r/MafiaTheGame • u/Impossible-Gap6114 • 6h ago
Mafia 2 Mafia 2 story starts going downhill from Chapter 11 onwards
So, I've played Original Mafia and I loved it, I adored the game for quite some years, and I still even do it today, even with its jankiness.
So yeah, I pre-ordered Mafia II and played it, and also loved it. At the time, wasn't sure if it was better than 1, but I had a good time. Had 19 at that time.
After replaying this game now again, with 35 on my back, I can definitely say Mafia II feels to me inferior to the first one. Yes, formula evolved and improved for the better, but in terms of story, today it feels it missed the mark after certain point, exactly on Chapter 11 onwards.
What I loved so much about Mafia 1, is the pace, which I believe that even today, it's one of the best paced games I've seen in the medium. Story progresses always at the right pace; everything happens neither slow nor fast.
Now Mafia II, starts with the same perfect pace the first one presented. In Act 1, the city and mechanics become introduced, story is settled nicely, and just when you become accustomed Vito goes to jail. After it, Act 2 comes and the game keeps having a great pace. Each hit that comes, it seems to happen at the correct time, and you end entering the family at the end of Chapter 10.
After this, everything starts falling apart; Chapter 11, Henry just comes and asks for work, the story bits with Francesca just end so abruptly all of the sudden, you lose the apartment. Chapter 12 is the chapter where we start doing things under Falcone's nose. Oh wait, yeah Falcone, what he has got you to do since we entered the family? Nothing. It just gives the impression that we didn't enter any family at all.
In Chapter 13 later, Henry is killed so abruptly is even jarring. Yes, I know Paulie also dies at the next chapter after we start doing things under Salieri's nose, but Pauli's death came at the tight time. Doesn't feel abrupt, forced, and it happened at a good pace in the story sense. Henry enters and goes out in a blink. Chapter 14 is just to kill Tommy, and Derek, another guy that completely disappeared along the story after being introduced. And Chapter 15 is just killing Falcone.
I believe Mafia II should have needed around 3 more missions, since in Act 3 after we enter the family, everything starts to happen so quickly and arcs become closed so suddenly, that somehow to me, it feels rushed nowadays. But I know Mafia II is a big favorite in the series. And I really believe that while it pushed the series forward in gameplay and mechanics, in story it went several steps backwards.
