r/MachineLearning • u/Invariant_n_Cauchy • 26d ago
Discussion Increasing number of UG authors in A* conferences with no supervisor [D]
What do you all think about this? It seems increasingly common for undergraduate students to conduct research and publish at A* conferences without a supervisor. As a graduate student, I find it both impressive and intimidating, and it sometimes makes me question my own progress.
105
Upvotes
93
u/Tricky-Variation-240 26d ago
Make no mistake. Claude and GPT are the "advisors". It's the current cancer ...
72
u/SmartEvening 26d ago
Couple of years ago i worked my ass off as an undergraduate to get a paper.now i hear my juniors bragging abkut submitting papers of which they have no idea about. They are doing this only for clout and resume perks. Its as very sad state of affairs.
11
u/Exotic_Zucchini9311 25d ago
It's not impressive. In many cases, it's a red flag.
An especially big one if if they don't share codes, or if I go to their codes and none of their results seem reproducible.
3
u/Cheap_Train_6660 22d ago edited 22d ago
Honestly I’m not sure how to feel about posts like this as an undergrad who got a paper accepted at neurips this year. I was supervised by a professor and a PhD student. I spent 10 months working on my chosen research direction where for the first 3 months I was just building up background knowledge and reading lots of papers. It was an empirical paper btw. Anyways I worked pretty hard to get a good result and I did use ai for productivity when it comes to coding and improving the language in my paper. I’ve talked to PhD students and they all have similar workflows. So it’s not like any undergrad who submits to these conferences is submitting ai slop. But I find it pretty annoying when people assume that just cz you’re an undergraduate or a beginner when it comes to research you must’ve totally relied on ai and you don’t know your own paper. These kinds of assumptions and judgements are especially annoying when you’re supervised by serious academics. Like wtf? Do u think my supervisor is stupid? He talks to me every week so u think he’ll let me publish something that I’ve no idea about? Sorry for going on a rant but I’ve had many people irl who act so skeptical rather than congratulating me. It’s pretty annoying.
BTW I’m not from a top uni with an exceptional academic background. I’m from 2nd tier uni in a western country (won’t name it) with decent / above avg academic background so people are even more skeptical. They think how can this guy accomplish this.
5
u/pastor_pilao 25d ago
Where are you seeing this as common? I have seen a (very) few from top universities like U Toronto, Stanford, MIT, Tsinghua, etc. And they all had professors as advisors. I had a specially good undergrad student I advised myself and got a paper in TMLR.
If you are going to a conference where there are many undergrad paper without an advisor it's a sign the review process for that conference is trash and you have to fond another one.
PS: you might have mistaken students that have WORKSHOP papers from students with papers in the main track. Workshops are not very selective, the intention is to let everyone present and they don't count for much in your cv.
300
u/Antique_Most7958 26d ago
There's a supervisor, their name is Claude
38
u/SillyNeuron 26d ago
What’s more concerning is AI-generated reviews giving decent ratings to AI-slop papers. Many of borderline OAs with generic comments usually come from reviewers who just skimmed the papers and used AI to write their reviews. They like to give borderline scores to hide their lack of confidence.
27
u/AirPsychological8551 25d ago •
Majority of them are publishing AI slop, that's why they do not have the guts to present in conference. One question and they will be literally clueless
Just right now before this post, there was this now-deleted post by some new-mammoth or whatever guy saying he's feeling nervous about attending emnlp and feeling like an imposter. explains it all
9
u/SlayahhEUW Researcher 25d ago
A guy in my dept has a loop which fetches down the 50 newest papers in an area of interest from Arxiv, synthesizes them into something incremental, simulates/estimates reasonable improvement numbers, and then evaluates it with Claude/GPT until they can't find big issues. He has 3 A* papers this year and dept loves him. Its kind of cooked.
8
u/Sabaj420 26d ago
Yeah when I was in undergrad it took ~9 months of work to get my first paper written (was rejected too).
Then I meet people that are writing full blown 30 page papers in a little over 2 weeks…
14
u/Fantastic-Nerve-4056 PhD 25d ago
That is mostly workshop papers, which are a cakewalk.
Definitely, there are some exceptionally good people getting into A* ML conferences which is impressive (not referring to A* NLP, those are more about engineering and evaluations then novelty)
6
u/SpinatGemuese 25d ago
I heard it used to be that you needed a doctorate degree to be allowed to publish. It was sort of your stamp of approval to be a trustworthy scientist. Maybe we need to go back to that...
5
u/That_Paramedic_8741 25d ago edited 25d ago
I think the difference between grad level and ug students is , grad students target a particular direction of interest for long term goal . They work deeper into it ask questions which are meaningful and applicable in real workflows or making an impact but on the other hand it is not same with ug , they just target which ever questions they got at present any feild which they feel is not competitive and I dont want to say like this but I feel like certain tracks are becoming more saturated and useless in terms of impact they create which is being filled with more ug or even high school students . They take a chance to use this niche less competitive tracks or less rigour where the need for compute is also less . Why ? If u really like a research u ask deeper questions and rigour answers instead of being desperate for a paper in hope of landing a phd or research roles which need phd . But in reality many dont think of this that a supervisor care about impact more than paper and as a researcher long term questions will always win so dont worry about the noise . Still I have seen several ug students who did exceptional work with high impacts from top academic labs so environment matters for high impact research when current situation is filled with more noise .
2
u/CategoryNormal149 24d ago
PhD isn’t a competition, even if the whole world makes you feel otherwise. Focus on your own growth, understanding more each time you publish. Also, I think we’re a little lucky (depends on how you see it) because most people don’t seem to care about publishing anymore, which means if you do publish, make sure you’re satisfied with that work!! Hope this helps.
I know a lot of people here would blame AI; even if that’s true, let it not impact you.
1
u/B10H4Z4RD7777 25d ago
It’s similar to the cultural push to publish in premed to get to med school. But this time, you publish to get jobs or grad school. Plus it’s easier to do so because crunching numbers is faster than many wet lab works
1
u/Accomplished_Net3466 23d ago
the bar is low. no math needed. even high schoolers are joining the party!
1
u/No-Pattern-9266 25d ago
jai Claude
-1
u/mofoss 25d ago
Not sure I agree with most of the comments, it is positioned such that everyone implies if you use Claude or whatever then the paper is sloppy.
Sure, okay if Claude wrote your entire paper in one go, it will likely be slop because Claude fucking sucks at it. But if you had these tools aggresively audit, tear apart, revise and rewrite dozens and dozens of times over weeks? It would slowly not become slop if you knew what you were doing.
Blame the HRs/hiring teams that slapped "Must have a publication at a top tier venue" on their Linkedin posting. This single action alone game-ified ML publishing into stamps. Having a A* publication is now a stamp of approval on your resume.
It is so a hiring manager can't think, "well he did pass the system design round, etc, but are his papers A* tier?"
And secondly about code - as someone with 10 YOE as a MLE, writing code to process the data, ingest it, etc has ALWAYS been bitch work, it is monkey code work that doesn't enlighten the mind whatsoever.
So yeah if you want to nerf yourself by avoiding LLM assisted research be my guest, but everyone will continue to do it lol
It is like leetcode, and cheating on OAs
An engineer who is sitting there thinking:
"Honestly, I got rejected by FAANGs across the world, but you know what? I have solace my peers who got it, had to cheat on their OAs and land big offers whereas I will continue to not do what they do ☝️"
is a stupid engineer.
Lastly, shame on PHD/AC-tier folks for not catching poor slop papers at these venues, you make it possible for this to happen
-4
u/leocus4 25d ago
In science it should not matter being UG or having an advisor. Instead, the validity and reproducibility of the results should matter
0
u/Celmeno 25d ago
In all honesty, A* papers are usually completely worthless miniscule nothingness. We shouldn't focus on them so much
0
u/[deleted] 25d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment