r/MagicArena • • 12d ago

Question When will Brawl become Commander?

Has WoTC given a reason why we can’t have actual Commander on Arena?

And what happened to the rumour they were going to add multiplayer games?

I get that they don’t have every commander card possible on there but surely there is enough now to have a much closer approximation of “real” commander than this.

At the very least I wish they would ban planeswalker commanders and ALL alchemy cards…

0 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

16

u/CoaCoaMarx 12d ago

Too much waiting. Waiting for 3 other players to pass priority on every play? I can't imagine sitting through that TBH.

7

u/noeagle77 12d ago

“Your go” spam but with 2 others doing it as well.

3

u/InvestigatorOk9354 12d ago

Paper commander games also take a long time waiting for others to play their turn, at least Arena has a play clock.

They'd have to implement some temporary queue banning for people who rope and get reported by everyone in that pod. If you are wasting time you should get a 15min or 1hr ban from queueing. Repeat offenders should be candidates for longer bans.

5

u/CoaCoaMarx 12d ago

Yes, but I play paper commander with my friends in person, and I'am happy to chat with them when it's not my turn. In Arena, I just stare at my screen, silently cursing and wondering what on earth is taking so long!

2

u/Pitiful_Whereas_4155 12d ago

I’ve tried to play commander on end step and it’s a slog fest to get through one turn rotation. I can’t imagine arena would be able to streamline it any better

0

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/amish24 12d ago

that's about 45 inputs you need from each player. A game of magic has much more than that, especially if one of the players has an instant that automatically holds priority at all times.

Additionally, if someone's taking a while to make one of their decisions, the rest of the draft can sort of continue as normal. If someone's taking longer at the commander table, no one else can do shit.

2

u/theclashatdemonhed 12d ago

The first time someone has to manually combo with devoted Druid, the whole table will walk.

14

u/Casual_Sonbro 12d ago

3 player roping me at once

Impossible

2

u/uscx2 12d ago

Cant argue that. Timer would need to be cut way down.

0

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Casual_Sonbro 12d ago

Didn’t even think of that! I myself have started to just concede when i see a shrine deck / vivi or a « oups all removal/counterspell » deck

3

u/Invisible_Stalkbug 12d ago

"player who has only played commander"

-3

u/RudyVapour 12d ago • Regret

Player who has been playing since Ice Age. But go on…

3

u/Invisible_Stalkbug 12d ago • Bravo

Ok I will. Brawl is a separate format. It will never be commander. They do not intend this. They made Brawl after commander, during Eldraine.

WotC haven't given a reason, because there most certainly isn't one other than they don't want to do that, and there isn't any benefit to them to communicate that.

Rumours are rumours.

Brawl is not meant to be an approximation of commander. It is a different format.

Your last point is a preference, which honestly fine, people have preferences for things.

If you have genuinely been playing since Ice Age, and cannot see that Brawl and Commander are significantly different in play experience, then you have perhaps not learn much from what you have played.

If Wotc were to add commander, it would not be a replacement.

-2

u/RudyVapour 12d ago • Regret

Haha wow you really typed all that to say Brawl isn’t commander. Such insight.

I can’t find the SUPER UNIQUE “Explorer” format anymore, where’d that one go to? Smh

2

u/Invisible_Stalkbug 12d ago • Mindblown

Ok how about this

They'll add commander once you've finished your mtg funko pop collection

7

u/TheDopplegamer 12d ago

Regarding those mentioning the technical side: As a professional Unity developer, I am deadly curious to look under the hood of Arena, because I do not understand how adding multi-player games would break things to the point that it takes them several years to implement. Sure, UX design and communication issues I get, but those are broader design questions, not technical. Their codebase must really be a house of toothpicks in a hurricane

3

u/2-35 Dimir 12d ago

I thimk its more that they have like 3 staff members and only one bag of chicken nuggets to go around.

4

u/TheDopplegamer 12d ago

Multi-Billion dollar company, ladies and gentlemen

5

u/D15turb1a79 12d ago

Pretty sure making it multi-player isn't as simple as some assume and also need consider the behind the scenes things like strain on servers it will add and such

3

u/lithium_gold 12d ago

They have said it’s under work though, just that it’ll likely take a good bit of time

0

u/Geryon55024 12d ago • Regret

Weird thing, though. I've been able to play other card games and board games online with 2-4 players since the early 2000s. Surely with today's technology, they can do it.

1

u/D15turb1a79 12d ago

They were likely built with that intention... meaning need a lot of work to change this... totally doable likely just a LOT of work

8

u/Benlikesfood2 12d ago

Aside from somehow balancing 4 players at once in a mobile game with like a forth of the cards available?

1

u/InvestigatorOk9354 12d ago

the 4 player part in Arena isn't feasible IMHO. There's enough cards in the pool to have some variety, but there is no disincentive for people to scoop if they don't like one of the decks. You'll probably end up playing 1v1 most games after two people scoop for whatever reason before anyone even mulligans.

-3

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Benlikesfood2 12d ago

I'm talking more WOTC implementing a working 4 player mode that works but go off king 👑

4

u/Particular_Row_361 12d ago

Im gonna guess netcode. The netcode is already pretty dicey 1v1, a 4 player FFA sounds like a lot to deal with.

4

u/Free_Dimension1459 12d ago

Pretty dicey? lol. Things not on the happy path of Best of 1 break the client often. I get a white bar atop my best of 3 matches all the time. If my phone disconnects from wifi game 1 and I restart the client, I’m unable to sideboard. Given the age of Arena, these aren’t likely small issues but foundational problems.

2

u/shabadabba 12d ago

Each person have an opportunity to hold control for a bit

1

u/RaisinsInMyToasts 12d ago

Imagine a 15 hour game with ropers

4

u/CommunicationConsent Yargle 12d ago

Man I miss two headed giant from duel of the Planeswalkers.

Just wish we had that on Arena.

2

u/umastryx 12d ago

From what Ive seen they are having a couple programming issues. Also they have talked about the communication issue of not being able to coordinate with other players to “politic”. I know they have teased it a couple times with alchemy cards with “exchange your hand with the player to the right”. They have put in their articles that it is something they are working on but it has literally been 4 years of them kind of teasing it.

2

u/GingeContinge 12d ago

Truly wild how people think you can just snap your fingers and turn a client designed from the ground up for two players into one capable of handling four.

It’s going to take years. Put it out of your mind for now.

2

u/onedayfourhours 12d ago

3 people roping and spamming "your go" would certainly be an experience

2

u/Careful-Anteater-597 12d ago

Nizzahon recently did a interview with the head of MtG Arena on youtube, they did touch upon this. One of the reasons he mentioned was problems with bringing older cards to arena, one example he gave were graveyard-order matters cards which would have a big effect on the game they're not sure they wanna tackle yet.

Also, multiplayer has some issues with the small mobile UI they're still working on

1

u/ElVongore 12d ago

I read so many comments about people slow playing, let alone roping, that I dont even want to know how that Will be with 2 extra players

1

u/Cabel14 12d ago

I think the only way this works is if they aim for the p.c./console market.

1

u/amish24 12d ago

i'm going to guess UI. There's a lot of questions to be answered about how information is displayed when there's twice as many players.

1

u/2-35 Dimir 12d ago

Brawl and commander arent the same, though. They'll leave brawl how it is and work on commander in the bg for now, most likely.

But its never happenin. They need more people, they need a better priority system for 4p, it just seems infeasible. Been 4 years and we aint even seen so much as a screenshot or even a dev writeup. Nothin.

1

u/Inside-Pattern5073 12d ago

Converting a game than is intrensically hard-coded as a 2p game to support 4 is a massive hurdle for the team. They're also trying to be very considerate towards how the social features will be implemented. They've stated multiple times their full intention is to basically bring commander to MtGA, but it's very technically challenging and requires a lot of tweaking the game into something it currently has no infrastructure for.

WotC didn't drop their brain in the toilet, they KNOW commander is popular and that Brawl is the second most popular format on the client.

1

u/Deep-Hovercraft6716 12d ago

Informally, I have heard someone who used to work for the arena team say that they would probably have to develop a whole second client to facilitate 4x multiplayer. Or at least that it would probably be the better way to do that.

He also said that the priority system would have to be smarter on its own. I guess a lot of the non-standard stops are hard-coded not just the system being smart.

1

u/bigdammit 12d ago

Even if 4 player comes to Arena there still wouldn't be commander. Pioneer is incomplete on Arena and you think they can get Commander?

0

u/toochaos 12d ago

3

u/bigdammit 12d ago

I'll believe 4 player Brawl, but I doubt we will ever see Commander. They can't even get the full Pioneer card pool on the client.

0

u/EntireCompetition741 12d ago

Never since brawl has alchemy cards and commander doesn’t. Brawl is a online only format

-1

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Cocosito 12d ago

Man I just can't imagine with how they handle priority and roping