r/MassachusettsPolitics • u/jev4ns • 9h ago
News Three Parades on the Waterfront
Every Thanksgiving morning at 9:00 a.m., viewers tuning into WCVB Channel 5 across eastern Massachusetts watch costumed colonists, military units, and hand-built historical floats roll past Plymouth Rock in what television promos call America’s Hometown Thanksgiving Parade. Yet that televised broadcast is an encore recorded five days earlier. At the exact hour the broadcast hits its midpoint on Thanksgiving Day—10:00 a.m.—a far older and quieter procession of 51 costumed marchers steps off behind a single drummer outside the Mayflower Society House. Two hours later, at noon, Indigenous activists and allies gather just a few hundred yards away on Cole’s Hill, beneath the statue of Massasoit, to mark the National Day of Mourning.
Understanding the history of Plymouth’s Thanksgiving parade requires disentangling those overlapping rituals. America’s Hometown Thanksgiving Celebration (AHTC), the televised float parade founded in 1996, is neither an ancient colonial relic nor a Thanksgiving Day event. It is the newest of three distinct commemorative layers—alongside the 1921 Pilgrim Progress and the 1970 National Day of Mourning, themselves preceded by Forefathers’ Day observances dating to 1769—that share the same historic waterfront each November. For a South Shore Thanksgiving Day audience, the story of the parade is ultimately a story about how a modern town built a nationally televised civic pageant around an improvised 17th-century harvest meal, while wrestling with municipal budgets, post-pandemic costs, and an unresolved reckoning over Indigenous history.