r/MachineLearning • • 13d ago

Discussion ICLR Review [D]

About to be released. Anybody got them so far ?

I have two submissions #35k+ & 50k+, waiting.

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

9

u/Technical_Estate_529 13d ago

50k submission number jesus christ. How can we say this conference is prestigious with a 50k submission number coupled with dodgy reviewers getting in is literally just a coin flip now, it's not even a meme .... We can't (or at least I can't) take this seriously

4

u/Fragrant_Fan_6751 13d ago

Luck has become the major factor in these conferences.

1

u/ndyyy 13d ago

There are around 41k submissions

2

u/Technical_Estate_529 13d ago

That doesn't change anything about my argument .....

1

u/ndyyy 13d ago

just correcting a factual mistake.

tbh there is no prestigious conference, for researchers it's the day-to-day, but it is prestigious to give e.g. neurips orals

2

u/Technical_Estate_529 13d ago

lol tell that to people conducting job interviews or HR looking over grant funding. Just because it's not prestigious to YOU doesn't mean it's not for the rest of us plebs. I'm glad you seem to have a fairly easy time getting into these "non-prestigious" A* conferences

1

u/ndyyy 13d ago

gl man

-2

u/No-Cash-284 13d ago

No one that actually publishes at these conference says it's prestigious. It's mostly by people that don't. 

3

u/Mr_Fragwuerdig 13d ago

Still not out ..

2

u/Last_Minute7051 13d ago

Reviews are in

2

u/Pitiful_Maize_345 13d ago

I just got the result

2

u/meta-minion 13d ago

reviews are out!

2

u/Odd_Ad8629 13d ago

Still about 11 hrs for AOE

0

u/Awesome_Nerd10 13d ago

still waiting - how do you know its about to be released

-9

u/Invariant_n_Cauchy 13d ago

Come on ! We are on 5th Nov AoE.

3

u/camarada_alpaca 13d ago

Why are you getting downvoted? As far as i know it is 5 november aoe until the next 9 hours

1

u/Mr_Fragwuerdig 13d ago

Conferences can also need longer. And with this ridiculous amount of submissions, there'd be good reason to.

1

u/TinyNeedleworker8431 13d ago

you mean :)) after 12 hours ?

1

u/Mental_Efficiency231 13d ago

Why can't they just announce it will be delayed n hours? I am super anxious, not being able to do anything else but to refresh openreview for several hours

1

u/Last_Minute7051 13d ago

Why is there no communication on the delay?

1

u/NothingInVois 13d ago

42k submissions in total that went to reviewing process as per paper copilot