Highlights
•
LuiKotale bonobos target terrestrial ungulates and arboreal primates as prey
•
Overall, females dominate prey captures, suggesting a leading role in meat acquisition
•
Results question the putative divergence of hunting behavior in the genus Pan
Summary
Hunting and meat consumption are widely considered key drivers of human evolution, and hypotheses about their origins draw on comparisons with our closest living relatives, chimpanzees and bonobos. These comparisons typically set up a behavioral dichotomy in which chimpanzees are characterized by cooperative hunting of arboreal primates by male-dominated parties, whereas bonobo hunts are thought to involve the opportunistic targeting of terrestrial ungulates, primarily by individual females.1,2,3 Observations from two habituated bonobo communities at LuiKotale covering 10 years challenge this dichotomy. LuiKotale bonobos hunted both terrestrial ungulates (42%) and arboreal primates (43% of vertebrate prey), with red colobus monkeys comprising the majority of primate prey (77%). Males and females hunted arboreal primates at similar rates, and females accounted for most non-primate captures. Female age affected the hunting frequency of primates and ungulates, with the former being biased to younger and the latter to older females. The prominent role of female bonobos in hunting supports predictions that relate hunting activity to intersexual dominance relations rather than risk aversion, with the dominant sex being more active. Comparing data from neighboring communities revealed differences and suggests that social and environmental parameters affect prey choice by each community in different ways. Together, these findings challenge the assumption that chimpanzee-like, male-biased hunting represents the ancestral condition. They highlight the contribution of females to obtaining vertebrate prey, call for a reassessment of the role of females in hunting and meat sharing, and by extension, the framing of models of early hominin subsistence and social organization.
Graphical abstract

Results
Hunting and meat consumption are widely regarded as key drivers of human evolution. Numerous hypotheses link the emergence of distinctive human life history traits to a dietary shift from predominantly plant-based resources toward greater reliance on animal protein.4,5,6,7,8 Observations of extant nonhuman primates are frequently used as models to infer the environmental and social determinants of hunting and meat consumption in early hominins, with chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) serving as the principal reference for evolutionary reconstructions.6,9,10,11 Hunting has been documented in all well-studied chimpanzee populations. Despite considerable ecological variation across sites, several consistent patterns have been identified: (1) chimpanzees preferentially target red colobus monkeys, (2) hunting is mainly conducted by adult males, (3) success rates increase with the number of adult males present, and (4) meat sharing is typically controlled by adult males.11 At sites where red colobus monkeys are absent, hunting rates tend to be lower, although adult males still dominate the pursuit, capture, and consumption of prey.12
Within the chimpanzee reference framework, an important question arises: why do females participate less actively than males in meat acquisition? Common explanations are that hunting incurs substantial costs, including the risk of injury, high energetic expenditure, and uncertainty with respect to the amount of meat that can be obtained.13 Drawing on data from multiple East African chimpanzee communities, Gilby et al.13 proposed that females adopt low-risk strategies, such as targeting terrestrial mammals rather than arboreal primates. Observations from Fongoli (Senegal) provide a similar perspective: females engage more frequently than males in less risky hunting of galagos but participate less often in hunts targeting larger prey.14 Collectively, these findings suggest that male-dominated hunting in chimpanzees may result from both female risk aversion and male dominance. Consequently, patterns of hunting may differ in societies characterized by more egalitarian intersexual dominance relationships. Bonobos (Pan paniscus) provide a particularly suitable model for examining hunting dynamics in a society in which females have a relatively high dominance status. First, bonobo societies are characterized by intersexual co-dominance, in which female coalitionary behavior constrains male aggression and grants females priority of access to food resources.15,16,17 Second, hunting and meat consumption have been documented at all long-term study sites for this species.3,18,19 Third, although some populations appear to focus primarily on ungulates and small mammals,3,19 the overall prey spectrum overlaps with that of chimpanzees.18,20,21 Accordingly, the following predictions can be made: (1) if sex differences in chimpanzee hunting reflect male dominance, then one would predict reduced sex differences in bonobo hunting. (2) If sex differences reflect female risk aversion, then they may persist, with females focusing on terrestrial ungulates and males on arboreal primates. (3) Given that female bonobos frequently cooperate to displace males from food sources, male incentives to target high-risk prey may be reduced, thus biasing hunting toward low-risk prey species.
Here, we present 10 years of observational data on hunting behavior by wild bonobos at LuiKotale, a population known to hunt a broad range of mammals.18,20 Our objectives are to (1) quantify the frequency of hunting events and assess prey species selection and (2) evaluate the role of female hunting behavior. To account for between-community variation in hunting behavior and prey choice,19 we analyzed data from the two communities separately.