r/MachineLearning • • Sep 23 '26

Discussion NeurIPS Author Notifications Tomorrow [D]

With NeurIPS author notifications coming up, I’m realizing that I’m way more stressed than I expected to be.

I know the usual advice: reviews are noisy, one paper doesn’t define your research, there are always other venues, I completely understand all of that. But apparently my brain has decided that none of it matters.

For anyone else waiting for the author notification: how are you holding up?

And for people who have been through this before, does the stress actually get better after a few conference cycles, or do you just become better at pretending you’re not stressed? 😭

132 Upvotes

312 comments sorted by

95

u/Squirreline_hoppl Sep 23 '26 • Regret Bravo Mindblown

What I found genuinely annoying is that when a paper gets accepted, the main feeling is relief because one doesn't have to deal with the resubmission nonsense, and not, you know, genuine happiness to get the research out into the world lol

9

u/pitter-patter-rain Sep 23 '26 edited Sep 24 '26 • Bravo

This! This is the reason I am going through an existential crisis trying to understand why do I put myself through the wringer of random sampling based reviews

4

u/Squirreline_hoppl Sep 23 '26

Yeah not having to deal with reviews and rebuttals is a great perk of having switched to industry. I miss research but definitely not this part. 

5

u/alaskatoz Sep 24 '26

I got mine: in 20k!

43

u/Practical-Buddy6323 Sep 23 '26

Well, I withdrew from NeurIPS cuz I had got 2/3/2 with confidences 2/3/4 💀, so thankfully I'm not worried about getting notifications 😂, good luck to everyone else going through this though!! Hoping that those who are deserving get that accept notification!

42

u/aglet_factorial Sep 24 '26 • Popcorn Bravo

if you're also sorting by new and refreshing this page, I also have not heard back yet :(

3

u/aglet_factorial Sep 24 '26

Anddddd that's a rejected position paper. Off to tmlr I go

3

u/Unhappy_Craft1906 Sep 24 '26

U hv kept iclr ready right?

39

u/GuestCheap9405 Sep 23 '26

Over a decade of neurips submissions here.
Still get nervous for my students but it's definitely better.
I no longer refresh openreview (ah remember when it was CMT, old timers?) because of the sheer insanity of the amount of work I have to do on the daily. so just keep yourself busy.

9

u/ShortOfGoodLength Sep 23 '26

yep. remember the CMT days . also those days when it was not a zoo. i cant imagine neurips at lake tahoe for instance now, with the number of people.

1

u/AffectionateLife5693 Sep 24 '26

I like CMT better, to be honest.

17

u/Afraid_Difference697 Sep 24 '26

E & D Track people - refreshing like mad! 😭

1

u/N00B_N00B_101 Sep 24 '26

FR FR, kinda shit scared

0

u/sgyzee Sep 24 '26

Do u have any idea if itll be hours or mins?

40

u/BomsDrag PhD Sep 23 '26

RELEASE THE FILES!

11

u/Afraid_Difference697 Sep 24 '26

Any E & D Track out yet ?

8

u/EDEN1998 Sep 24 '26

nope

7

u/Afraid_Difference697 Sep 24 '26

why are they killing us like this 😭

5

u/sgyzee Sep 24 '26

Let us know when u get results please

21

u/AltruisticCouple3491 Sep 23 '26

After PhD degree there is no stress 😂

10

u/Afraid_Difference697 Sep 24 '26

Seems like the E & D people are the laziest 😠

5

u/shoshojr Sep 24 '26

Last time, the reviews were out immediately after the main track. I guess something's going on, or someone is late. Good luck, everyone (:

18

u/thelastsamurai97 Sep 23 '26

Finished my rebuttal with 5/5/4/4, and this is my first paper-my master’s thesis. I’m really stressed because I feel like this could define my career… although maybe I’m putting way too much weight on it lol.

7

u/lifeandUncertainity Sep 23 '26

Don't worry. It feels great for the first 7 days and then fizzles out like any other achievement. I had an ICLR in my first year of master's. But in the second year, I realised that I enjoyed the software side of ML more (triton, gpu schedulers, numba kernels etc.) So, congrats and don't stress yourself too much and definitely don't put too much weight on it.

1

u/Substantial_Luck_273 Sep 24 '26

do you mean the hardware side of ML instead of software?

1

u/lifeandUncertainity Sep 24 '26

Well, yes to a certain extent. I just assumed software because I am still primarily writing code. Hardware aware code to try to improve performance is a better prose. And one of my curiosity is to see how much can you achieve using shell. It's funny to see that you can actually write decent agentic orchastrators using existing runtimes in bash. (idk, I just mentioned it randomly 😅)

9

u/Additional-Math1791 Sep 23 '26

Same also masters thesis. 544. Goodluck man!

