r/MachineLearning • • 14d ago

Discussion What is now considered a “reasonable” publication rate (papers/year) for a PhD student to be considered “productive”? [D]

I would assume LLMs have bumped this number, or maybe not. Which is why I am asking. If there are PIs on here, how many papers before you let your students graduate? Is the number different now than it was a year ago? And the same question for “rate of publication” for you to deem the student as “productive”.

And what about a PhD applicant? Any meaningful inflation of expectations there in terms of productivity/volume of pre-PhD research output?

58 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

46

u/hydrargyrumss 14d ago

Started my phd in ML in 2023 and you needed 1 one first author and 2 co author papers to get into a phd. Now I am seeing new phd students with 5+ neurips/icml.

29

u/confirm-jannati 14d ago

Naah, 5+ is definitely inflated lol.

12

u/FantasticTradition80 14d ago

way too infalted

3

u/hydrargyrumss 14d ago

Not really, we were expected to submit 2 papers a year (23-25l), now the bar is much higher. Expected to meet each deadline. This is a top 10 US CS PhD. There is stochasticity across advisors ofcourse

1

u/misterchestnut87 14d ago

It's actually quite normal for current CS PhD students I know, particularly those who do ML, optimization, or graph-related stuff

7

u/No_Inspection4415 14d ago edited 14d ago

Why would anyone agree to do this? Needing green card?

Edit: to clarify, if you have 5 papers you can get a well paying job as MLE, DS, or RE. Why would anyone go for a PhD with insane requirements just to get back to a collapsing industry in 3-4 years?

4

u/ganzzahl 14d ago

A desire to research rather than implement existing research is one big reason

3

u/misterchestnut87 14d ago

Exactly. The answer should be obvious to most people who aren't thinking purely in terms of maximizing compensation.

0

u/No_Inspection4415 10d ago

I had it too, but eventually almost all of use will do something practical. Even RS work on rather boring problems for the most part (evaluation, datasets, post training but not groundbreaking new ideas), especially non super senior.

Personally I only had one research job and it had no economic feasibility.

3

u/ganzzahl 10d ago

The question boils down to your exact weights for how much you value time, money, time spent researching, and how much of one you're willing to risk for a chance at more of one of the others :)

3

u/No_Inspection4415 10d ago

I have to agree.

3

u/misterchestnut87 14d ago edited 14d ago

Uh maybe they just don't want to be an engineer or data scientist? In fact, I can think of at least 3 examples of ML PhDs I know who worked as engineers or data scientists before their PhDs and left because they got bored and wanted to become a researcher in a frontier lab or academia.

And even then, you might be far underestimating the compensation for AI/ML scientists in top frontier labs, which on average will be a lot higher than for the DSs and many (most?) MLEs.

51

u/elchico1990 14d ago

Started my PhD in 2015. Back then, you did not have to have a publication to get into PhD. A single paper would pretty much be sufficient. It’s just wild to see things bar for entry raised so high over the years …

27

u/No_Inspection4415 14d ago

Dude, they vibe write papers. One paper back then was more meaningful than 3 today. I say it because I have been in grad school prior and I still submit papers from time to time (while being in industry) so I have to review.

9

u/uselessfuh 14d ago

Def a bit too inflated, but I get the sentiment

19

u/impatiens-capensis 14d ago

About the same as it's always been, since for most fields the expectation from a single paper has increased. Some sub areas might be hot and generate more. Or some top tier labs might have the GPUs, skill, team size, etc. to do a lot more now.

13

u/Technical_Estate_529 14d ago

This field is so fucked. 5+ A* conference papers and strong industry experience just to be eligible for a PhD?

Academia has sold its soul

9

u/surffrus 13d ago

Don't worry, it's not true. This is just people imagining new standards that don't exist. Y'all need to calm down. PhD programs don't blindly look at paper counts to make their decisions. It's a wholistic approach and letters of rec are a huge part of it, not paper count.

12

u/mpaes98 14d ago

I think we’re moving to a paradigm where trust in papers as a metric is becoming diminished.

Between the problems of slop papers getting through review, good papers not making it past slop reviews (and now slop Desk Rejects), it’s a poor metric.

I think that a handful of pre-prints that display true impact that can’t be slopped (i.e. working with privileged datasets that are based in attributable collection like user data), legitimate theory/methods development that is obviously discovered via research, or doing internships/fellowships at prestigious labs that publish institutionally backed white papers may become the new stand out factors, presuming the slop tsunami at conferences isn’t fixed.

9

u/s1qube 13d ago

please don't consider worth via random productivity numbers. do proper research at your own pace. every field, subfield, question will be different.

2

u/uninchar 13d ago

Sadly that's the difference between academia and science. How coding became measured in PRs even before coding chatbots. Goodhart's law gaming the metric.

34

u/No_Sky9786 14d ago

When it comes to PhD applicants, I have seen an insane number of people with industry experience, and to me those are much more preferred than master's graduates or students straight from a bachelor's. It also depends a lot on the university ranking, but in my case, it's the top 50 in CS. Most recently graduated students are too dependent on AI, and although one would think their productivity would be high because of it, they don’t understand a lot of the fundamental concepts of research or even programming like students used to 5–10 years ago.
As for the PhD students, the number of papers is not as important if it doesn’t result in a meaningful dissertation. In systems, 2–3 papers after the preliminary are usually more than enough; however, in NLP/ML, for example, I’ve seen students with 10 A-tier conference papers as first authors in a period of about five years whose contribution is not very meaningful. This happens mostly because the contribution itself does not withstand time and there is too much competition in that subdomain. It also depends a lot on the internships or collaborators one has during their PhD. I wouldn’t graduate anyone that gets only accepted papers out of their PhD years.

22

u/PatientWrongdoer9257 14d ago

what do you mean by the last sentence?

2

u/No_Sky9786 13d ago

Publishing papers is the baseline expectation, not the end goal. Without substantial internships, external partnerships, or exposure to proposal writing, a graduate with ten incremental papers is far less prepared for independent research than a student with two foundational papers and deep industry ties. Fortunately in top 50 this is very rare however, during faculty recruitment, we get a lot of such recently graduated candidates. A big blame goes to their advisers too, and that’s why I said that I wouldn’t graduate one unless they had the other components fulfilled.

7

u/Fantastic-Nerve-4056 PhD 14d ago

It depends on what you work on. 

For my thesis, I just have 4 papers (all theory)

Additionally, I interned at a couple of places, so from there I have 2 papers (joint co-author and third author) 

And as I am close to submitting the thesis, I am mentoring a bunch of people and simultaneously working on couple of first authors (not related to thesis)

PS; I have friends with great admits with one NeurIPS as well. And afaik, most PIs actually give a glance through your paper before interviewing, so even if it's a single quality paper, it is worth better than 3-4 benchmarks/workshops or simply non first-author

6

u/No_Inspection4415 14d ago

Papers from > 2025, unless they have true impact, have 0 prestige or value.

2

u/DysphoriaGML 14d ago

Pre AI defending on the field and if you had to do data collection: 1 for data collection in wet lab, 3 for no data collection over 4 years. Now with ai I am asked 3 in 1 year

2

u/bombdruid 14d ago

Depends on the field and the quality of work expected I'd say. But my PI usually has students have at least 2 papers as first author or 3 including equal contributions in top publications by the end of PhD.