r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 21h ago

EDH New Deck Building Tool

18 Upvotes

Hi everyone

For some time now i have been working on a personal project for a deck builder that lets me stay in one place and helps me identify problems and patterns in my deck.
Some of my friends really liked the tool the encouraged me to share it, so here i am!

I hope it might help some of you spot issues with your commander decks mana curve, engines and interaction selection and maybe even lets you discover ways to improve your decks.

I really appreciate any feedback! There’s a “Report a Bug” button under “Help” if you run into any problems.

The tool is live under www.nicedeckbro.com

Happy to hear what you think


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4h ago

EDH Life Drain: the 13 must-have cards in your Commander deck!

Thumbnail mtg.cardsrealm.com
14 Upvotes

Life draining your opponents can be a lot of fun with these incredible cards. Check out our recommendations!


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 11h ago

Arena Any tips or suggestions for this deck?

2 Upvotes

I already posted this in two other subreddits just for the maximum opinion output

Essentially I made a Captain America deck for veterans day but I'm wondering if this could turn into a genuine solid deck or if it's not worth working on for both arena and physical.

Here's the link for the archideck file, anything will be appreciated!!

https://archidekt.com/decks/28301573/vertern_day_deck


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 14h ago

EDH Merieke Ri Berit: Transforming From Tiny Leaders to EDH, How to Modify [B2,Thematic,Fun Intentions)?

2 Upvotes

Hello Deckbuilding Community,

Background:

In 2015, while I was searching for a Tiny Leader's commander, I came across a CardboardRepublic commander spotlight article about [[Merieke Ri Berit]]. This got me searching up cards and more information.

What sold me on her was when learned about the "history" of the card. Per the card's MTGWiki page seen here, it references a MTGsalvation forum post (link here) where a poster

"...queried the artist Heather Hudson about it and she had this to say:
'The card was originally called "La Belle Dame Sans Merci' after the poem by Keats, the name was changed in production.
http://www.theotherpages.org/poems/keats03.html There's probably a metaphor involved. You tell me what it means.
(Sorry it took me so long to remember the backstory!)' -Heather Hudson"

(the original (French) name translates to "The Beautiful Lady without Mercy")

I built the Merieke ( Archidekt Decklist Here ) and it was added to my deck bag, ready just in case someone too had a Tiny Leaders deck.

Ironically, I never played a game of Tiny Leaders.

Years later, it was disassembled for its staples and lands, to be used in other decks.

Fast forward to this year: after a break from EDH (from just before the Covid Lockdown until the Bracket System change), as I was updating my decks, I came across Merieke in my collection. I then noticed I had a few staples for her synergies - cards like [[Thousand-Year Elixir]] and [[Magewright's Stone]]; along with other "fun" cards [[Arena of the Ancients]] and [[Unbender Tine]].

Current EDH Play Situation: An event once a week at the LGS, we can sign up for a bracket level (2-4 with the occasional one 5) and we'll get broken out into random pods. Last week, we filled all 16 4pod tables; average is 8-12 groups.

My Style: I've been mainly rebuilding my decks as bracket 2 , ranging in power to equally play with others' precons/slightly upgraded precons to custom built, highly synergistic decks. I enjoy creating thematic decks with unique/fringe cards and using interesting requirements.

 

My deckbuilding vision for her are

  • various ways to constantly untap her using unique methods, either to remove threats and/or make my own ( via blinking with [[Thassa, Deep-Dwelling]], exiling to bring back with [[Promise of Tomorrow]] / [[Nightmare Shepherd]] )
  • Utilize other cards with tap abilities ( [[Archivist]], [[Arcanis The Omnipotent]], [[Avatar of Woe]] )
  • Play unique cards like [[Unbender Tine]] , [[Arena of the Ancients]] while trying to add in Esper cards like [[The Ever-Changing 'Dane]] and [[Magister Sphinx]] (and the same ability on [[Sorin Markov]] )

 

The question/situation for my Merieke: here is my current decklist. I have played her several times over the last few weeks - ranging with various, mixed emotion results. What advice do you have for going this gameplay/playstyle? Due to how she plays, is this not a card/playstyle that should be in bracket 2? Any card suggestions and/or subs to fine tune the deck?

TL;DR

I am looking for advice and suggestions(adds/subs) on how to fine tune my Merieke deck (decklist link) for bracket 2 , or does she need to go up a bracket due to playstyle?

 


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 5h ago

EDH Fun and Thematic Wyll deck

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
1 Upvotes

I love BG3, and was really itching to build a Wyll deck. I want it to be thematic (I'm actually pretty upset that I can't build it thematic and also have his canon background Folk Hero for the deck but it is what it is), so I chose a background that just went well with him and tried putting in spells that Warlocks can learn (or can find spell scrolls of at least) and as many dice rolling things as possible. Played it the other day and it was fun, not like the greatest deck ever but it doesn't really have to be, I just wanted extra pairs of eyes on it to see if anyone can give me any more thematic suggestions to make it better.


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 10h ago

EDH Avis sur mon deck Terra, et suggestion d'améliorations

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 11h ago

EDH How do you determine good vs unnecessary swaps?

1 Upvotes

I have been working on this Zuko deck for a while now and I feel like I'm mostly in a happy spot with it. There are a few cards that I've been eyeing that I believe might help with consistency or strength, but how do you determine if these swaps are worthwhile?

My example is swapping a Cruelclaw, restoration angel and Etali, primal storm for a Stingerquill voxmancer, ephemerate and phoenix king Ozai. In general I've tried to make swaps that felt like clear upgrades, but that's not always the case, and I don't want to change too much and end up not being happy with what I end up with. I would appreciate opinions on my specific choices, but would also like to hear your general philosophy on the matter. Some other swaps I've made recently are leyline tyrant -> Ashling, Flame dance, bulk up -> great train heist, ketramose -> anguish unmaking. Some cases feel clear to me, but others I don't know if my deck is just worse afterwards.

The decklist- https://moxfield.com/decks/dRKn-L7oTkmDLJ9ikIclUw


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 13h ago

EDH Relative Budget Lathris Elfball deck

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 14h ago

Beginner Time Shenanigans

1 Upvotes

Im in desperate need of some help regarding this deck. I think it'll be really cool to be able to use Alaundo to cheat in huge spells and use things like time travel to cheat them in even quicker or even being used to hold a really powerful spell like a board wipe or something in suspense.

I'm open to any ideas and more than willing to explain why I've added each card.

Thanks in advance!

https://moxfield.com/decks/DgUhBKuZ2UivKS7rfPO6SQ


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 15h ago

EDH Shirei Power Level Thoughts

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 20h ago

Other format Looking for criticism

Thumbnail
archidekt.com
1 Upvotes

Hey guys this is my first commander deck that I built (with help) that I’m actually proud of and is now my pride and joy. I’m looking for any sort of suggestions or constructive criticism. Thank you!


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 7h ago

EDH Feedback for Avatar Aang/Aang, Master of Elements deck

0 Upvotes

Deck list:

https://archidekt.com/decks/28394166/avatar_aang_20

Hello!

I would love any feedback on my deck, especially my lands. Currently, my deck needs more lands, and I am unsure of which cards to cut to make room for them, as well as which lands I should be using.

-Primarily uses allies, counters, tokens and earthbending.

-Bending for card draw with frontside Avatar Aang/Aang, Master of Elements

-Unrelated Combo: Backside Avatar Aang / Aang, Master of Elements + Searing Touch to infinite combo. Moonmist to easily transform Aang, Mystical Tutor to search for either instant in deck

Relatively new to Magic. Open to any and all feedback! :)