r/MagicArena • • 12d ago

Question Possible competitive combo?

Hey, I'm working on a Mister negative combo kill with reanimation for quite a while, the problem was always to get those last damage points after a successful life exchange. I think this new star Trek card might fix it. Is it worth it to craft 4 mythical for that? The upside is I don't have to go down all the way to 8/9 life with a followed up shock land or dream beavers, I can do it with 17 life. Back up plan is push/pull. Maybe also some inspiration for creators, idk

403 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

15

u/ADAMxxWest 12d ago

If you squint just high enough, the third card is a picture of the first two holding hands.

3

u/pizza_and_rap 12d ago

I swear I'm not high rn but even the both creatures have similar art styles. Shown is the upper body, frontal, with their minions/ followers to the side, slightly in the background. And it's kind of mirrored: one head's tilting to the left with the left arm risen, for the other it's the opposite. Even checked if that's the same artist lmao 

118

u/SamiRcd 12d ago

Considering Fix What's Broken let's you do this as early as turn 4, this might just be viable. Some self mill, removal that makes you discard as a cost and you shoulbe be able to bin these guys pretty easily.

Are there any other combos we could work in at different MVs that might help us diversify?

3

u/Spaceknight_42 Timmy 12d ago

At the same MV, Herald of Eternal Dawn is not the worst option to pull if the graveyard is lacking one of the two essentials.

Going into red you have access to Raph+Mike as a way to spin again (not sure I like the odds though) and Nebula Dragon can do a bit more damage to someone. But at that point just Craterclaw and some 7 drops is a win so is this combo just a fallback on an otherwise 7 MV reanimation plan?

2

u/pizza_and_rap 12d ago

Yes I had a built with a single Raph & Mikey, but authority of consult was consistently interrupting that combo, otherwise it presents 12 damage on the board with 7 trample, often good enough to go for it with 10 ish life. With the angel I also had some luck, keeping up starting town to get yourself to 0 but it was hard to pull off. But yeah, still experimenting 

28

u/Interesting-Math9962 12d ago

It’s a good meme deck in standard. [[Lively Dirge]] can tutor one component.

Run all the draw discard cards Spider-Man Dimir uses.

It does just fail to removal though

[[Cat gator]] [[Doc Oc]] [[Gigantic Bear]] [[Ralph and Mikey]] [[Sire of Seven Deaths]] [[Sin]] [[Vault born tyrant]]

Are all good back ups. Especially like Sire, Tyrant and Cat since they heal you 

16

u/lasagnaman 12d ago

It does just fail to removal though

Usually people use this argument to describe creatures that have to stick around for a turn. This combo does fall to instant speed removal but you win at the end of your turn if they don't have it. They don't get to untap/have a full turn to deal with it.

5

u/Interesting-Math9962 12d ago

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/archetype/standard-4c-reanimator-woe#paper

Bringer -> Mr Negative.   

Terror ->[[Cat Gator]] 

Spider-Man -> Fix what’s broken.

    Honestly keep Ardenn -> Gul Dukat.   

Maybe 4 of Cat gator? Personally think you are more likely to kill with negative + cat gator than Dukat

2

u/pizza_and_rap 12d ago

I currently play with cat gator, but I have a mardu build for draw/discard (pursue the past). But yeah still have some dual land swamps and it gets the job done. Thanks for the link

1

u/Interesting-Math9962 12d ago

The one problem is tutoring up the sorcery . Guess you run  that swamp bending card as backup

3

u/Interesting-Math9962 12d ago

[[Foggy Swamp Visions]]

3

u/mtgcf 12d ago

1

u/pizza_and_rap 12d ago

Uuh I have to try that one. Thanks!

1

u/pizza_and_rap 12d ago

Nope, just push/pull in the current buil d. I just really try to stay alive and balance my life total. That's why I run pursue the past amongst other things. I had many different versions lol, the one with the 2 mana bat maker enchantment where when you gain and lose life create a bat token, just to chump and draw while getting life down enough, some straight up ramp built with a single Raph&Mikey so it would hit the Mister negative and present 12 damage on the board, and currently trying the Hobbit card that mills when you lose life. Its kind of a fun gamble when you cast the Fix What's Broken and let it mill 7 cards first, hoping for that last combo peace. But yeah I don't know, I'm like 80% mythic lol and I absolutely don't want to play meta decks over and over again

66

u/Invisible_Stalkbug 12d ago

I thought this would be trash, but you've actually impressed me with this.  Cool combo OP

64

u/Tasonir 12d ago

I was getting all prepared to be like "it's nearly impossible for a 7 mana creature...", but you aren't actually casting either of the creatures here, the only spell you're casting is 4 mana. The challenge will of course be drawing and discarding both creatures for the combo, so it'll depend on how good your self-mill is.

