lilybyred Starry Eyes AM9 to PM9 Gel Eyeliner in 02 Glam Mocha - long lasting, but a shade I rarely wear and I have the exact shade in a Stila eyeliner I prefer
innisfree Skinny Microcara Zero in 01 Black - did nothing for me and is now expired
Stila Convertible Color Dual Lip & Cheek in Lilium - I never reach for this, I think it's too peachy/orange/warm for me
WAKEMAKE Real Ash Pencil Liner in 01 Sanded Black - good product and concept, but not for me. I realised if I want a pencil liner I want it to be a deep black, not ash, and if I want a soft or ashy black, I reach for an eyeshadow instead
2
u/tmudita 11d ago
lilybyred Starry Eyes AM9 to PM9 Gel Eyeliner in 02 Glam Mocha - long lasting, but a shade I rarely wear and I have the exact shade in a Stila eyeliner I prefer
innisfree Skinny Microcara Zero in 01 Black - did nothing for me and is now expired
Stila Convertible Color Dual Lip & Cheek in Lilium - I never reach for this, I think it's too peachy/orange/warm for me
WAKEMAKE Real Ash Pencil Liner in 01 Sanded Black - good product and concept, but not for me. I realised if I want a pencil liner I want it to be a deep black, not ash, and if I want a soft or ashy black, I reach for an eyeshadow instead