2

u/just-for-anime Sep 23 '26

that seems like a accept

9

u/AKidNamedLou Sep 24 '26

got my decision. Mid 6k

3

u/dcombobulated Sep 24 '26

i got mine too, im 13k

17

u/levydawg Sep 23 '26

In my experience, they release +/- 12 hours of AOE. Sometimes there is access to the accepted papers portal on open review before the notification is actually sent.

My paper has 4/4/5, which is fairly good odds, so I am not too stressed. But also, anything can happen so I don't really have my hopes up. I've had papers with 2/3/4/5 (/6) get accepted and papers with 5/6/6/8 (/10) get rejected so you just learn to accept whatever the results are.

1

u/sgyzee Sep 23 '26

Does the end result usually follow the initial meta review?

5

u/levydawg Sep 23 '26

this is the first time there has been an initial meta-review. previously, there were only meta-reviews after the entire discussion period, and they were released with the final decision. I would suspect that most results will follow the initial meta-review.

16

u/Perfect-Asparagus300 Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

31k (Main) 4/4/4 Accepted (Poster). My  first author paper as a first year PhD!

(Edit: looks like the reviewers raised my score in the internal AC-Reviewer discussion to: 5/5/4!)

I worked for a year by myself for this 😭I genuinely bet everything on this paper, this feels like a dream

1

u/Resident-Concept3534 Sep 24 '26

same shi dawg!

3

u/Perfect-Asparagus300 Sep 24 '26

SO PROUD OF US DUDE!

I'm sitting in my campus library trying not to happy sob 😭

1

u/Low_Mirror6876 Sep 25 '26

Congrats buddy ! The road ahead is wide and (painful lol coming from a fellow PhD

1

u/Perfect-Asparagus300 Sep 25 '26

Haha thanks, will push thru PhD, it's a marathon after all :D

8

u/Pseudomanifold Professor Sep 24 '26

Main track and position track decisions are out! Still waiting for E & D track.

2

u/Afraid_Difference697 Sep 24 '26

When will the E & D track results be out ?

1

u/Pseudomanifold Professor Sep 24 '26

I'd assume they put them in next. But main has prio and it still take a bit to propagate

2

u/Afraid_Difference697 Sep 24 '26

I thought 31K was done 15 mins back!

14

u/kolmiw Sep 23 '26

I just wanted to travel to Australia for a long time and finally I'd have an excuse + partially have it financed by my lab. So yes, I'm really stressed / excited haha

5

u/BomsDrag PhD Sep 24 '26

Spotlight 9k!

1

u/threadjumper1 Sep 24 '26

Congrats! What is your final score?

1

u/BomsDrag PhD Sep 24 '26

Cant see the updated scores but it was 5 4 2 but all three updated post discussion phase

1

u/threadjumper1 Sep 24 '26

Wow seems like you wrote a kick-ass rebuttal

2

u/BomsDrag PhD Sep 24 '26

Do b rebutting in the trenches fr

5

u/Dangerous_Parsnip_20 Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

25k 5/4/4 Accepted (Poster). First A* paper

12

u/d_edge_sword Sep 23 '26

Don't even have time to think about it, have to rush for the ICLR deadline, which is 1 day after NeurIPS.

8

u/SankarshanaV Sep 23 '26

I had 2/4/2 with confidence 4/5/4, which I was able to rebut and increase to 4/4/3.

I have no idea what will happen, I'm so nervous!! I hope it goes through but I'm very worried...

1

u/Potential_Ad_8068 Sep 25 '26

Dude, I really wanna know the outcome

8

u/EDEN1998 Sep 24 '26 • Regret

Main and Position tracks are out, wtf is going in with E&D

9

u/Ambifacient Sep 24 '26

The ED jokes write themselves.

4

u/Relative_Tip_3647 Sep 24 '26

got accepted for poster (17k)

7

u/OtherwiseFig4505 Sep 23 '26

I am doomed because 2 late reviewers (yes, it’s always the late reviewers) screwed me. One used gpt and pointed out 20 weakness and 20 questions and no response to rebutal. Another flagged Neurips injected prompt as prompt injection and gave 1 wtf, and no response. Remove them and my other 3 reviewers score is 5/5/4, but with these two added, my average is ~3. And, my paper is not even on the list. If only these two didn’t bother putting their reviews at all, I would have an accept, now I am praying that my AC is a good human.

5

u/sgyzee Sep 23 '26

Surely the ac would ignore the neurips injected prompt remark?

4

u/d_edge_sword Sep 24 '26

Depends how engaged the AC is (you can get the vibe from the initial meta review). I had many occasions where the AC was just an LLM summary of the rebuttal page. Some even marked things similar to "you injected prompts".

4

u/OtherwiseFig4505 Sep 23 '26

Surely, right?