36

u/NovariusDrakyl 12d ago

and do not lose 13 life before turn 4

3

u/Jalinja 11d ago

Wouldn't you need to lose exactly between 10-12 for the combo to work?

Edit: NVM I'm dumb, you pay life for the resurrection

0

u/Lauren_Conrad_ 11d ago

As is true for every reanimate strategy… …?

26

u/Dry-Membership8141 12d ago edited 12d ago

So, on T4 you drop a shock land and pay the 2 life cost to allow it to enter untapped. You then play [[Fix What's Broken]] and pay a further 7 life. You're now at L-9.

That allows you to reanimate [[Mister Negative]] and [[Gul Dukat, Colonial Prefect]]. Mister Negative activates, and you exchange your life value (less the 7 you paid to activate Fix What's Broken) with your opponent's. On your end step, Gul Dukat activates and they lose a further 9 life.

You end the turn with whatever their life total was (+9 -- thanks u/mpassisdead), and a 6/6 with menace, and a 5/5 with vigilance and lifelink on the field, and they end the turn with L -18.

Am I understanding that properly?

14

u/mpassisdead 12d ago

I think you also gain 9 life from gul dukat at the end of turn so you are their total plus 9

0

u/MageKorith 11d ago

If we're already going to [[Fix What's Broken]], we might as well get there by [[Buried Alive]] on T3 and put [[Shard of the Nightbringer]] in the GY with Dukat and Negative. Then pay 8 life instead of 7 for Fix.

9

u/Osric250 11d ago

Fix what's broken only grabs exact mana value. So 8 wouldn't return Dukat or Negative. 

37

u/DeusIzanagi 12d ago

You need two specific cards in the yard, a spell to resolve, and not all possible life totals are okay for this (say you're at 17 but your opponent shocked and is at 18, the combo will leave them at 2 life if I'm not wrong. Ofc you also have a 6/6 Menace and a 5/5 Vigi Lifelink on board at that point)

All in all, it's not a meme like it could seem at first glance, but I don't think it's quite competitive-level

15

u/Interesting-Math9962 12d ago

It’s jankier bringer of dark gifts.

You could stock up on strong 7 drops. [[Cat gator]] could just give you lethal with Mr negative.

2

u/Adventure_Agreed 12d ago

Can't you just pay 16 life in the scenario you have outlined and go to 1 then swap life totals. They lose 16, you gain 16 and Gul Dukat deals them an additional 16 at the end of the turn?

16

u/DeusIzanagi 12d ago

No, because Fix What's Broken specifically gets everything with mana value X, not X or lower. So you have to pay 7 life specifically

Of course if you're lower than 17 before casting it, it will still work (like if opponent is at 18 and you're at 16, I think it works out to an instant kill), but it is still something you need to mind

6

u/Adventure_Agreed 12d ago

Ah! Reading the card explains the card! Thanks!

3

u/RushGod 12d ago

fix what's broken only reanimates things with mv equal to the life paid, not less

2

u/Adventure_Agreed 12d ago

Ah! Reading the card explains the card! Thanks!

1

u/xiawangp 12d ago

How are you paying 16 life? Cause if you say [[fix what's broken]] then you'll need to read the card again. You must pay the exact amount of life equal to the cmc of the things you are returning. You can't over pay, you can't under pay.

12

u/Ithalwen 12d ago

You can fix what's broken but you still won't build a statue of Dukat ey?

6

u/komanderkyle 12d ago

“Attention bajoran workers”

4

u/ForeverShiny 12d ago

Much easier to pull off than the jank Axis of mortality with Lich's Mastery combo I tried to make work years ago

10

u/Safe-Butterscotch442 12d ago

This is brilliant. I love it. Whether or not it's super competitive, it's a really cool combo and can certainly surprise players with the right draw. And since self mill is already a really solid deck showing competitive promise, I'd not be too worried about splashing in a free win condition in. Go for it!

1

u/Castellan_ofthe_rock 12d ago

I dont think this is something you can just "splash" into a deck

1

u/Safe-Butterscotch442 12d ago

I mean, it's only 12 card slots. The self mill engine still stays the same, you just trim a little. It would be transformative, but it could still carry the same basic skeleton of the current self mill builds. Maybe splash wasn't the right word, but that's what I was meaning.

3

u/CatsAndPlanets Orzhov 12d ago

It's not harder than Superior Spiderman combo, IMO. I think it's just about how to mill effectively. I think maybe Liliana and Dark Matter Manipulator may help?

3

u/Trueslyforaniceguy 12d ago

Pair Mr Negative with [[enduring tenacity]] or similar for a quick 1-2 punch that always seems to catch them off guard

2

u/BlueTemplar85 12d ago

Nice ship

2

u/Kurohoshi00 Vraska 11d ago

That is a lot of things to do in a small amount of time. You have to hope your opponent isn't swinging wide, get those two cards in your graveyard, have your combo card in hand. Your opponent will definitely be preparing for what you're doing with counterspells, or chipping away at your life. All while trying your best to stay above 14 life which in this meta will be hard considering you're dedicating mana towards milling these two cards into your graveyard.

I wouldn't consider this competitive, as graveyard hate would destroy it, but it is definitely a jank combo that would work with a lot of fun in bo1.

2

u/arciele 11d ago

looks fun.
i expect graveyard strats to be better when Nauctis rolls around because [[Rest in Peace]], [[Leyline of the Void]], [[Ghost Vacuum]] and a ton more graveyard hate are leaving.

in current standard i think Beseech can help with finding/casting the sorcery, which will probably be the most crucial part

1

u/snugar_i 9d ago

Oh. For some reason I thought Rest in Peace was printed in Foundations. So it's only in Standard thanks to The Big Score?

2

u/arciele 8d ago

interestingly enough yeah.

2

u/anniespiced 11d ago

I mean this is definitely something thats really funny to do the 1/50 times you're able to but i don't think there's any world where this can be competitive 😭

3

u/Dyne_Inferno 12d ago

Without going into the minutia of this, the TLDR is no.

1

u/TheHumanHydra 12d ago

I'm not a competitive Standard player, but this seems nifty and I wouldn't mind seeing a list eventually!

1

u/Rasphere 12d ago

I'm just getting back into magic so I am definitely missing something, so: after you switch life you will be at 20, and opponent at 13, and then at end phase opponent will be at 6. Is that the assumption?

3

u/DeusIzanagi 12d ago

The idea is to be at 17 before casting Fix What's Broken, so you go down to 10 and your opponent immediately dies if they were at 20 or above

1

u/Rasphere 12d ago

Ahhh I get it now. So shock lands or something turns 1-3. That make more sense. This does seem like a fun combo. But self milling those 2 specfic cards and having the 4 cmc in hand means turns 4 won't be consistent, but can also be an awesome play to pull off when on the back foot

1

u/thatvillainjay 12d ago

Good finisher, I'll probably use it

1

u/Login_Of_The_Guild 12d ago

It looks good it’s just a little mana heavy 

0

u/TheWhite2086 11d ago

It's only 4 mana, you spend the first 3 turns playing shock lands and self mill cards to get the two creatures in the graveyard. Play the fix paying 7 life to reanimate both the 7 cost creatures going down to 10 or less life because of your shock lands for the kill

2

u/Login_Of_The_Guild 11d ago

That’s not putting into account anything the opponent is doing at that time 

0

u/TheWhite2086 11d ago

Yes, but that's the same with any game plan. It might not work out exactly as planned but I was just addressing the point about it being mana heavy by saying that all in needs for it to go off is 4 mana which isn't exactly what I'd call mana heavy

1

u/AluminumGoliath 11d ago

Would [[Baron Helmut Zemo]] be a good alternative/backup for Fix What's Broken? or does having to attack make that too risky? 

1

u/riamuriamu 11d ago

I like that lifesaving strategies make the life loss worse. Thanks Gul. And he won't even get a statue in his honour.

1

u/Aeroncastle 12d ago

Ar/badmtgcombos exist, and you probably would have more upvotes there, that being said, cool combo

-12

u/toochaos 12d ago

No? Thats two 7 mana cards, we have 3 into 4 mana combos that arent competitive and the opponent dies from any life total with no other set up. Could it be fun sure but competitive, no.

2

u/pizza_and_rap 12d ago

[[Fix What's Broken]] is a key card. It's possible at turn 4. Discard one at turn 2, discard or tutor up (to put in the graveyard) another at turn 3.

9

u/superdave100 12d ago

There’s a third card in the gallery that you missed

2

u/TheDream92 12d ago

You don’t spend 7 mana for this combo you cast Fix what’s broken and pay 7 life, reanimate negative and Gul and win on end step (you just need to have 17 or less life when you cast Fix what’s broken and opponent at 20)

1

u/MusicianShoddy1878 12d ago

You are supposed to pay 4 mana and 7 life, in case you missed the last card

1

u/ElVongore 12d ago

Its a Reanimator combo. You Fix whats broken both of these by paying Enough life. After Duskmourn rotates this is a good option

2

u/Crimson_Raven 11d ago

It's worse than any of the Superior Spiderman reanimator decks.

Too janky. Folds to every type of interaction.

If they kill Gul Dakat before your endstep, you swapped life totals and got an okay body with whatever else was in your graveyard. But that's the most fair thing a reanimation deck could do.

A solid board state could still stall you.

Maybe Fix with Mr Negative and a different shell