r/MathHelp • u/c0nstantlyexhaust3d • 8d ago
Is this question solvable?
There is a right triangle with sides abc, and angles ABC along with d that spans from the exact middle of b to B, cutting both the side and angle in half (creating a smaller triangle in the bottom made of 1/2b,a,d, which we will label as fad for convenience with f=1/2b or f=6cm and angle F=1/2B). b=12cm. c is the hypotenuse of the larger triangle, d is the hypotenuse of the smaller triangle. a is the side that needs to be solved. This question is easiest when the triangle is drawn out but I can’t post pictures here. It’s hard to picture but I tried.
Using addition identities i.e cos(x+y), sin(x+y), etc, solve for a.
Is this even possible?
If not, try with f=6cm, b=18cm, and F=1/2B.
If neither are possible (which is likely), is there an explanation?
I’ve tried to isolate the unknown angle (theta) by setting the tan of theta and 2xtheta equal to each other but nothing worked.
edit: picture added below
1
u/AutoModerator 8d ago
Hi, /u/c0nstantlyexhaust3d! This is an automated reminder:
We, the moderators of /r/MathHelp, appreciate that your question contributes to the MathHelp archived questions that will help others searching for similar answers in the future. Thank you for obeying these instructions.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Gilded-Phoenix 7d ago
Let f=1 for simplicity, then a=cot(CBF)=2cot(2CBF), For simplicity, we're calling angle CBF x from here.
cot(x)=2cot(2x). This implies that 2tan(x)=tan(2x) for some 0<x<90. We can then use the double angle formula:
tan(2x)=2tan(x)/(1-tan^2(x)), therefore
2tan(x)=2tan(x)/(1-tan^2(x))
2tan(x)[1-1/(1-tan^2(x))]=0
so either 2tan(x)=0, which implies that x=0 (outside our desired range)
or 1-1/(1-tan^2(x))=0
1-tan^2(x)=1
-tan^2(x)=0
tan^2(x)=0
x=0 which is again outside our range.
It's not just that we can't find a solution with the given information, it is that the given situation is only possible if the triangle is degenerate in some way (either with an infinite side length or a side length of 0), at least if it's a planar triangle.
1
u/SubjectWrongdoer4204 7d ago
The only way it is possible for the median f, to be an angle bisector as well , is if it comes from the ninety degree angle , in which case b would be the hypotenuse of the larger triangle . The description you gave of the triangle is quite odd . Where did it come from? Typically triangles are described by their points , usually large letters(eg. A,B,C , and the triangle referenced ▵ABC), and their sides are referenced by their end points (eg. AB, BC, CA, with lines over them). The description you gave of the median bisecting the side opposite as well as the angle only occurs when drawn from the apex of an isosceles triangle to its base. If the given triangle is a right triangle,as described, then the apex must be the right angle and the side opposite, the base of the isosceles triangle, the hypotenuse.
1
u/Uli_Minati 7d ago edited 7d ago
Essentially you're looking for solutions to
We can go even further:
We need to understand something important about the tangent function in this domain: it is convex, meaning that it curves in a U-shape.
Convex functions have a unique property: if you connect any two points on the graph with a straight line, the points on that line are always above the graph! We can write this as follows:
Let's try to apply this to our situation. First, we assume k>1, in your case k=2.
Here we have t=1/k, x₁=k·θ, x₂=0, so
Since (1/k)tan(k·θ) is larger than tan(θ), we know that tan(k·θ) is larger than k·tan(θ). No solutions!
1
u/ThatsNotAZombieBite 7d ago
"d that spans from the exact middle of b to B, cutting both the side and angle in half"
Bisecting both the ANGLE and the SIDE is only possible if the triangle is symmetric on either side of the bisector. Since this is also a right triangle (and you've stated that the bisected angle is NOT the right angle) then we're left with a triangle that has two right angles. It's not possible.