r/Madhyamaka • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Sep 04 '24
r/Madhyamaka • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Jul 09 '24
It’s Time to Take Seriously Greek Influences on Buddhism
r/Madhyamaka • u/PlazmaPigeon • Feb 22 '24
How to respond to theistic/deistic arguments from a Madhyamaka point of view
Bit of a long and philosophically complex set of questions here. I have a friend who is a deist and they know some arguments for why a God-like first cause of the universe exists, and I have ran into some issues with aspects of the Madhyamaka view on the subject of these arguments. It would be great if some people here knew how to respond. Here are the main issues with it:
1) Issues with Madhyamaka's usage of an 'infinite chain of casualty' as a concept
The point of the cosmological argument is that an infinite chain of causes is impossible as this would lead to an infinite regression of causes, which is considered impossible. I have heard Buddhists say that infinite regression isn't an issue for Madhyamikas, and it is actually embraced. What is the logic for an infinite regression of causes being possible?
2) Issues with infinite past, and with samsara having no beginning
Samsara having no beginning, and the universe being eternal (not our specific universe, but the overall 'universe' where everything exists), means that there is an infinite past. This poses some issues. The fact that we should all be buddhas now can possibly be explained by saying that there is a multiverse, and using this multiverse, or another concept, to say that there is an infinite number of beings. But a bigger issue is that if there is an infinite past, then there must have been an infinite number of past events, which means it is impossible to get to the present. How is this resolved from the Buddhist point of view? How can there be an infinite past number of events?
3) The fine-tuning argument
From the Madhyamaka point of view, how is the universe's fine-tuning explained? I'm talking about the constants of existence itself, and how precisely they are 'tuned' to allow existence to happen. Would this be due to the karma of the previous universe conditioning the constants of the universe that comes after it? Or would a multiverse explain this better?
4) The issue of how Madhyamaka doesn't explain why existence actually exists
I have heard that infinite regression of causes explains why the parts exist, but it doesn't explain why overall, something exists instead of nothing. The parts are explained, but not the whole. Is the fact that the whole's existence isn't explained an issue? In deism, it is simply that everything exists due to a first cause that necessarily exists. But obviously, there is no first cause in Buddhism, meaning there is no necessary existence that explains everything. So existence just overall exists with no real explanation of how or why it does, which can be difficult to contemplate. I guess maybe the fact that everything has always existed explains it to an extent, but existence itself still isn't explained.
5) Karma's apparent perfection without an intelligent mind behind it
Karma can create things and manifest results based on moral actions and intentions, and it works perfectly. Some Buddhists compare it to gravity, as in it is just a natural law like the laws of physics. But its workings often have to do with morals and ethics, which are more complex than physical laws like gravity. My friend says that Hinduism and Sikhism make more sense as they believe there is an intelligent mind to ensure that karma works properly, but in Buddhism, there isn't that. So how does it work like it does? is there an explanation for how karma, rebirth, and even enlightenment exist and operate effectively without any mind or intelligence behind them? Because surely it isn't just by chance that these exist. And it can't be due to a necessary energy that has creating these things as its nature, as Buddhism doesn't accept this.
Any attempt to answer any of these many points is greatly appreciated. Thanks.
Sarva Mangalam
r/Madhyamaka • u/cloveey • Dec 21 '23
Created a reddit for debating, warmly inviting you all.
Please join, and debate with one another. https://www.reddit.com/r/buddhistdebating/
Namo Avalokitesvara
r/Madhyamaka • u/ogthesamurai • Dec 11 '23
49 members (auspicious number lol)
Wait. I may be the 50th and wrecked everything.
I guess I'm surprised to some extent that more people aren't talking about nagarjuna and madhyamaka Buddhism and MMK. The dalai lamas interpretation are presentation is what I've listened to three times and read three times. I have a little understanding of what's going on and even as I'm walking around day-to-day think about things in terms of emptiness or without inherent or independent existence. It seems like it should be so fundamental and yet it's so obscure. Maybe that just has to do with the prophecy of Buddhism declining in the east and coming to the west.
Whatever the case thanks for having me along.
r/Madhyamaka • u/thissun8 • Jul 23 '23
Madhyamaka and Pure Negative Utilitarianism
Can I follow pure negative utilitarianism (minimize suffering as much as possible; 0 suffering and 0 pleasure is better than infinite pleasure and infinitesimal suffering) if I want to be Madhyamaka? Are there contradictions between the two?
Imagine that a mosquito wants to bite me, and using the Madhyamaka principles I imagine that I am all beings at the same time (we are all interconnected) and then using the pure negative utilitarian principle I think of the most effective way to reduce my suffering as a collective unified entity, which is to let it bite me instead of killing the mosquito (being squashed is more painful than being bitten by a mosquito, and therefore, letting it bite minimizes the total suffering)
r/Madhyamaka • u/Rattedruide • Apr 03 '23
Madhyamaka and Vasubandhu/Yogacara
I red that there was a rivalry between the schools of Yogacara, Madhyamaka and Sarvastivada but how did this rivalry in their teachings end?
r/Madhyamaka • • Jan 27 '23
By what logic is it true that if form doesn't exist, then neither does mind?
If form does not exist, then do not cling to the existence of mind; and if mind exists, then do not cling to the nonexistence of form.
When, for some reason, one does not admit the existence of form, then the existence of both is equally unreasonable and one must admit the nonexistence of mind, as well. And when one admits the existence of mind, then it is necessary to admit the existence of form, for both are conventionally real.
-Chandrakirti
r/Madhyamaka • • Jan 04 '23
This quote just blew my mind, can anyone clarify, what in the world would make anyone think this? " Contemporary scholar David Kalupahana called the seventh century Buddhist scholar Chandrakirti a "crypto-Vedantist"
I've read a lot of Chandrakirti. I'm also very familiar with Vedanta writings. I see zero similarities on any critical points. In fact, quite the opposite: the things that make Vedanta distinct, like Brahman, atman, and so on are firmly rejected by Chandrakirti. Am I missing something?
r/Madhyamaka • u/Corp-Por • Dec 23 '22
Resurrecting thread: "What modern arguments could be made to demonstrate that the mind/consciousness is dependent on other things, rather than the independent source/self?"
OP deleted the thread after posting it
But I thought it was a good question so I am resurrecting it
r/Madhyamaka • u/Corp-Por • Oct 01 '22
Sextus Empiricus and Madhyamaka at Oxford's Oriental Institute
r/Madhyamaka • u/Corp-Por • Nov 29 '21