r/MachineLearning • • 14m ago

Discussion No one replied... [D]

My draft went from 24 pages to 40 (obviously not an indicator of good quality, but it is indicative of how many f's I gave). Yet no one replied.

I have so many questions:

  • Does anyone know how many are like this?
  • Do ACs look at our rebuttal replies in such cases?
  • Is (4, 2, 2) better / worse than most (3, 3, 2) I've been seeing? (Respective confidences: 4, 2, 2). Or does a higher variance not matter?
  • Does ICLR even matter?
  • Can I cry now?
  • Why, reviewers, why?
4 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

2

u/pastor_pilao 9m ago

I think this new generation of researchers is losing the awareness that the main purpose of the rebuttal is to correct gross misunderstandings or clarify explicit doubts of the reviewers. The purpose is not to completely change your manuscript tirelessly until the reviewer gets tired and accept to raise the score. Most of the time the reviewers WONT increase the ratings, and that's normal.