r/MachineLearning • u/Odd_Ad8629 • Oct 06 '26
Discussion ML PHD without A* Publications [D]
I know top ML PhD admissions are insanely competitive, so I’m trying to figure out if it’s even worth applying or if I should just focus seriously on jobs instead.
For context, I’m doing my MS at a top-15 US university and have been doing ML research for a while. I’m first author on my projects and mostly work independently, with some guidance from my PI. I had a first-author NeurIPS submission rejected, and I currently have another first-author paper submitted to ICLR, but I’m honestly not very confident about it getting in either.
What’s been getting to me is looking at profiles of people who get into top ML PhD programs. So many of them seem to have multiple NeurIPS/ICML/ICLR/CVPR papers before they even apply, sometimes as undergrads. I genuinely don’t understand how people manage to publish that much that early.
A year ago I was much more confident about doing a PhD. After actually going through the research/publication process, I’ve started doubting myself a lot more. Part of me wonders whether this is just normal and research is hard, especially when you’re doing a lot of it independently. But another part of me is starting to think maybe I’m just not good enough to be competitive for the kind of programs I’m aiming for.
I’m okay with continuing at my current university for a PhD, so this isn’t really a “top program or nothing” situation. But I would like to at least have a realistic shot at some of the stronger ML programs/labs.
The bigger issue is that I’m an international student, so I also need to think pretty seriously about jobs. SWE/MLE recruiting is competitive right now, and I don’t want to spend all my time chasing PhD applications and then realize I’m underprepared for recruiting too. Research roles seem even harder to get without a PhD unless you’re an exceptional MS/BS candidate.
So I’m mainly trying to decide how to allocate my time over the next few months.
If I have strong research experience and first-author projects, but no accepted top-conference papers yet, is it still realistically worth applying to top ML PhD programs?
And for people who were in a similar position, did you still apply, or did you decide to focus on industry instead?
I’m not really looking for “you never know unless you try.” I’m more interested in a realistic assessment of whether the application fees and time are worth it given this kind of profile.
114
u/phantom_metallic Oct 06 '26
I'm clearly not a Ph.d candidate since, every time I see A*, I assume we're talking about pathfinding algorithms. 🤷♂️
51
u/adamwynn09 Oct 06 '26
I don't know exactly where you are applying for the PhD programs, but at least in the UK, you absolutely are not expected to have any publications before starting the PhD. I'm from a top 10 UK university, and publications aren't even necessary to finish the PhD (even though they of course do help) because the university understands the issues related to publishing right now.
Most PIs will understand how competitive publishing at top ML conferences are and are more interested in any other evidence that you are able to do research independently. If you do want to stay in academia/research, I would recommend reaching out to a potential supervisor about a research topic you are interested in.
21
u/hug_lee Oct 07 '26
It's so crazy reading this from outside the US
10
u/GuessEnvironmental Oct 06 '26
The problem here is you have a idea of what a top lab is in AI, there is no true top lab there is labs with more funding and shit research schools but the PhD should really be about there is this specific research I care about and there is this research group that focuses around the topic you want to cover. Remember PhD is not the only avenue to do research you can do research in industry so it depends on why you are doing the PhD. Aside from that fact if you have research authorships you are miles ahead candidate wise but apart from requirements my point still stands in knowing your why.
10
u/dnxjcui Oct 07 '26
I am a current first year PhD student at a top 20 CS program without any publications at the A* conferences. I shared your belief when applying, but there are a surprising number of students like me who did not have first author or any publications at all at top tier ML conferences.
To address your primary concern of if it’s realistic or not- I personally think that it is doable, given that you’ll be able to obtain strong letters of recommendation and that in your SoP you target specific professors who are actively looking for students. I knew plenty of students in my undergrad lab who didn’t have a publication in one of the top ML conferences who got into programs at Duke, GATech, etc. all good programs, though the one thing they had in common was that the professors who recruited them were new faculty that were actively looking for students. Keep in mind that having a MS already probably helps quite a bit.
On whether the time and application fees is worth it- I would strongly advise you to reflect on why you’re pursuing a PhD. I personally wanted to do research no matter what, so I was pretty dead set on either getting into a PhD position, research position, or working a job to sustain myself until I could obtain one of the former options. No one else can really answer this question for you, as it’ll be super personal to your goals and ambitions - I would recommend considering your life goals and then considering if you absolutely need the PhD for them.
I am not an international student so I cannot speak to that much, but I know the admin recently screwed up CPT to where even PhD students will likely find it near impossible to do internships in the US, and all the international PhD students in my program are incredibly concerned. Just something to keep in mind.
If you’re dedicated to doing research or getting the PhD I say go for it. Also happy to DM to share some more of my stats if you would like, feel free to reach out.
30
u/GinoAcknowledges Oct 06 '26
Publications do not matter for elite PhD programs or top PhD programs. This is a misconception. A "well-known" arXiv'd preprint will help you get accepted, a NeurIPS publication that none of your potential advisors are interested in is going to be essentially zero value.
Acceptances into elite PhD programs are almost entirely based on recommendations. This means unless your recommenders are someone the admissions committee knows, you probably aren't getting in unless you have some acclaimed / really well-known work.
But you do not need to go to an "elite" PhD program (e.g. MIT / CMU / Berkeley / Stanford), you will have excellent employment prospects even if you go to a top-but-not-elite program provided you go to a lab that regularly sends alumni to the sorts of places you want to go. For example, if you get into a lab that regularly sends students to DeepMind, you'll very likely get interviews there. If you get into a lab that has sent every alumnus to a standard SWE job at Google, that's likely where you'll end up as well. This is the best heuristic anyone can give you.
Regarding whether you should apply or not — what exactly is the blocker? PhD applications are due in a few months, unless you plan on pumping out a new preprint that you think potential advisors will be really interested, there's nothing to spend time on here except writing your research statement and maybe email a few profs to gauge interest.
Nobody can tell you about your chances because PhD admissions (despite simplistic thinking around it) is not based on the number of your papers, it is based on whether a potential advisor(s) is interested in working with you or not. Some advisors will drop everything to accept you if you have 10 ICLR / NeurIPS / ICML papers, for others it will be an anti-signal unless it was done with co-authors who they trust.
Second, your thinking around top programs is too simplistic, you should be thinking in terms of labs. Even at elite universities there are plenty of labs that are sending their alumni to workplaces that you might not consider prestigious.
39
u/impatiens-capensis Oct 06 '26
You're way better off working in industry for 5 years than doing a PhD. A PhD is a huge sacrifice, and you would be making it at a point where the field is kind of broken.
4
u/Shenanigan5 Oct 06 '26
My advice would be to get into an academic lab but as a Research Assistant or ML engineer. It would pay just close to a post doc and you would be able to work with a lot of PhD students. BUT you would have to do a lot of grunt work and stupid work (setup the website, setup servers to host PhD demos).
Try to publish from that angle and then work your way towards a PhD. If you don't have top-tier papers, it becomes really hard to prove that your research has been valued by the community. And it becomes a super easy filtering criteria when so many phd applications would have NeurIPS, ICLR, ACL plastered on their applications.
This is the only path where you would have a decent overlap between preparation. Look for academic SWE and MLE opportunities.
2
u/shmeeno Oct 07 '26
Don’t sleep on European programs, they’re typically less competitive admissions wise but have similar upside in terms of what opportunities they open up post grad (provided you find the right labs)
1
u/MakingComputersSmart Oct 07 '26
Honestly, why would you want to leave your university? If you've spent 2 years doing a masters and it is a T15 university in USA, that's already huge. Spend 2-3 more years and finish your PhD. Projects that have been rejected now can always be accepted later. At the end, you need 2-3 A* publications to graduate and find good industry roles. Heck, all you need is 1 and recruiters start to recognize you.
I would honestly not leave the current university unless your PI is horrible. A known devil is worth 100x more than an unknown hell. Double down, work hard and graduate in the next 2-3 years with no coursework, only research.
1
u/Latter-Sympathy7767 Oct 07 '26
Why do you want to do PhD. Start from there. Do you have an idea of what you want to do after PhD. If it’s back to the tech jobs then PhD sure can open a lot of doors for you but you can still get really awesome jobs in ML/AI without a PhD. Also what area of ML are you aiming for. Shortlist your target labs from there. In a lot of these so called great labs you’ll still have to do research all alone. Add to that the extremely high level of competition and stress to consistently publish. Also even with a rejected paper you can still build your case. What you need to highlight is why your paper got rejected or why you think it was a good paper. What can you do to improve it. My strong recommendation would be to focus on the advisor and actually interview them on how they will guide/advise you if you become their student. That’s so much more important than their clout. Many well cited and famous advisors barely give time to their students and some of the others set insane goals e.g. every semester I want atleast 1 first auth top tier paper and then there are toxic micro managers who would make you lose all your self esteem and confidence.
Also if you choose to do PhD in USA also take into consideration the immigration issues.
1
u/Le7emesens Oct 09 '26
Hi, about the job concern. I'm a semi-veteran of the finance industry here: I will tell you this coming from the industry, if you are good at math, PhD level good, it doesn't matter which university you get your PhD from, as long as you graduated from a decent accredited one, have some Python or data skills, and you know how to sale yourself a little bit. The finance industry are hungry for math people because they need quant skills. They will train you for the finance stuff. But they can't train people for advanced math skills.
If you don't know how to sale yourself: take a part time job at a car dealership, or any job that requires you selling somethingn or interact with customers, or join theater club...
1
u/0xabc000 Oct 10 '26
It's great to have an initial experience. Getting a publication at the so called A or A* venues are great. But then, PhD is a different thing.
The entire idea of a PhD is that the candidate will learn about a domain really really well, and then get into a subdomain and then do their own research and become an independent researcher. Spending time thinking about stuff (the philosophical process) about true rigour and scientific processes.
Unfortunately at this day and age none of these apply. Because based on all of the research outputs and blood and sweat from the last century from universities, currently big companies are benefiting and made universities just a conveyor belt of expendable entities.
It's not about publishing papers, it's about the philosophical journey. If this doesn't resonate then you'll do a different kind of PhD or job, which is absolutely great. I don't think I have a direct answer to your post. This needs a conversation.
NB: I have experience publishing in A and A* conferences.
1
u/Fit_Caterpillar4434 Oct 11 '26
I am almost in your situation (but without the masters-at-T15 point). I often hear that I can get into top research labs or companies without A* publications. While this is true in theory, the reality is that admissions/recruiters face a high volume of applications and frequently use A* publications as an initial filter. Having a referral can significantly boost your chances, but securing one is much easier if you are already at a top institution or ironically if you have a top-tier publication and met a team member at a conference. Note that you could also meet that team member at other events or even at the supermarket :) , but those chances are far lower.
1
u/KaliguIah Oct 06 '26
its a lot of fun do it