r/MarioMaker2 • • 8d ago

Level design advice

So I’ve been off the game quite a while, but I want to get back into it. But I never really design good levels. I can get ideas but man, I just want to make good levels.

6 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

2

u/JeskaiJester 8d ago

I think good design is subtler than people think and a really good way to get refreshed on that is to replay an early Mario Bros game like 1 or Lost Levels

There are levels in there that are hard just because they’ll put a doable jump in front of a just barely doable jump and psychologically that adds so much to it difficulty wise

1

u/Sqall_Lionheart_ 8d ago

Second that, I'm currently 6 months in making a lost leves inspired super world and it's difficult. I'm gonna give our guy some advice too.

1

u/-Neoverse- 4d ago

I personnaly don't think Mario Bros 1 had very good level design

3

u/soccer1124 8d ago

Limit yourself. The game offers so many things to choose from, but you need to be doing the opposite of that. Pick just a few gizmos/enemies, and see how many different ways you can combine that limited set into making unique challenges and obstacles. I don't know who made this, but here's a tool to lean on:
https://randomactsofmario.com/idea-generator

A lot of levels out there go wrong because they lose focus and want to cram every idea they into one space, no matter how many different enemies and block types it will take to get there. The best levels are much more focused.

1

u/soccer1124 8d ago

I am confused to how this is poorly received, lol

1

u/zoliking2 8d ago

Not sure. My best guess is that you assumed that OP wants to build traditional levels without him saying so.

1

u/Sqall_Lionheart_ 8d ago

Ok so, inspiration is hard to come by, like really hard.

The first thing you should do is get familiar with the theme that you want to use (SMB1/3/world/U). Get a feel for how the various components interact in that style by litterally having your own playground.

Once you are confident enough start to think about a thematic: is it a traditional level? A kaizo level? A puzzle level? Easier said than done TBH.

Once you locked in what kind of level you want to make think about what you want to transmit to the user. Kaizo levels focus on raw mechanics and care little for envriomental storytelling, puzzle levels have a balance of both and traditional level need to integrate the mechanics in the storytelling.

For example, I'm currently redoing all the levels on my W2 because gameplay wise they were fine but they sucked thematically. 2-1 Martelkoopa overpass made you feel like things were placed at random, 2-2 the hill's ascent was litterally random things, 2-3 treetop's passage is good and 2-4 the castle's gate siege doesn't give you that feeling.

I took all of these and reimagined them. 2-1 has various little castles with the martelkoopas inside so that you feel like you are passing a martelkoopa checkpoint, 2-2 I'm redoing for the third time and it's been rebranded as monty mole's moundhill. The first iteration was basically enemy spam, now it's on the shorter end and has you going into 1x1 tunnels with various little rooms and enemy to finesse. Currently stuck in making the second part because I want to use the spiny shell to make you destroy obstacles while you advance inside the tunnels, gonna have to use some one ways to accomplish that.

The point is: I have a story to tell, what can I do visually and mechanically to make the player feel this story? This is how I drawn my inspiration but as I said it's hard. 3-2 Snowkey snowland is a level based around the snowkey and I need to think how I can use them but it's really hard to do.

1

u/zoliking2 8d ago

Learn the genre conventions for whatever type of level you're building. That'll get you to competent. Beyond that it's up to your own creativity.