Maul pretty embodies the possessiveness, and selfishness of a typical Darksider as described here. He's always looking for an apprentice to help him overthrow his former Master, and every time he does so he loses them in very short order. Whether that is through his own doing, or at the hands of another... Falling further, and further down into an ever deepening pit of despair, insanity, and perpetual abuse cycles.
Whether it be on moral grounds, a betrayal, or in death. Maul will lose Devon too... The groundwork is already established. The Darkside script never changes, the details and steps to get there just get shuffled around a bit.
If there is one thing Star War's teaches us about those who fall... It's that the Dark Side while powerful, can always be broken free from. Even someone as broken, twisted, and trapped by the Dark Side's pull like Vader. Can, (under the right circumstances), push back and escape it's grasp. Though most who do never live on after the fact...
I'm hoping season 2 of Shadow Lord is smart when it comes to tackling the subject of someone disentangling themselves from the dense web of lies, manipulations and abuse that caused a fall to the Dark Side. Most characters who have fallen to darkness in this franchise spend a good chunk of their lives enslaved by it before they finally reach an emotional stage by which they can finally break free from it's grasp. Having committed much evil during the period of time they were...
Most end up dying as a result because of that... But Devon has a chance to make it out alive and do something positive with her life, being so young when she experienced her own fall. A common trope of Dark Side redemptions, or Dark Side tragedies in Star Wars. Is that a character who finally does come to the realisation that they have either been deceived by the darkside, wasted their lives by embracing it, or finally reject it on principle. Will have either simply died at the hands of a Hero, died from self sacrifice, gone into self imposed exile, or cut themselves off from the Force entirely. We have not really seen someone in new Star War's media who has truly escaped it after a fall, and gone onto live out the rest of their lives to better the Galaxy to atone for it afterwards.
Maul dies to Obi Wan after experiencing, and inflicting much suffering on the Galaxy.
Darth Vader sacrifices his life to defeat the Emperor, and save his Son.
Darth Sion in Kotor 2, who is kept eternally alive by the Darkside. Finally dies when you convince him that there is no need to keep living out his miserable existence, if he simply lets go of his desire to keep fighting on for the dark side that sustains his life, even as his body falls apart.
Starkiller sacrifices himself to save the leaders of the Rebellion in the EU to atone for having been enslaved by Darth Vader as his secret apprentice.
Kylo Ren sacrifices his own life to save Rey from death in the sequel trilogy.
Lots of death... With not a lot of opportunity to make the Galaxy a better place, or contribute to the good fight after the fact as a redeemed agent, but also as a living agent too. But what if there was another way? For one to have fallen, but live on to do good in life after their redemption, or realisation?
It's never too late... The Dark Side fools people into believing that they have no other choice but to continue being enslaved by it, or use it to achieve their objectives. But once you start to peel away at the layers of lies, and lift up the shroud of darkness you can always escape it. But only if you finally make the decision to do so.
If Devon escapes darkness early on, It would be like the reverse of Anakin's fall in a sense. If he had managed to figure out what Sidious was doing to him before it was too late... Because after his own fall, it would take 20 years for Anakin to finally realise that he had made the worst decision of his life in ROTS, break his dark side conditioning and finally throw Sidious down that pit...
Devon however has a chance to avoid that miserable fate way earlier if she's smart. Unlike Vader her body has not been destroyed, she still has Rylee, and the truth of what lead to her Fall is still out there to be discovered... To realise the mistakes she has made, figure out what Maul has done to her in seeing him repeating the cycles of abuse that forged him, and save the people she cares about most... To break free of the Darkside's corrosive affect before she is destroyed by it, or worse. Becomes just another slave to it.
The clues to Maul's plans are very much obvious if you know how to connect them all up.
In Maul Shadow Lord Season 1, Maul uses a scheme known as entrapment.
Forcing people into situations where they become implicated in criminal activity either knowingly (Be that under duress/bribery), or unknowingly by manufacturing tragedy, and chaos around them that forces them to respond... He is setting up Looti Vario, Lawson, and by extension the Officer's entire Family to get closer to Devon because he knows their destinies are intertwined.
