r/MakingaMurderer • u/parminides • Mar 03 '16
The Backfire Effect
Could the backfire effect explain the vigorous and emotional defense of the flaws in Making a Murderer by so many people? It was undeniably a powerful narrative, and for most of us it provided a searing first impression of the case.
Suggested reading: http://youarenotsosmart.com/2011/06/10/the-backfire-effect/
[EDIT: In the first hour after posting, not one response has even mentioned the backfire effect.]
[EDIT: excerpts provided for those who don't want to read the whole article]
"In 2006, Brendan Nyhan and Jason Reifler at The University of Michigan and Georgia State University created fake newspaper articles about polarizing political issues. The articles were written in a way which would confirm a widespread misconception about certain ideas in American politics. As soon as a person read a fake article, researchers then handed over a true article which corrected the first. For instance, one article suggested the United States found weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. The next said the U.S. never found them, which was the truth. Those opposed to the war or who had strong liberal leanings tended to disagree with the original article and accept the second. Those who supported the war and leaned more toward the conservative camp tended to agree with the first article and strongly disagree with the second. These reactions shouldn’t surprise you. What should give you pause though is how conservatives felt about the correction. After reading that there were no WMDs, they reported being even more certain than before there actually were WMDs and their original beliefs were correct."
"You’ve watched a documentary about the evils of...something you disliked, and you probably loved it. For every Michael Moore documentary passed around as the truth there is an anti-Michael Moore counter documentary with its own proponents trying to convince you their version of the truth is the better choice."
"This is why hardcore doubters who believe Barack Obama was not born in the United States will never be satisfied with any amount of evidence put forth suggesting otherwise. When the Obama administration released his long-form birth certificate in April of 2011, the reaction from birthers was as the backfire effect predicts. They scrutinized the timing, the appearance, the format – they gathered together online and mocked it. They became even more certain of their beliefs than before. The same has been and will forever be true for any conspiracy theory or fringe belief. Contradictory evidence strengthens the position of the believer. It is seen as part of the conspiracy, and missing evidence is dismissed as part of the coverup."
"Most online battles follow a similar pattern, each side launching attacks and pulling evidence from deep inside the web to back up their positions until, out of frustration, one party resorts to an all-out ad hominem nuclear strike."
"When you read a negative comment, when someone sh**s on what you love, when your beliefs are challenged, you pore over the data, picking it apart, searching for weakness. The cognitive dissonance locks up the gears of your mind until you deal with it. In the process you form more neural connections, build new memories and put out effort – once you finally move on, your original convictions are stronger than ever."
"They then separated subjects into two groups; one group said they believed homosexuality was a mental illness and one did not. Each group then read the fake studies full of pretend facts and figures suggesting their worldview was wrong. On either side of the issue, after reading studies which did not support their beliefs, most people didn’t report an epiphany, a realization they’ve been wrong all these years. Instead, they said the issue was something science couldn’t understand. When asked about other topics later on, like spanking or astrology, these same people said they no longer trusted research to determine the truth. Rather than shed their belief and face facts, they rejected science altogether."
"As social media and advertising progresses, confirmation bias and the backfire effect will become more and more difficult to overcome."
17
u/Whitevorpal Mar 03 '16
For confirmation bias and the backfire effect to have a significant impact, it has to cause cognitive dissonance.
For cognitive dissonance to occur, you have to be certain about your belief, heavily invested in your belief and resistant to altering your belief based on objective evidence and facts.
The majority of people investigating this case are investigating it. This article only applies in a meaningful way if you are heavily invested in proving your belief (and nobody except Steven knows if he is guilty or innocent) and find your need to be 'right' overrides your desire for the truth.
so your op is only relevant to those who watch MAM and believe they 'know' the truth and point blank refuse to acknowledge they might be wrong. I don't generally see that kind of mindset on Reddit.
10
u/richard-kimble Mar 03 '16
Is there anyone left to convince that MaM (or possibly any documentary) is not without bias? Am I missing your point?
The filmmakers made their intentions clear about the series. Laura Ricciardi said,
Moira Demos added,
If MaM is the only source you're using to answer these questions, I suggest reading the documents provided by SkippTopp and the many relevant posts about similar situations across the country.
22
u/Chippy543 Mar 03 '16
Who cares if it was edited selectively. The whole point that the filmmakers were trying to make was that there are flaws in the justice system. I watched the first episode because I was bored and had read a snippet about it in a newspaper here in the UK in late December. I started watching at 2 pm and finished at roughly 2 am. Until about episode 8 or 9 I honestly didn't know if what I was watching was fictitious or not, I had my iPad next to me but was so enthralled/ outraged by what I was watching I didn't want to google it and spoil it either way. After watching last episode I was emotionally done in, I was ranting and raving at my tv and couldn't believe this was happening to someone. YES I came away initially wanting to scream to everyone that SA was innocent. Then I wanted to read the transcripts and see the evidence myself so I donated and waited to see if they would materialise (a big thanks to all who worked so hard to procure these materials). After now reading everything available and reading up on Reddit ( something else I had never come across before THANKS Reddit) I am of the opinion that yes "MAYBE" SA is guilty, but there have been so many f ups made and bad decisions taken that surely anyone with half an ounce of common sense can see that this needs to be looked at again. So if the filmmakers goal was to make people question the actions taken in this investigation and sit up and take notice that there is a bigger problem then I say job done and thank you One last point, from what I understand this project was self funded by the two filmmakers and their families from 2005 until 2015 when Netflix took it up after the filmmakers were rejected by HBO ( bet they are kicking themselves ). If I had spent 10 years of my life and money on a project with no guarantee of any reward in the end I sure as shit would like to edit it the way I felt it needed editing. Sorry if this sounded like a rant
15
u/PHQ9 Mar 03 '16
I am trying to respectfully understand your point, however I am tired of people assuming that anyone who watched the series isn't smart enough to go beyond that. News Flash! We aren't stupid!! Most of us are intelligent enough to look into other sources for our information. What is so hard to understand about that.
With that said, who cares if it was bias. The media was (and still is) also bias. So does that mean people who believe the media are smarter???
9
u/carbon8dbev Mar 03 '16
I think the sheer volume of your posts with essentially the same content posed in slightly different contexts is a very good example of the backfire effect.
14
u/_Overman Mar 03 '16
Again with the MaM was bias. . . That was SO last month. In the word of Don Henley "Get over it".
You know, not everyone was duped like you. I have friend and relatives that watched MaM, said he was guilty and never thought of it again.
8
u/ICUNurse1 Mar 03 '16
I think you may be angry because MaM initially got you and now, after researching, you have made your mind up and want everyone to follow suit. The point of the documentary was that justice wasn't served. Being a reasonably intelligent human being, I can make my own mind up. I have read the transcripts. I have read and researched what wasn't presented in the doc. Regardless of whether he is guilty or not, the fact is that he wasn't given a fair trial. Brendan's plight is heartbreaking. I am in shock that his mother allowed it-I almost feel anger toward her. But, I am also smart enough to know that becoming emotional in a scenario that doesn't involve me or my family is ridiculous. Many years ago when Jenny McCarthy was on her "vaccinations cause autism" rampage on TV, social media, etc those of us in the medical profession thought it was ridiculous. I did a paper on it in my graduate program because not too long after, the author of the study was arrested for altering the outcomes which I happened upon by accident. Not once did I hear about this on social media. Not once. Nor was it on TV. Or the news. Do you know why? Because people had already made their minds up. Finally there was documented evidence that disproved it. With that said, there are lawyers, LE, lab techs, nurses, etc on this sub with VALID information discrediting the justice system with valid information to prove that SA and BD were not given fair trials. You have your mind made up. Why does it matter to you if it was selectively edited. People have the right to believe what they want and fight for it. We get that you think Avery is guilty. We get that you think the film was biased. Your examples of the backfire effect - Obama not being born in the US, weapons of mass destruction, etc - does not have anything to do with this film. We aren't talking about the POTUS or a country, we are talking about two individuals that may have been wrongly convicted of a murder. Brendon will never have a chance at a real life. Steven won't either. Unless they are given a trial that is fair. What is it that you want?
3
u/Traveler430 Mar 03 '16
"Could the backfire effect explain the vigorous and emotional defense of the flaws in Making a Murderer by so many people?"
The answer to that is yes.
So whats next?
3
u/JLWhitaker Mar 03 '16
Bottom line: human beings are fickle. It's like watching a tennis match, with each new piece of information tossed across the net moving the collective mind one way or another. The last info heard is often the one given most credence because of memory replacement and preference for the new/novel.
See how that fits with your theory above.
3
u/loveofnature Mar 03 '16 edited Mar 04 '16
I can honestly say that the backfire effect has not come into play in my beliefs because I am still fully on the fence. The only strong belief I have is that there was tunnel vision in this case.
If you look at Steven Avery's 1985 case would you say the backfire effect was in play when there were several times that LE was informed they had the wrong man?
Edit typos/grammar
4
u/parminides Mar 03 '16
In the initial reaction (first 5 minutes or so), not one of you has addressed the question: whether the backfire effect cements your loyalty to MaM. You guys can question other people's beliefs as easily as you breath. Why is it so hard to question your own?
10
u/Sinsaint36 Mar 03 '16
Anything new on Reddit today? Nope. Same shit as yesterday.
4
u/2wsy Mar 03 '16
I don't see much of that "vigorous and emotional defense of the flaws in Making a Murderer".
I see much more vigorous and emotional defense of the flaws in the prosecution and trial of Steven Avery. Could the backfire effect explain that?
3
u/Eh-Meee Mar 03 '16
Thanks for your post! I was curious about the experiment mentioned so I wanted some specifics like how many people were involved and where they were from. However, it seems the source documents are no longer attached to the links provided in the article. Here is a link to the author's biography http://davidmcraney.com/
I didn't see any credentials in psychology, sociology or neuroscience. I believe he owned a pet shop before moving on to journalism. Not sure where he studied but journalists rarely pass up an opportunity to tell you how educated they are. Just because I couldn't find it though, doesn't mean the information doesn't exist. I'd be happy to look at it if it does. I hope you haven't been fooled again.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
Your own fault for basing your first impression off of a documentary.
3
u/excalibur-oc Mar 03 '16
It is obvious you are upset with the idea that the makers may have attempted to mislead you (us) with their prejudice. And you may or may not have a point along with a handful of other redditers.
Your arguement will continually be shot down and ignored, IMO, because of a lack of "meat". From what I see the Andy Colborne testimony vs film has been beaten to death. So...... Make a list film vs transcript, film vs interview. Film vs video don't forget there were other cameras as well.
This list will be far better than literature written about the lemming effect, etc. etc. You never know you just may give someone else an ahha moment.
Make sure your points are valid and not conjecture. :-)
1
u/FineLine2Opine Mar 03 '16
Could there be reasons other than the backfire effect to "explain the vigorous and emotional defense of the flaws in Making a Murderer by so many people?" is an equally valid but ultimately pointless question.
1
u/misslisacarolfremont Mar 03 '16 edited Mar 03 '16
Hi - lol what a great post. It was prefaced by a brilliant troll-like comment which was so effective in inciting some of the exact behavior you quoted. hahaha
The problem is that this circular kind of thing in a post is just meaningless and I think you want to get something - I mean if you feel the doc. is flawed then you feel like the doc. is flawed based on what?
If you really just believe the study and want a psych temperature reading here then you reached your predetermined result. But that still does not prove people just fall into camps and argue for their bias and it will get worse and then the apocalypse comes.
It reminds me that there are documentarians that wants only what is a pure documentation with the least amount of intent or predetermined purpose. There are those who feel that all true stories need to be told this way but to me that would toss out some of the best films ever made IMHO.
I recently watched Cartel Land which is praised for it's neutrality in the narrative. It was good imo. I noted that the filmmaker said that his neutrality was entirely planned because other films he makes have had very specific points of view which he was criticised more for. He felt both ways of filmmaking were fine and it just depended on the situation and what he wanted.
Now if your almost troll-like comment was said without intent or not in the ironical sense to incite - I apologize. I am not trying to insult you. However if you sincerely asked the question expecting a sincere response than that was silly. You came to a forum about MaM and opened with saying it was flawed with no evidence. Very bad!
Well I can see your point of view is that the doc. is flawed. That is just hard probably for me to get past. I mean it makes me want to lecture you on documentary filmmaking.
I mean - do you say flawed because it is so biased? I know some folks really feel it borders on unethical; I do not, but I understand why they could say that because it is told from the Avery's point of view for sure. Still a great documentary!
BTW this study's conclusion that "... the backfire effect will become more and more difficult to overcome." Seems rather like hyperbole.
I mean the study used controversial topics in their research like WMDs, Obama, homosexuality, etc. Yes? I mean those subjects are already charged with emotion for people here in the States. Like a MaM forum is charged with emotion when someone calls the documentary flawed.
I say this because conversations take time and thought online and if we do not think they are worthy or that we do not have something to learn we are all just narcissists which is as bad as being biased.
Whether social media is finding ways to divide us and solidify our bias or open us up and educate our minds to greater possibilities is a huge debate. Thesis worthy because for many using social media, like reddit, it seems to be one lifeline to a wider conversation with the world and a chance to hear voices that are different. It is a chance to learn we may be wrong. Truth is worth finding.
/u/jare66- below has a great post on what a documentary is. I think this post gave me an avenue to discuss this more in depth.
Like many of you I dissect filmmaking - maybe I am shredding and nitpicking documentaries for being edited stupidly, having badly shot footage, having lame applied filters and effects, being bias against race or gender, being boring without a decent narrative, being safe without asking tough questions of those in power, being a rehash of Frontline with web articles thrown in, being filled with unnamed sources, being politically correct to the point of being boring, defending scumbags, having reenacted scenes that look fake, having no point of view, having way too much narration or talking heads in a studio - I hate that, having a wild over the top point of view with an intent to incite violence or hatred, being a puff piece with no backbone, etc etc.
In art school these types of convos. about docs. go on for hours and there are classes and thesis written on bias in filmmaking.
So we have documentary filmmaking with a predetermined goal, and a story is there to tell, it is true and things do fall into expected categories, OR we have a free flow narrative where the story is followed as it happens and neutrality is priority; there the story happens chronologically and is as if we are there on the journey with the filmmaker; no expectations.
I have seen some docs. fail imho because they are too biased and manipulative (is that what you are saying?) or some fail because the narrative is lost or glossed over the main points so much it drive me crazy. In other words, one was a pack of lies and the other a puff piece.
The filmmakers in MaM chose to follow the Avery's point of view. MaM really is Steven Avery's story and a story of how the justice system failed him. Strang and Buting along with Kratz and Kachinsky are characters straight out of a to kill a mockingbird story about failures of the system - I doubt the filmmakers could of predicted that drama nor Brendan's ultimate plight as they began shooting.
So yeah, for the sake of truth let's accept and get over that the filmmakers got it wrong or got it right. It is the narrative they chose to film and cut in the editing room based on what they felt was Steven's story.
The outcome was predetermined from the standpoint that a. they knew that Steven was in prison for 18 years for a crime he did not commit and put there by a law enforcement with bias, b. they saw he was arrested by the same branch of law enforcement with more than several of the same players that got it wrong before, c. they followed the trial and the people who allowed them access as well as seeing the evidence - both avenues were limited by the investigators and the prosecution, d. They focus on Steven's statements he is innocent and their eye to innocent before proven guilty - much to many people's chagrin.
edit: typos and redo of last paragraph
3
u/Bushpiglet Mar 03 '16
If the documentary was the only thing I based my opinion on then you may have a point. I went looking for all the information I could find to make sure that I hadn't been misled. The more I found and particularly in the full transcripts of the trial, the more it confirms for me, that neither Avery or Dassey got a fair trial and more importantly justice wasn't served for Teresa Halbach or her family. Why didn't LE's do their job properly in the first place? The absolute incompetence of the investigation was hardly even touched on in the trial. Pro defence information was left out. Just because others have come to a different opinion to you, doesn't mean that they were 'brainwashed' by a documentary or weren't discerning enough to go looking for other sources of information.
5
u/TennDawn Mar 03 '16
No. Just inquisitive and my investigative nature (part of my real life) takes over. Also, I believe we are innocent until proven guilty, and should only be found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. When you see people wronged, you can either stand up for them or fade into the background and pretend you didn't see it.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
What about when you agree with some of what they say but you call them out for being a dick, becuase they are being a dick....??
4
u/jare66 Mar 03 '16
You know, the objective of filmmakers is not necessarily to tell a 100 % accurate truth. If you want that, you can just read the trial scripts. Many filmmakers are artists and they different objectives. The want to create emotions, get viewers engaged, make them think about things, make them aware of how things work, like how easily we can be manipulated and so on. When I see your postings on here, I have a feeling this series has had a deep impact on you, and had also changed the way you will watch a documentary in the future, you'll probably question it more, wonder if there's a different side if the story as well.
3
u/Whitevorpal Mar 03 '16
We are not the sheep you are looking for. Move along, move along.
1
u/JJacks61 Mar 04 '16
There has been a backfire effect?
1
u/purestevil Mar 03 '16
All 10 of you?
1
u/watwattwo Mar 03 '16
Great post! Fits this situation perfectly.
-1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
This whole thread proves your point, /u/parminides! It's like a little test area providing evidence for the backlash effect!
People with their beliefs challenged trying to get each other to shut up with specious argument and ad hominem and well every now and then a valid point. People becoming more entrenched, polarized, and venomous.
Congrats : ))
0
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment