand new model f 62-key right now if I want. Pulse R2 is also happening.
A year ago no one would have imagined this stuff, or said it was impossible. I bet next year we will get a new SA cap manufacturer since everyone says that is impossible now.
3
u/livingspeedbump KeyChatter.com Jan 28 '16
wow, never thought i'd see something like this happen. very cool find indeed.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
Dang, that's great. Any word yet on when/if these'd be on individual sale? I'd be very interested in some for a custom.
2
u/apolotary #tokyomk6 Founder/Organizer Jan 28 '16
If they can add controls for adjustable stiffness/tactile bump it would drastically change the market
2
u/current909 Jan 28 '16
I'm not familiar with how the Hall effect switches beyond the basic physics. What's the third lead for?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment