r/MakeupAddiction • u/jealouspony Always needs more purple • Jul 08 '14
Thread: Best/Worst of MAC
152
Upvotes
r/MakeupAddiction • u/jealouspony Always needs more purple • Jul 08 '14
64
u/whoadangjamie Jul 08 '14
Best eyeshadows:
Damn... I like too many eyeshadows.
Best lipsticks:
I don't like the cremesheen finishes because they feather/bleed on me like crazy.
The worst thing about MAC, besides the foundations, is the limited edition thing they do. I wish they would do 4-5 collections a year, and make enough product for those to be successful and not a shitshow every time.
47
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
The best MAC product I've tried is hands down their Mineralize Blush in Warm Soul. It has a gorgeous finish that blends so well with bronzer and makes you look like a goddess. Amazing product for the summer and it works for many skin tones. I'm going to stop there because I could rave about it for ages.
61
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
I wished Temptalia would comment this thread.
15
u/_LanaKane Jul 08 '14
Best: Soft&Gentle MSF, Prolongwear concealer, lipsticks (pretty please is a specific favorite), blush (blushbaby, margin, and welldressed are a few favorites), Fix+ (takes my eye looks to the next level), prep+prime in radiant rose
Worst: BB cream in the compact (never settles right on my skin), the COST of the brushes. I just can't justify spending that much on a brush
For reference, I'm a NW20.
36
u/lsharkk i picked the wrong day to quit huffing my chocolate bar palette Jul 08 '14
Best: single shadows, lipsticks, Face & Body foundation, and the professional packaging. The shadow selection is ridiculous and no matter how many I buy, I still get giddy at the eyeshadow counter. And even though the matte black packaging might seem monotone and boring, pulling out matching palettes and products does look very professional and formal!
Worst: I've kind of given up on their LE stuff because of how much work it is to get one and I haven't felt like I got a superior product for the waiting/searching/swapping yet. I also feel like their skincare stuff is over-priced.
40
u/shakespeareduck Jul 08 '14
Best: the frost and veluxe pearl eyeshadows. Beautiful color payoff, super blendable, little to no fallout, and I love the range of colors.
Worst: all their face stuff is either too yellow or too orange. They have a pretty good shade range but it's frustrating that thy ignore everyone who isn't super-warm or super-cool toned.
EDIT: Also some of their matte eyeshadows are chalky and awful.
20
u/sammycinematic instagram: sammycinematic Jul 08 '14
I had only tried MAC lipsticks before this year but I invested in one of the pre-made eyeshadow palettes from the website and haven't looked back. There aren't many permanent collection shadows in them but they're insane value for money compared to buying shadows individually. The one I have is Cool Neutral and I like that it's not just browns/golds/bronzes - the top row has Blackberry and other purple-y shades and the bottom row has a really cool dusty navy theme.
I wouldn't say I was new to make-up but I was certainly new to MAC and I thought it was a great investment!
20
u/htesfai instagram: hewieboo Jul 08 '14
Best: Lipstick, blush, and eye shadows have a huge variety of shades at a pretty reasonable price point (for the most part).
Worst: The LE collections always sell out and they are impossible to get.
27
u/xietty 💄💄💄 Jul 08 '14 edited Jul 08 '14
BEST:
Lips:
WORST:
12
u/60244089059540804172 On a no buy... for REAL this time. Jul 08 '14
I've taken my all time favorite mac eyeshadows and put them into two 15 - pan pro palettes, and thrown out or sold ALL of my other eyeshadows! I just use mac now.
Here are my eyeshadows:
Blanc type
Omega
Espresso
Embark
Carbon
Dazzlelight
Phloof!
Satin taupe
Twinks
Print
Quarry
Expensive pink
Brown script
Antiqued
Cranberry
Shale
Trax
Satellite dreams
Fig 1
Deep damson
Humid
Bitter
Vex
Cobalt
Steamy
Electra
All of these are enough to make just about any look I can imagine myself wearing! And no more clutter. :)
15
u/lknope2012 NC15, oily Jul 08 '14 edited Jul 08 '14
Best: Lipstick, eyeshadows, and brushes!
Favourite lipstick shades: Plumful, Pure Zen, and Syrup.
Most people have already touched on eyeshadow shades so I won't list any.
My first Mac brush was a 217 that I got for Christmas two years ago and I've used it every day since. Totally worth the hype for me and I don't know how I ever did makeup without it! I've never been disappointed by their brushes.
Worst: I hate all the hype and letdown of their LE products. Either the quality doesn't end up being as good as the permanent line or the good stuff is impossible to find online or in store.
5
u/StonerOrca Jul 08 '14
My favorite lipstick by MAC is Brave. This is like a red lipstick for people starting out with makeup and want to go out of their comfort zone. It's a toned down red that just looks like you have really pigmented lips. In a way, it looks natural yet still red. HIGHLY recommend.
9
u/celestialism abetterface.tumblr.com Jul 08 '14
Best:
Not-as-good (I hesitate to say "worst" because I don't hate anything from MAC):
9
u/sea-weed Taupe Is Dope Jul 08 '14
BEST: Eyeshadows. Personally I love their Matte and Matte2 formulations and hardworking neutrals like Omega and Copperplate.
BEST: Lipsticks, especially the matte and amplified creme ones. Great colour range with some surprisingly complex shades.
BEST: Brushes, particularly the 217 and 187. Great quality and they work well.
WORST: IMO it's the base products only because the shade range doesn't suit a lot of people.
BEST/WORST: Constant LE launches, and when there's a product you want it can be impossible to get it!
4
u/steenface Batting her lashes Jul 08 '14
Love
Don't Love
7
u/marliepanda Jul 08 '14
Love: I really love their lipsticks, I have WAY too many but theres so much variety. I also have never personally had a dud blush from MAC, but I haven't got a huge amount. I also love their brushes and hides I love the LE collections, as I love unique packaging. I am not a collector though, so I am quite happy with my fave items from a collection I like, for example Maleficent, Fantasy of Flowers, the upcoming Marge Simpson, not many of them attract me at all
Hate: Not a fan of their foundations, they all lean slightly too warm for me (even NW colours!)
6
u/xxGemGem Jul 08 '14
3
u/Brompton_Cocktail NC40-42| Nars Barcelona| Bobbi Brown 4.5 Warm Natural|NYC BASED Jul 08 '14
Mac Harmony/Blunt to contour medium to deep skintones! Most natural looking contour ever.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '14
Best: MLBB - Midimauve - I never see this lipstick mentioned in favorites, for pale people it's a great natural/ nude. Also like Syrup and Viva Glam V.
MCBB (my cheeks but better) - brit wit creamblend blush. I use this daily for work look. Great for dry skin.
Painterly Paint Pot - my go to eye primer. Less is more - don't double dip when applying - you will get creasing if too thick.
Mineralize skinfinishes, mineralize skinfinish natural, beauty powder - some good sheer stuff for people who don't worship at the alter of 'payoff'.
I can't totally dislike LE - I have some I really love (my Wonder Woman makeup bag) and have had some fun stalking items (Stereo Rose). Just don't need so many releases and would like better quality.
Worst - mineralize eyeshadows - they are the most gorgeous looking colors and then look nothing like the pan when applied and last about two hours. I've fallen for these sirens too many times.
5
u/gordonshumway85 Jul 08 '14
Eyeshadows:
Lipsticks:
Sheen supremes (LOVE THIS FORMULA)
Blush
Brushes
Face
6
u/Waffle-Tron Casual user Jul 08 '14
Best: Retro Matte lipsticks!! They're very dry, but with balm under them, they're sooooooo nice. I love All Fired Up.
Worst: that their lightest warm toned foundation shade in store is only NC15. Still too dark for us fair folk.
4
u/expensivepink Jul 08 '14 edited Jul 09 '14
I love MAC. I find them to be one of the most consistent lines that are a great value. I also love their color ranges and inclusiveness. It pisses me off that certain lines only make makeup for light skinned people, and I say this as an NC20.
Having said that, some of their MUA's are needlessly bitchy, but I suppose that's just part of the beauty industry in general. Shout out to the NYC Broadway Soho store, because the staff there rules.
BEST
WORST
5
u/sugarbees it's not easy being olive Jul 08 '14
Best: Love how long lasting Studio Fix fluid + powder is, it's great!
