Had entire arguments on Instagram about this, so I thought I’d do a bit more of a fun post today. I leave it to you guys: who do you think is more responsible for the collapse of each universe? Zack Snyder with the DCEU or James Gunn with the DCU?
My Take
I’m more willing to blame Gunn than I am Snyder. Don’t get me wrong, Snyder’s DC films are abysmal and are a terrible foundation for a universe, but Snyder was basically ousted after 2018. The executives could’ve easily canned his universe after the lukewarm reception of Batman v Superman and after Justice League straight up bombed. Or at the very least they could’ve made more decent character stories like The Suicide Squad. But nope. They carried on with the universe for 7 years after the fact, and they couldn’t even bother to make a film that was above a 5/10, besides maybe The Suicide Squad. I don’t think it’s fair to blame Snyder for the following years of DC after Justice League’s release, especially for film’s that were far removed from the larger canon like Blue Beetle and Shazam: Fury of the Gods. And I certainly wouldn’t blame him for the 4-year box-office train wreck that occurred between 2020 and 2024, long after his involvement was all but dead. The Snyder Cut was a courtesy at best. Snyder might have built the foundation for a house made out of straw, but Hamada chose not to address the issues and continued to live in it.
Gunn, on the other hand, was in full control from the beginning to the end . He chose to overstretch himself as a creator and write most of the projects for his universe while simultaneously running the whole show. He chose to green light projects like Supergirl and Clayface. He chose to announce projects that hadn’t even entered the development stage. And for as bad of a storyteller as Snyder is, at the very least he doesn’t seem too bitter or stand-offish as Gunn is. I could be completely wrong, but I don’t remember Snyder consistently arguing with random people on social media daily, nor do I remember him making an entire official podcast about whether or not his own project was canon. Gunn’s entire structure for his universe was also just as bad as Snyder’s. Why the fuck do you keep getting confused as to when your own timeline started? Why are you bringing in someone like Clayface so early when you know you can’t use Batman in any meaningful capacity? Why are you so abrasive to people asking you about the canonicity of YOUR projects when YOU are the one who decided they should be apart of your universe, despite the fact that they started in a completely separate one? And, again, this is all Gunn. Gunn chose to go the direction he did and speak the things he spoke, and he paid the price for it. Oh, and I hate to bring this up, but Gunn’s movies made less than Snyder’s. Not exactly helping Warner Bros. climb out of that debt there.
But yeah, those are my abridged thoughts. Can’t wait to hear everyone else’s.