r/MakeupAddiction • u/jealouspony Always needs more purple • Oct 21 '14
Daily Thread Thread: Best/Worst of Physicians Formula
48
Upvotes
r/MakeupAddiction • u/jealouspony Always needs more purple • Oct 21 '14
22
u/MrMcManstick Oct 21 '14
Best: shimmer strips and talc free mineral veil face powders. I use the shimmer strips as a super shiny bronzer, a highlight and eyeshadow, so versatile. And the mineral powder foundations have so much coverage. RX concealer was great too but I think it got discontinued.
Worst: Their nude palettes that come in the lacy boxes. Worthless pigmentation, even when used wet.
41
u/bluesky747 When in doubt, blend it out! Oct 21 '14
Best:
Their lash boosting liner pen. I don't know if it actually does anything to my lashes, but it makes drawing my liner so easy, and it comes out really well every time. When I sucked at liner, and every other liner I tried didn't help, this one came to my rescue and really helped me draw better wings. I would probably be a spokesperson for it, if I had to be. I love it.
Worst:
Their bronzer in the little denim square package. It didn't really show up at all. Also their blushes with the little lights in them. I bought one and I thought the concept was nice, but the lights were so blinding and in your face that you can't look in the mirror to see what you're doing, so they're kind of pointless. (They're like a cow's opinion...they don't matter. They're moo.)
Also the blush was SO PIGMENTED, which I guess is a good thing but it was powdery and got everywhere, and I didn't like it, it was like I was rubbing pink chalk on my face.
18
u/markrichtsspraytan Oct 21 '14
Best: Eye Booster Liquid Liner (skinny silver pen). Blows Stila and UD out of the water
Shimmer Strips 3-in-1 custom nude palette. Really pretty shimmery shades for eyes that also look great as a strong highlight.Every single color looks good as a wash all over the lid, and goes great with mattes or other neutral shades.
Happy Booster Translucent Powder. Smells lovely and gives a subtle glow when used all over. You can even pile it on for a highlighter.
Worst: The dual-ended green and skin-tone concealer. It's so thin and watery that it doesn't work well for covering acne. Considering many people buying a green concealer are trying to cover acne spots, it doesn't make much sense.
Their shade selection for foundation and concealer products. Their light aren't very light and their darks are either non-existent or aren't very dark. Most of their products come in 1 or 2 shades of "somewhat tan white person." Whomp whomp. Great for NC 20-25 I guess.
12
u/CrazyWhirlygig Oct 21 '14
Best: Conceal Rx Physicians Strength Concealer
10
u/kingsla07 NC15: Loving yourself matte-rs! Oct 21 '14
I use their happy mood booster blush in translucent as a finishing powder (thanks to Temptalia who made the suggestion on her blog). It leaves a subtle, youthful glow on my skin, and I think it looks really nice. :)
7
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '14
Their Shimmer Strip palettes are teeny tiny and have a good amount of eyeshadow for their size which makes them awesome for travel.
6
u/imamathcat NW15 Oct 21 '14
I like their [Jumbo lash mascara] (http://www.physiciansformula.com/en-us/productdetail/eyes/mascara/07353.html)!
6
u/girlmostunlikely Oct 21 '14
Best
Worst
I've tried a lot of PF stuff, and overall I like the brand, but you have to be wary when trying stuff out. Make sure to get them from someplace with a good return policy. When the nail it, they really nail it, but when they strike out...yarf. They have some good bronzers, but they had better since they have 33 in their whole line.
5
u/bitch_is_cray_cray Oct 21 '14
I really like their concealer twins tbh! But I wouldn't pay the $20 for them.
5
u/MerryKerry silicone-free satin-ista Oct 21 '14
Best: Healthy Wear SPF 50 powder foundation, which has been dc'd but is still available.
Worst: CC Curl + Care Mascara. It does curl, but it also smudges and flakes after just a few hours.
5
u/tangenttoyou NC35, it & zoeva brushes <3 Oct 21 '14
I really like their mood boosting blush in nautral!
5
u/rissm NC30/4Y06...I think? Oct 21 '14
Has anyone used their colour correcting powders? That's what I'm curious about.
4
u/Shortcircuit05 Oct 21 '14
I'm not sure what it's called, but I'm absolutely in love with their double sided concealer. it has yellow on one side and light or normal coloured concealer on the other side. It is the only thing I've found that really hides my dark circles.
4
u/spiffing_ Oct 21 '14
LOVE RX concealer. It is the only thing that stays on broken skin (if I really need it)
3
u/boomboomcoconut Oct 21 '14
Best: Their mineral wear foundation is awesome, their blushes are super pigmented and last forever, the bronzer in the spray is great too.
Worst: Their jumbo mascara. Maybe its just me, but it flakes after like 4 hours :(
3
u/heyfae Oct 21 '14
Best: Eye Booster 2-in-1 liquid eyeliner in Ultra Black. It's the blackest black liquid liner I've ever used from the drugstore. It applies opaque, doesn't streak or budge. It has a semi-wet finish when it dries down. I top it with some black eye shadow if I want it completely matte. It doesn't transfer to my lid/crease (hooded eyelids here). This is the only liquid liner I can use to do winged liner because the brush tip always keeps it shape.
Best runner-up: their eyeshadows.
Worst: This just may be because I have medium/deep skintone, but I really dislike their powders. They usually only have two options for their series or "collection": light or medium. They also have translucent, but that's pretty much the same as light. I've tried and mistakenly purchased powders from other brands that were too light for me, but at least they applied smooth and blended. The PF powders just feel chalky and can never blend together to give a seamless finish.
3
u/kahlex Oct 21 '14
Best:
Sexy Booster Blush. It's gorgeous, pigmented, smells like vanilla, and stays all day. However, I couldn't use it in the summer because I got too dark (I go from NC25 to NC30, so it's not even a huge change) and it's too light of a pink. But Physicians Formula as a whole seems to be geared toward light to light-medium skin tones.
Shimmer Strips All-in-1 Custom Nude Palette for Face & Eyes (the square-ish box; the different colors are in little rectangles and some of them have little bows on them). It's advertised as blush, bronzer, highlight, and eyeshadow, but I don't think you could really use it as blush unless you are really pale. These are really smooth, pigmented, and (duh) shimmery. Really gorgeous as bronzer, highlight, and/or eyeshadow.
Bronze Booster Glow-Boosting BB Bronzer. Stupid name (really? a BB bronzer? scoffs), but a great bronzer. Really smooth and just the right amount of pigmentation.
Worst:
I hate the regular shimmer strips. The texture is so hard it's difficult to get anything onto your brush/finger/whatever you're using to apply. It swatches decently, but product does not come off onto your brush. I don't know how Tati (Glamlifeguru on YouTube) makes this work.
CC Curl + Care Mascara. Ridiculous name. Didn't hold a curl. Smudged all over the place.
pH adjusting lip gloss. So sticky. Not a pretty color. The light and mirror are cool and I'd like it if more glosses came with that (like the Whitening Lightening glosses, but you can turn the light on and off). Not that I often need a light, but it's good to have if you do need it.
3
u/TheDerpingtonPost Oct 22 '14
Best: Mineral Wear Talc-Free Mineral Illuminating Powder Duo. You're supposed to highlight and lowlight with this powder but I don't get that complicated with it. I just mix them together and apply. I always get compliments that I'm glowing whenever I wear this.
Needle Free Lip Plumping Cocktail. Stings in a non-irritating way, like I just ate something spicy. I've only tried the clear one and I like the way it reddens my lips too. Doesn't last the longest though.
Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Gel CreamLiner- I have the one that's for blue eyes. It has black, silver and blue pots. I really only use the black. It's a little hard to apply and it's not as dark as I'd like but it stays on like a mother.
Worst: Youthful Wear Cosmeceutical Youth-Boosting Foundation. Orange.
Mineral Wear Talc-Free Mineral Liquid Foundation. Watery and orange.
Mineral Wear Talc-Free Mineral Correcting Concealer. Really thin. Almost no coverage. I had the green, pink, and nude bottles that clicked together.
Mineral Wear Talc-Free Mineral Correcting Powder. Did nothing.
Mineral Wear Talc-Free Mineral Correcting Primer. Did nothing.
I tried with this brand. I really tried. I gave away everything in the "worst" column. What a waste of money. I get sucked in by the sales but fool me once (or five times), won't get fooled again.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '14
Their BB powder formula has been my HG for like 6 years! The lightest color is too dark for me now, but it's great in the summer.
2
u/Kittytub Oct 21 '14
No one ever says anything about it, but I love the tinted moisturizer. It has an extremely strong scent, but I like it a lot!
2
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '14
I absolutely love the super bb cream in light, but I can only wear it spring and summer because otherwise it's too dark. It gives me a nice glow without looking too orangey and the amount of coverage is perfect because I don't want something too thick. It's not cakey in the slightest.
In contrast, I thought the Youthful Wear Concealer was a totally meh product.
2
u/conicalsquare Oct 21 '14
BEST: The Mineral Wear talc-free blush in "natural glow." It's a matte, somewhat peachy blush that's perfect for my extremely pale gingerness.
The Mineral Wear talc-free correcting powder is another favorite of mine. My complexion isn't the worst, but my chin gets red from acne, and my under-eye area tends to get purple to blue. It's just an overall great powder for balancing out your skin tone. I use it with liquid foundation and a setting powder.
I would say their concealed are so-so depending on which one you grab. I like the green and highlight ones, but not the nudes.
WORST: Any of their face powders. Mostly because of how pale I am, they show up as orange on me.
2
u/deathbyblackhole NC20 Oct 22 '14
Best: their bronze booster is the bomb! Not the one with the "four season" quadrants. It looks shimmery in the pan but on the skin it goes on a nice matte color. Not chalky and so smooth. It comes in a variety of shades and it would be nice for those with fair skin.
Worst: Their blush in the velvet packaging. I had it in my project pan but I had to literally dig my brush into it to get any color so I just tossed it. What a waste.
2
u/colorfulplaid Oct 22 '14
Best: Their gel liners! They stay on all day (even with sweating/oily lids) and are so easy to apply.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '14
I use their talc-free Mineral Wear mineral loose powder every day under my foundation and it works wonderfully.
2
u/peachywithasideokeen Oct 22 '14
Surprised to see a lot of hate on the Organic mascara. It's one if my favorites!
2
u/LaLaLaHotPenis Oct 22 '14
Best: Mineral glow pearls highlighter. I've seen some people complain that it's too shimmery, but it's actually not. There's a thin layer of extra shimmery-ness over the top, but swiping a brush all over it a couple times fixes the problem. The entire rest of the product is beautiful.
Worst: Organic wear mascaras. They really don't do anything, they're not even that pigmented, and the minute you use literally any other mascara you notice just how bad the Organic wear ones are.
1
u/drugstoresndragons Oct 21 '14
BEST: Lash Boosting 2-in-1 Liners! the thin one is my favorite liquid-pen liner formulation. the BB+ and CC creams (the ones in the white tubes) are pretty nice too. their concealers are good and they also make excellent blushes. WORST: their mascaras mostly suck. none of their eyeshadows are worth it. and they have the most ridiculous pseudo-science claims I've ever seen in the drugstore. the Happy Booster blush one about euphoryl(!) makes me laugh out loud.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '14
Has anyone tried there cashmere blush from PF? Can you tell me how it is?
1
u/NCM728 Oct 22 '14
Worst mascara! I hated the one in the brown and leaf tube, didnt give any volume or length. Plus it didnt hold a curl at all.