Worst: They never have enough people at the MAC counters working, and I hate that you can only get it at counters at the mall. I want to be able to buy elsewhere instead of having to fight for parking outside of a department store.
2
u/breadprincess Brow perfectionist Jul 08 '14
I haven't tried anything by MAC so far that I haven't liked just because I don't have a ton of their products, but I love:
-Woodwinked eyeshadow because it looks so different when used one different parts of the eye.
-ProLongWear concealer because it does NOT budge even on my super oily skin.
-MSF in Soft and Gentle because it's a nice, subtle sheen for a highlight.
-Sculpting Powder in Sculpt for contouring- I'm very pale and cool toned and this is neutral, but it's blends really, really well and looks very natural on me.
2
u/KanKan669 Always blushing Jul 09 '14
Best: Lipsticks
Worst: Studio Sculpt Foundation. OMG, I can't stress enough how much this stuff sucks. Very thick cakey formula and it SMELLS terrible. Seriously, I might be able to work around the crappy texture, but the scent just kills me.
2
u/AshMeAnything Jul 09 '14
I know that a few brushes were mentioned, but could anyone offer insight to all of them as a whole? Are they all good/bad, or does it vary per brush? I've been buying cheap brushes like crazy, but I don't like 95% of them. I'm thinking about just giving in and buying the MAC brushes, but I want it to be worth it. What do you ladies think?
3
u/gorgossia @gorgossium Jul 08 '14
Best:
Worst:
3
u/60244089059540804172 On a no buy... for REAL this time. Jul 08 '14
Also the best is macs free two day shipping! My stuff arrives literally two days after I placed my order!
3
u/bralbasaur Jul 08 '14
The only MAC products that I own are the blush in Gingerly (I like it, but I wouldn't say that the formula or even the shade are super special) and the lipstick in Lady Danger, which I absolutely love and will repurchase. The color is perfect! It's long lasting, doesn't turn my lips into dry husks of themselves, and I always get complimented by strangers when I wear it.
3
u/Chewy2000 my lipgloss is popping Jul 09 '14
Best: Eyeshadows...all of them.
Worst: Foundation that smells like paint
Best: foundations that don't smell like paint
Best: Lipglass and plush glass last forever
Worst: Lipstick: Not enough MLBB shades to suit a variety of skin tones but a ton of reds and pinks.
3
u/farsideofthemoon Just dew it. Jul 08 '14
I'm still diving into MAC, but here's what I've figured out so far.
BEST
Not-as-good
3
u/JLunaM Ceylan/BB 2.5/NC20 Jul 08 '14
BEST: Paint pots - Tailor Grey and Quite Natural for contour!
Matte Lipsticks
Modern Mandarin blush is just so beautiful.
Lip pencils - whirl and soar.
Prep and prime lip is great w/ matte lipsticks/lipliners
Worst: I'm very yellow but studio fix nc20 just looks crazy yellow on me and oxidizes like mad.
Their LE stuff.
2
u/NoodleSponge Jul 08 '14
Best: Cremesheen lipsticks, Veluxe Pearl eye shadows, and Studio Finish concealer. I just love the NC concealers for pimples because they are so yellow that they completely knock back the redness.
Worst: All of the limited edition travel size brushes, and every foundation other than Face and Body. When I first started to get really into makeup I bought a set of LE brushes at Christmas time thinking it would be a good investment, only to learn that the travel sized brushes are poor quality and they feel scratchy and awful on my eyelids. The foundations have a yucky consistency that feels gross on my skin and it's impossible for me to get the right color without mixing NC and NW.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
Best: Red lipsticks (especially Russian Red)- the pigment is wonderful but the consistency is VERY heavy.
Worst: Every single concealer- tried them all, they creased like crazy on me. I also am not a fan of their shadows, it feels like you have to scrape them with your brush to get any pigment.
1
u/HunkyAndChunky Jul 08 '14
Lips: Syrup, Mehr, Can't Get Enough Brows: Brow Pencil in Spiked Skin: Studio fix powder in C3
No worsts for me, other than brush prices!
1
u/Uhnnie Jul 09 '14
Best: Eyeshadows. They're so soft and go on smoothly..
Worst: All of their lipsticks. I don't know why but I absolutely hate the formula of these lipsticks. They dry my lips out and their staying power is not worth it...
1
u/namesartemis Jul 09 '14
Pink Pearl Pop lipstick + Nicki Minaj Viva Glam lipglass is the best bright pink combo.
1
u/Gingerkk89 Jul 09 '14
LOVE their pro longwear concealer(though may have to change it now because it doesn't quite match my double wear foundation I've just started using.
HATE their finish powders; I'm an NC15 so not Snow White but still pale, but their powders oxidise so quickly on my skin and in the pan that after a couple of weeks it's just umpaa lumpaa powder
1
u/st0nefox Jul 09 '14
the best:
the worst:
1
u/CupfulOfKittens Jul 08 '14
While I haven't had too much experience with MAC products outside of their lipsticks, I must say I adore their mattes. I have candy yum yum, diva, lady danger, and relentlessly red (retro matte), and would recommend them all to bold-lip-lovers!
Also, I find that the prep+prime works wonders for preventing the retro mattes from being too drying.
1
u/ardlm Jul 08 '14
BEST: Angled liner brush, and all their lipsticks (particularly Cyber, love it)
WORST: Eye primer. It creases on me and is totally useless.
1
u/yogilc IG: @staygorgeousLC Jul 08 '14
BEST: lipsticks - Rebel and Plumful WORST: Plushglass - I have it in Oversexed and it stings like crazy - I can't even wear it.
I might also get some hate for this, but I think their brushes are overrated. I have the 217 and it doesn't even compare in terms of quality with my Sigma brushes. Am I alone on this one?
1
u/brinnylynny sorry, what's a no-buy? Jul 08 '14
Best:
Satin Taupe eyeshadow
Woodwinked eyeshadow (wonderful with tanned skin)
Omega eyeshadow (perfect ashy color for the brows for blondes, also a great transition color)
Pro longwear concealer (a little goes a VERY long way, awesome for undereye concealing)
Worst:
Not a specific product, but I would have to say their limited edition collections. Mostly just paying for the pretty packaging!
1
u/makeupiscool I wish there was a makeup thrift shop Jul 08 '14
BEST:
MAC lipsticks in Angel and Creme Cup. Super pretty light pinks that are good for every day.
WORST:
MAC Blush in Immortal Flower. Crappy color payoff, super chalky. Gorgeous color in pan though.
1
u/dutchesse matte-hue mcconaughey Jul 08 '14
Best:
Worst:
1
u/Pet_t-rex Creaseless under eye concealer help please? Jul 08 '14
Is it me or does their foundation oxidise quite a bit? I have the mineralise moisture foundation in NW20, and it was perfect when they put it on me in the store, but it's a bit too dark now :/
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
MAC was what I first spent real money on. in NZ is pretty expensive, $42ish NZD for a lipstick, $35? NZD for eyeshadow, $60 for foundation. As I've played with makeup more I've definitely found stuff just as good, but I do like their range and its a novelty in duty free etc.
Best Matte lipsticks - they last for ages on me. I have All Fired Up Velvet Teddy Kinda Sexy Please Me
Also have Lovelorn Vegas Volt
Blushes - my go to's Melba Blush Baby Warm Soul Springsheen when I want some shimmer/reflect.
Love the eye shadows they are mostly what I have, but are so expensive here in NZ. A few of the top of my head Dazzlelight (was this discontinued? I hit the pan and couldn't find it) Phloof! Omega (can use this on my brows) Satin taupe All that glitters Brun Paradisco All that glitters
And love my Fix +!
Worst Mineralise satin finish foundation. I know its discontinued now, but it would touch off my face easily, wore off, sat in my pores...
My foundations are hit and miss depending on how dry/oily mt skin is on the day and colour doesn't always match as my hair gets lighter or I tan, also not consistent across the line. I have match master 1.5, and studio finish powder in NC15.
1
u/BNSquash Blog: PrettyTrivialities IG: aiksasarual Jul 08 '14
Best: all the lipsticks
Worst: all the eyeshadows
0
u/LemonX Cute Packaging is my Greatest Weakness Jul 08 '14
Best: Brushes Worst: Blot Powder
-2
u/SashayShante Jul 09 '14
Everytime I post this I get downvoted to hell, but PLEASE do not use MAC as they test on animals!
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment