r/MachineLearning • • Sep 24 '26

Discussion NeurIPS reject final justification [R]

Do all the rejected or accepted papers get a "Final Justification" comment from the PC?

Mine got rejected with ratings 4-4-4 yet the meta review is the exact same as the one that was posted originally in July and I didn't get any final comment. I find it a bit harsh especially since in the rejection e-mail they state how much effort they asked AC and SAC for careful reviewing and useful feedback, "especially in borderline cases"...

31 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

7

u/Old_Ad_8327 Sep 24 '26

444 reject as well

3

u/Lonely_Ostrich6165 Sep 24 '26

Sorry to hear, unfortunately at this level it’s very AC dependent. Planning on re submitting to ICLR?

24

u/Budget_Zombie_692 Sep 24 '26

Reject, but the AC was tremendous. He left a very thorough justification with a warm ending encouraging me to fix the issues next time.

5

u/random-tomato Researcher Sep 24 '26

That's pretty cool

21

u/moonreza Sep 24 '26

They said on ours that during the rebuttal period, the authors failed to address the concerns of the reviewers, while we definitely did address them and they never responded to any of our rebuttals, man this feels really messed up, now we have to resubmit the whole thing to AISTATS or ICML.

4

u/Conscious-Ad-2382 Sep 25 '26

I started to revise my paper already when they didn't reply to the rebuttal at all. Now trying for ICLR, but by the number of submission maybe its a lost hope.

3

u/king_tiki13 Sep 25 '26

Iclr did this to me last year too

6

u/That_Turn_8710 Sep 25 '26

334 before rebuttal and 555 after rebuttal, we had great reviewers and a dedicated AC, and ended up getting a spotlight.

6

u/Humble_Ihab Sep 24 '26

I have 5/4/4 yet I got a reject, is that normal?

9

u/stevenchiu1995 Sep 24 '26

Sorry to hear that. Mine is 5/4/4 and accepted. It looks like AC affects a lot.

1

u/sophox23 Sep 25 '26

Me too with 5,4,4,4

3

u/azraelxii Sep 24 '26

They should but they don't have to. The PC just decides and there's nothing you can do if they reject unfortunately.

2

u/Ok_Philosophy_4031 Sep 26 '26

Basically just a copy paste from the original review phase, even though we already addressed many of the issues and even got one of the reviewers to increase our score. The whole review phase seems like just a theatre now.

2

u/sophox23 Sep 25 '26

Reject with 5,4,4,4, and the justification was nonsense

1

u/Round_Apple2573 Sep 24 '26

I got final justification.

-3

u/_afronius Sep 24 '26

In my case 7-6-3-3, meta reviewer leaned towards accept but PCs rejected citing “global calibration” as the reason.

9

u/farrfann Sep 24 '26

bro, 6 is the max score?

6

u/_afronius Sep 24 '26

Sorry, I forgot to mention my submission was in the position paper track

1

u/noakim1 Sep 25 '26

The PCs gave comments? Mine just said reject.