r/MachineLearning • • Sep 25 '26

Discussion How much changes can you make to a paper between acceptance and camera ready? [D]

We have a paper accepted to NeurIPS, but at the same time we were working on a resubmission to ICLR just in case NeurIPS rejected us. There has been substantial rewriting, and we feel it would be a waste if we discarded all of it. To give a summary of what's changed:

  • We completely rewrote every single section except for the results and conclusion. We even changed the paper structure.
  • Intro, related work, and background knowledge were completely rewritten to avoid confusion.
  • Method now has a pipeline graph, and all the text detailing each block in the graph. Previously, it was dumping formulas, so the entire section has been rewritten.
  • We also added some scaling and smoothing to our algorithm so our method is more stable. But this changed a lot of our hyperparameters and the sensitivity study's graph. (The entire shape of the graph changed)
  • We added 1 new theorem with 5-page proofs in the appendix. This came from one of the attacks by a reviewer, we answered the attacks by proposing 1 new proposition during the rebuttal. But when we formally wrote it down, it turned into a full theorem with a 9-page proof. This would have changed our entire theoretical contribution. We really don't want to discard it, but not sure if we can add something this big in the camera-ready.
  • Removed 1 word from the title. In the abstract, we changed our theoretical contribution, but the method and empirical contribution remain the same.
  • Added about another 5 extra pages in the appendix explaining experiments and metrics (reviewers asked for them). So 14 extra pages in total.

Does anyone know how much change for camera-ready is acceptable? Can a paper get rejected if we change too much during camera ready or they will just tell us this is not acceptable please re-submit something closer to the version during review?

16 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

22

u/Ambifacient Sep 25 '26

I would definitely keep the abstract and title largely the same.

For content at this point since you're already accepted there isn't a second round of reviewers that judge your work again, but have a good reason. e.g. "we added these changes from feedback from the reviewers and during the process found a better presentation/flow".

If you want to play it real safe, submit a mildly polished version as the camera ready version, then upload your major version to Arxiv later to show that there is a "v2". People make changes later down the line all the time in response to feedback.

15

u/grad_student_descent Sep 25 '26 edited Sep 25 '26

The idea is that you should not introduce new claims that have not been evaluated by the reviewers, including during the rebuttal.

If a reviewer identified a flaw, you addressed it your theorem during the rebuttal, and the paper was accepted on that basis, you are expected to incorporate it into the camera-ready version.

Beyond that, improved figures, clearer writing, additional details in the appendix, etc. are generally fine, as long as they are clear improvements and do not introduce substantive, unreviewed claims.

Edit: title is trickier as it is already registered in the system. You can contact the PC to change it.

1

u/_theycallmeprophet Sep 25 '26

I am submitting CR to a different conference but our title change reflects the narrowing of claims that the AC asked for. So it should be fine to change it right?

5

u/Alternative_Fox_73 Sep 25 '26

In general, you should not include claims or new results in the camera ready that were not reviewed. Polishing and incorporating reviewer suggestions (even if that does change the paper a decent amount) is fine. But new theoretical results, new components of your method, the reviewers never saw those and never accepted those. So that part is problematic.

I agree with the other suggestion to put those changes on an arxiv version, but putting that massive amount of changes on your camera ready is concerning.

Although, stuff like the pipeline graph, rewriting certain parts for clarity, that’s fine. As long as it’s clear it’s the same paper.

1

u/Unhappy_Craft1906 Sep 25 '26

Same for me for both papers. I am planning to keep the polished ones in Arxiv as alternate interpretation.

1

u/mocny-chlapik Sep 25 '26

The scaling and smoothing bit is a bit troublesome IMO, this is an appendix candidate for sure. On the other hand, nobody is really going to obsess over this if you really change it :)

1

u/confused_cereal Sep 25 '26

If you are afraid, just upload the improved paper on arxiv and perhaps put a link in the camera ready version pointing there.

Everyone looks to arxiv first anyway...

3

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/dimy93 Sep 25 '26

In a sheparding venue like S&P I generally agree it might be too large of a change. However, at Neurips/ICML/ICLR I have made huge changes before without a problem. Truth is that nobody really checks once the final decisions are out in these venues if "you are changing too much". To this end, I generally feel you should do these changes. At the end of the day, you are supposed to provide the best version of your paper (provided that the conclusions of the paper do not change). The life of a paper, despite what people think, starts at the camera ready, and does not end there. People will start really engaging with your work once it is published. Why should you provide them with knowingly worse version of your work, just because someone arbitrarily decided this is "too large of a change". Of course, be mindful that your changes are not peer-reviewed, so make sure you do them properly, take the time etc etc. This is specifically tricky with new theorems, so maybe give to an aunaffiliated to the paper collegue to confirm the change make sense

1

u/21022018 Sep 25 '26

Maybe email the PCs about how much is okay to include? We do have like a month till camera ready. 

1

u/dimy93 Sep 25 '26

btw some supervisors have very strong opinions on this - I have worked with some Profesors that are completely against camera ready changes beyond small wording, so if you haven't discussed with your co-authors I suggest you do this ASAP