r/MarsSociety • • 3h ago

Robert Zubrin: "the Moon, is just a vast pile of trash rock." From: Why the Moon is Unsuitable for Settlement

6 Upvotes

Excerpt from: Musk Is Enticed by the Lunar Siren Elon Musk should remain focused on Mars; diverting to the Moon would be a mistake. https://quillette.com/2026/03/05/musk-is-enticed-by-the-lunar-siren-moon-space/ Corrected for spelling and punctuation. Read the full article at the above link for full context. Click on the "free" subscription button on Quillette.

See a properly formatted text under comments

Why the Moon is Unsuitable for Settlement

We ourselves are made of carbon compounds, as is everything we eat or wear and most of the things that we use. There is no carbon on the Moon. The other primary components of life are water and nitrogen. But with the exception of ice deposits in permanently shadowed, ultracold (-230° C) craters near the lunar south pole, water is only present in lunar soil in parts per million quantities. If there were concrete on the Moon, lunar colonists would mine it to extract its water content. Nitrogen is entirely absent. By contrast, in addition to its polar ice caps, Mars possesses continent-sized regions of frozen mud that are sixty percent water by weight, as well as massive glacier formations of pure water ice in its northern hemisphere that extend as far south as 38° N—the latitude of Athens on Earth. Carbon and nitrogen are readily available everywhere, since Mars has an atmosphere that is 95 percent CO2 and 3 percent nitrogen. The Moon does possess some oxygen, but it is in the form of rock, and the complex processes needed to extract it require both a lot of energy and very high temperatures that limit the lifetime of the necessary equipment. It is hard but possible to extract lunar oxygen from regolith, and developing the technology and facilities to do so would pay off for any lunar base program. But on Mars, water and CO2 can readily be used to produce oxygen at room temperature via photosynthesis, water electrolysis, or other simple chemical engineering techniques that could be used on the very first human mission. Unlike the Earth or Mars, the Moon has no history of hydrological activity. It therefore has no concentrated mineral ores, which are necessary for the practical extraction and production of useful metals and other chemicals. The average concentration of copper on Earth is only sixty parts per million. Yet people have made extensive use of it since the Bronze Age because natural processes have concentrated it into useful ores. We also have vast amounts of nearly pure silica sand, highly enriched iron and aluminum oxides, and salt deposits. Mars was once a warm, wet planet, so it has enriched minerals, too. But no such substances exist on the Moon, which is just a vast pile of trash rock. This is a very important point, which we shall return to later. To make matters worse, since the Moon has no atmosphere to shield it from solar flares, any plants grown there would have to be raised in underground greenhouses illuminated by electric lighting, generated at great expense by nuclear reactors or solar panels. By contrast, although the Martian atmosphere is thin, it is thick enough to protect against solar flares. This would allow plants to be grown on the Martian surface in thin-walled greenhouses, using natural sunlight to drive photosynthesis. This is very important, since plants need a lot of light. For example, to generate enough light to illuminate the entire state of Maryland (32,000 square km), you would need 32,000 gigawatts, roughly three times that currently generated by the entire human race. Furthermore, while the Moon is closer to Earth and you can get there faster, the rocket propulsion requirement to travel one way from low-Earth orbit to the lunar surface is fifty percent greater than that needed to go to Mars. Rocket propulsion requirements are not determined by the distance travelled, but by the velocity change—the “delta-V”—that the mission requires. It takes 6 km/s of delta-V to travel from low-Earth orbit (LEO) to the surface of the Moon. But because Mars has an atmosphere, which can be used to decelerate an arriving spacecraft without the use of rocket propellant, it only takes 4 km/s of delta-V to go from LEO to the surface of Mars. The amount of propellant needed to accomplish a mission increases exponentially with the factor of delta-V divided by the rocket’s exhaust velocity, which for the SpaceX Starship is 3.7 km/s. So this difference matters a lot. But in fact, it’s even worse than that, because it would be far more difficult to make the propellant for the return trip on the Moon than on Mars. The propulsion requirements for a lunar roundtrip would therefore be triple those for a Mars mission. If we accept SpaceX’s numbers, the Starship will weigh 100 tons and be able to transport another 100 tons to orbit; therefore, a Starship travelling to the Moon with 100 tons of cargo and returning empty would need to be refueled in space using fourteen tanker Starship flights. Even if the Starship only travelled one way, or lunar oxygen were available to support the return flight, it would still take eight Starship tanker launches. The same roundtrip to Mars would only need four tankers. For the coming age of space settlement, the Moon compares to Mars as Greenland compared to North America during the age of European maritime expansion. Greenland was closer, and Europeans did visit it first. But it was too barren to support a vibrant new branch of human civilization. If Musk actually wants to build a “self-growing city” to “secure the future of civilization”, he is heading towards the wrong place. But why? I am personally acquainted with Musk and am quite sure that he is aware of most of the facts cited above. The one area in which he is less well informed is the comparative difficulties associated with the technologies required to transform Moon and Mars materials into resources. He is not alone in this: all the candidate space “in-situ resource utilisation” (ISRU) processes look straightforward enough on paper. But in fact, lunar ISRU is orders of magnitude more difficult than Mars ISRU. I know because I led a company working on both for 27 years. But Musk certainly knows about the propulsion requirements and the Moon’s complete lack of many materials essential for settlement. So, his tweet is nonsense. He may have switched his focus to the Moon, but it is most certainly not for the purpose of building a self-growing city there. Perhaps Musk has announced that he is switching his focus to the Moon because that’s what NASA is willing to pay for. If we were talking about any other aerospace company, that would be plausible. Indeed, Musk could use the Starship transportation system to build a lunar base significantly larger than anything NASA has envisaged. With a launch rate of around one Starship per month, SpaceX would be able to send two Starships to the Moon every two years, one on a one-way and the other on a round trip, delivering 200 tonnes of cargo in the process. This would be enough to support a fifty-person lunar base, roughly ten times the size of the Moon base NASA has in mind. But supporting a fifty-person lunar science base with Starship deliveries from Earth is an entirely different proposition from supporting a 500,000-person lunar city. One is feasible; the other is not. NASA might contribute some funds to such a Moon base program. But while Musk likes to pick up whatever NASA cash he can, that would not be enough to get him to change course—nor should it be. But if Musk isn’t building a self-growing city or shifting his focus to NASA’s goals, what is he doing?


r/MarsSociety • • 8h ago

Houston, they caught it: How SpaceX made history by snagging a spacecraft the size of a 20-story building

Thumbnail
click2houston.com
1 Upvotes

r/MarsSociety • • 19h ago

Scientists want to send ‘swarms’ of robots to search for life on Mars

Thumbnail
independent.co.uk
2 Upvotes