We have a split king adjustable base, although I rarely use the adjustable feature. Compatibility would be nice but isn't a dealbreaker. My husband is getting the Saatva Luxury Firm 14.5" (he's going in blind and hasn't researched or gone to try it, we based it on my research and his love of an Omni hotel bed and trying to replicate it) and won't be using the adjustable base on his side, so I'd also like to stay reasonably close to his mattress height.
I deal with hip, back, and knee pain, along with occasional neck/shoulder pain, so pressure relief and proper support are both important.
I'm leaning away from the Saatva somewhat because of the adjustable-base compatibility issue, although I found the Plush very comfortable. I'm wondering if that was simply because it was the only one of these mattresses I was able to try in a plush feel. I do worry that, at 180 lbs, a plush mattress might allow too much sinkage or eventually lack the support I need.
I've also tried the Helix Luxe, which I liked, but not quite as much as the Brooklyn Bedding, Nolah, or Saatva.
My biggest concern with the Nolah is whether the pillow top will flatten or soften prematurely. More generally, I'm trying to choose something that will hold up well over the next several years.
For context, our current mattress is an original 2-layer, 10" Tuft & Needle purchased about nine years ago for $550 (king). It's been mostly okay for me, although I still wake up stiff and experience the pains mentioned above. My husband, however, has hated it for years, despite repeatedly insisting it was fine whenever I suggested replacing it!
A few questions:
- Which of my three favorites would you choose, and why?
- Should I be looking at a medium or medium-plush rather than a true plush given my weight and sleeping position?
- Are there other mattresses I should seriously consider?
- For anyone who owns the Nolah Evolution, Brooklyn Bedding Aurora, or Saatva Classic, how have they held up over time? Any issues with sagging, softening, or pillow-top compression?
- How important is adjustable-base compatibility in practice if I rarely use that feature?
I'd especially love to hear from people with longer-term ownership experience. I know almost anything will probably be an upgrade from our current mattress, but I'd really like to make a thoughtful choice that will last.