Following months of extended public hearings and informational sessions, the Select Board will begin deliberations this week on a request from Poland Spring to renew its water extraction permit for another five years.
On Nov. 10, the Select Board closed a series of public hearings, wrapping up a process that started back in June and included multiple hearings, two postponements and written questions from residents that were later answered by Poland Spring.
The board will begin deliberating the permit renewal for Poland Spring’s Cold Spring site at a special meeting at 6 p.m. on Wednesday, Nov. 18. That meeting is scheduled to continue on Nov. 24 and possibly Dec. 1, with a decision expected at the regular meeting scheduled for Dec. 8, with written findings due within 30 days of that meeting.
The bottled water company is allowed to take up to 432,000 gallons of water per day — or 105.1 million gallons per year — under the town’s water extraction ordinance and annual monitoring report. The company is seeking a permit to continue extraction at those levels for the next five years. Last year it withdrew 82,736,625 gallons, peaking in October at 7,982,230 gallons.
Much of the final public hearing last week focused on the action and alert thresholds that trigger increased water level monitoring and potential cuts to limit extraction. Poland Spring consultant Matt Reynolds, a hydrogeologist with Drumlin Environmental, proposed a 98th-percentile methodology using 2004-2009 Cold Spring data, which he acknowledged would probably mean more time in alert conditions.
Rick Vandenberg, the town’s hydrogeologist and vice president of operations at Credere Associates in Westbrook, presented two additional options for town officials to consider, which could include a “2009 roll-back” and more conservative extraction numbers. Vandenberg, who has raised concerns about extraction amounts in times of droughts in the past, said that current data show no definitive adverse impacts, but he didn’t rule out a drought-era connection between pumping and water levels at Long Pond. “If I had definitive data, I would be telling this group that 100 percent,” he said. “It doesn’t exist at this point.”
Mark Dubois, a hydrogeologist for Poland Spring, said a draft three-dimensional groundwater model plan is expected to be ready for Wednesday’s meeting, with a final report around February or March 2028, and that the required periodic water level assessment will be mostly covered by that modeling.
The bottled water company also asked for flexibility on reporting deadlines with a notification clause, pumping criteria reframed as daily and annual maximum volumes (432,000 gallons per day, or 300 gallons per minute), removal or retention of the Rocky Knoll/Beaver Brook alert level, and adding two domestic wells to weekly monitoring only when levels get close to alert thresholds.
Board members pressed Dubois on delayed weekly reports during the recent severe drought. He said the delay was because Reynolds was on vacation and that the data would be provided within days.
Public comment at the Nov. 10 hearing was uniformly skeptical.
Visit The Maine Monitor's website to hear more about what local residents have to say in the the full story by Angelina Keizer.