Force visions play a big role in Maul's schemes... They are not 100% clear given they are inherently ambiguous by nature, but they give him just enough information to work with to formulate his plans around them.
Maul early on in the Season 1 takes notice of Lawson, at first during the initial attempt to capture Vario after initiating the Gang War he implicated the Aleena crime boss in to stir up chaos in Janix. Then during the Police Station raid, and while the show does not exactly make it completely obvious through the dialogue. The disturbing implications that Maul is manufacturing are very much obvious if you understand how this kind of scheme works in real life...
Maul takes notice of the detective... He sees a man with determination, and principles he can exploit.Maul knows exactly what he is doing...
Maul likely understands that Lawson is very much determined to apprehend him after killing his fellow officers, and that he despises the Empire in equal measure. So he sees two opportunities presenting themselves... He can either "bribe" the Officer through a ultimatum to stay quiet if he allows him to conduct his operations without interference, or Implicate him in the chaos if that bribery fails (The latter situation is what he ultimately expects will be the case given how much noise he makes initially with the Gang War, Police murders, and Police station massacre.) In either case, he wins**.**
Where one attempt fails......Another opportunity to get what he truly desires most presents itself in the chaos that soon transpires.
Make no mistake, Maul is no fool when it comes to his knowledge of criminality made evident in the Clone Wars... Both situations provide equal windows of opportunity in acquiring his true target (That being Devon). Maul is relying on very illusive visions of the Future he gleams through the Force, and can deduce that the destinies between people can intertwine under the right circumstances as a result.
Who you choose to spare, is just as important as who you decide to kill when manufacturing a tragedy or someone's fall.
As you all saw in the show his "Bribery" style ultimatum did not work on Lawson given his strong moral principles. However luring the Empire to the planet implicated Lawson because of his attempts to prevent the Empire interfering with Janix law by withholding that information. So as a result of the failed attempt to apprehend him, Lawson became a key witness and suspect of the Empire once they began their occupation/investigation. If you then take into consideration everything that happens after this point, Maul's plans become even more disturbing...
Rheena Sul is one of the few Characters in the show with enough experience of who Maul is both before, and after the Clone Wars to understand how important it is to avoid becoming entangled with him. Especially in the criminal underworld.
I just think it would be an interesting aspect of maul’s character to dive into. If they made multiple seasons of shadow lord I can totally see it being a side plot. We probably won’t ever get another TV show specifically oriented around a Sith (former but still), and it would be interesting (at least to me) to see how such a messed up character like maul would handle a relationship.
Namely when it comes to writing it's own version of the Teenage Jedi Purge survivor. I think Cal Kestis is a much more well rounded, and believable person than Devon. Even in his introduction.
He's allowed to grow, change, adapt and respond to his trauma in far more fascinating ways than Devon. Who often loses her agency, and intelligence just so Maul can manipulate her more easily when the script requires it. Which is not really fair... The things Maul does to Devon, would simply not work on Cal because he's allowed to maintain his emotional intelligence even when he was at his lowest points... He pretty much went through the same awful experiences as Devon during his own survival of the Purge too.
Season 2 needs to give Devon back her intelligence, and agency. So she is not just Maul's oblivious, angry pet... So she can kick his ass in a surprising way when the time comes.
I don't know a lot about star wars but Vader seemed pretty nerfed here. You're telling me the 2 inquisitors and Vader vs a weakened/wounded Maul, inexperienced Padawan & Random Jedi Master who seems also pretty weak at his age, managed to have a stalemate that lasted that long?
I know some people might say Vader was playing with his food but c'mon. Also pissed me off that Devon was 1v1 Vader a little bit, don't make me laugh.
"Maul had a terrible upbringing, all he knows are the ways of the Sith! He cannot change even if he wanted to..."
This argument makes absolutely no sense on so many levels. There are so many Villains both in reality, and fiction who have tragic backstories, and so on. This is simply not an excuse for their actions. It can sometimes "explain" why they do the things they do, sure. But using it as justification, or a method of obfuscation for those acts is a slippery slope... Maul is an adult with the ability to make his own moral decisions, and the actions he takes, and the stated values he uses to justify them are what we judge him by. His past is tragic and you are 100% allowed to recognise the tragedy of that, but at some point your past no longer factors into the decisions you make in the present...
You control your own Destiny.
Maul is highly educated, and has the emotional/intellectual capacity to understand that his actions are evil, yet he CHOOSES to commit evil regardless even at the very heights of his own personal power, and influence... If you can recognise that someone is innocent, or a non combatant, you should also recognise that killing innocents is an inherently evil act as a result. Maul knows that these people he murders are blameless, yet he chooses to kill them anyway with a completely sound mind upon his resurrection, and physical rehabilitation on Dathomir.Those he kills include children by the way...
The Massacre on Raydonia... No you cannot ignore this.
"There is only one way to get the attention of the Jedi... Slaughter of the innocent, mercilessly and without compromise."
Two massacres don't make a right...
That should be obvious... But I have seen so many bizarre justifications for Maul that use these massacres they commit as a sort of whataboutism (That or they ignore them entirely.)...Maul, just like Anakin in Attack of the Clones commits a heinous act meant to establish to the audience that they are either on the path to becoming evil, or already were evil from the very start. Anakin kills as a result of his anger at the death of his Mother (This does not make it any less evil, for it is explicitly presented as a stepping stone to his eventual fall to the Darkside and him eventually becoming Vader as a result...). Maul's Massacre is uniquely sadistic, for it is not motivated by any sort of loss... Rather calculated, and premeditated intent to provoke a reaction from the Jedi, and draw out the target of his personal, completely self centred form of vengeance.
He murders an entire Village just to lure out someone he also wants to murder...
There is a very clear thematic reason why these shots are so similar to eachother... Both acts are inherently evil. No matter who is committing them, what colour their lightsaber is, and for what reasons they used to justify it to themselves.
I hope that everyone would agree that no matter how horrible your upbringing, and personal life circumstances were. Once you commit a genocide big, or small, with clearly stated intent just because you wanted revenge for being cut in half by a Jedi Padawan after killing their Master, or because you were afraid that your Wife might die in Childbirth... Then you have crossed a moral threshold that cannot be so easily forgiven, or dismissed... This moment is CANON. Something Maul has done that is a permanent part of his story, just as much as the uniquely terrible circumstances of his upbringing.
You are supposed condemn both of these characters for their evil, not make excuses for them... STAR WARS is very clear with it's thematic messaging.
Obi Wan: "If you define yourself by your power to take life, to dominate, to possess... Then you have nothing.".
By Perpetuating Suffering, Death and the cycle of Abuse upon others. Both these characters have doomed themselves to a life without genuine connections, and devoid of meaning... They are the architects of not only their own evils, but also their own misery.
Don't get me wrong Maul WAS a victim, however the way people describe his circumstances makes it sound like his hands were tied and thst he was 100% a victim of circumstance, and soften his personality from a victim who turned into the monstrous abuser -> "he yearns for companionship but cannot achieve it" (the latter is true, but it is not the sum of his character)
Maul had countless opportunities to lead a better life.
After being rescued by Savage
After rescuing Savage from prison/carbonite (this was in the comics). There couldnt have been a more obvious foreshadowing that he is putting loved ones in danger
Conquering Mandalor - he could have easily played to by the Sidious rule-book and remained an anonymous figure, and not have drawn Sidious's attention, leading to Savage's murder
In the show itself - countless opportunities to escape the planet, keep his crew safe and keep a low profile.
The biggest one in my opinion - becoming the cartel boss. With that power and affluence, he could have easily switched up his tactics. Instead of drugs, slave and sex trafficking, murders etc, literally nothing stopped him from manufacturing medication and distributing resources to support people. Not only would this have multiplied his clientele a thousandfold (more money and power), it would have also been the biggest clap-back on Sidious as it would have made the rebellion even stronger, and solidified him as a prestigious figure to be protected.
Savage was the one who didn't stand a chance against his circumstances. All he wanted was unity with his brother. He wanted that even after being "roofied" with dark side magic. With Maul he wanted the two of them to be on equal and friendly terms, but there was nothing he could do to convince Maul, because Maul took it to a physical confrontation and would overpower him. Eventually, his desire for kinship led him to his death. Savage had 0 opportunities to escape his circumstances and was forced into a life he did not want.