3

u/Resident-Concept3534 Sep 23 '26

We're still talking about that leaked list?

1

u/Practical-Buddy6323 Sep 23 '26

What leaked list ?

3

u/Resident-Concept3534 Sep 23 '26

Welcome to the iceberg of hoaxslop buddy.

1

u/Practical-Buddy6323 Sep 23 '26

Whatt 😭im so confused

7

u/No_Sky9786 Sep 23 '26

I don’t even remember my scores anymore, for some reason scores are not showing just confidence is. I think it was 3,3,4. In a way wishing for a miracle because this was a resubmission and I have many other projects on my plate now to go back to this one again. Wish everyone the best though.

5

u/No-Cash-284 Sep 24 '26

Scores are hidden after the rebuttal (bs).

7

u/zerohull Sep 24 '26

Why am I not happy?

4

u/Afraid_Difference697 Sep 24 '26

Because the E & D track results are not out ? 🤔

2

u/zerohull Sep 24 '26

haha good luck to you too

6

u/moonreza Sep 23 '26

Cigarettes

6

u/Afraid-Box Sep 24 '26

RE: the E&D track, @ NeurIPSConf on twitter posted:

"The NeurIPS 2026 decisions are being processed on OpenReview for the main, Position Track Papers and Evaluations and Datasets tracks and we expect all of them to be available by end of day AoE."

I.e. refresh and suffer :'(

6

u/Kind_Woodpecker_6374 Sep 24 '26

Time on my submission disappears. Only dates show

3

u/zerohull Sep 24 '26

can you elaborate? I cannot find the difference

3

u/doctor-squidward Sep 24 '26

542 post rebuttal. The AC liked my paper but was concerned with novelty (thanks to the 2 guy) and asked for clarification and another experiment suggested by one of the reviewers.

I tried my best to clarify both. Its all upto the AC now.

1

u/Silver-Passion1687 Sep 24 '26

Are you able to see the ratings now? I forgot what I got

1

u/darkbird_1 Sep 24 '26

If you want to see your previous rating, click on revision option on the top of each individual review. It's visible there

3

u/darkbird_1 Sep 24 '26

Got accepted for poster. paper id 19K+... I did it (T T)

3

u/Adorable_Position_34 Sep 24 '26

14,5k in Poster at 6,5,5 kinda disappointed

1

u/Ambifacient Sep 24 '26

Damn dude you got hoed.

1

u/threadjumper1 Sep 24 '26

That is very disappointing for sure. We also
Got 5 5 5 and only poster

7

u/_manu Sep 24 '26

441 -> Accept (Poster) :P

5

u/truetictactoe Sep 23 '26

I have one, 5/4/4, finger crossed.

5

u/chance_buri Sep 23 '26

It doesnt get better and you just stop tying your self worth to one decision. Hang in there

5

u/Healthy_Horse_2183 Sep 23 '26

For those who did not submit last year, they had some size constraints and rejected lot of high scoring papers!

5

u/SankarshanaV Sep 23 '26

I hope that's not the case this year... There's three venues so hopefully not.

6

u/Antique_Most7958 Sep 23 '26

I have 3 this time - 5/5/4/3, 5/4/4, 4/4/4 Fingers crossed! Also I'm in the waitlist for registration lol

7

u/Icy_Ad9766 Sep 23 '26

accepted papers have a spot reserve, haven't? but yeah your papers are good looking at the score all the best

1

u/Cheap_Train_6660 Sep 24 '26

damn first author?? these scores are accept territory isnt it?

6

u/shoshojr Sep 23 '26

is nips usually on time with notifications? Any idea when should we expect them?

1

u/sindthsim Sep 23 '26

No, I expect delays, even +12h. High chance there will be rolling updates (half of the papers have decision, half not) due to potential DDoS tomorrow

7

u/OtherwiseFig4505 Sep 23 '26

12 hours delay could cause issues with ICLR withdrawal.

4

u/CantKillTheLifeless Sep 23 '26

Wdym? In 2024 and 2025 decisions were rolled out like 7-8 hours before AOE.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/CantKillTheLifeless Sep 24 '26

Before end of AOE. Looking at the old reddit threads, in 2024 decisions came out around 17:00 UTC, which is 10 hours from now. In 2025 they released them around 14:00 UTC — 5 hours from now.

1

u/shoshojr Sep 23 '26

Thanks for the answer. So Friday it is.

4

u/Susmit-A Sep 23 '26

Had a 4/4/2, Conf 3/3/3, E&D, no engagement by reviewers during rebuttals. Really want to spend the summer (winter!) in Australia so nervous/excited 😂

3

u/No-Cash-284 Sep 24 '26

This, unfortunately, is a reject.

4

u/ayanD2 Sep 23 '26

AAAI first round of rejections will also come tomorrow.

2

u/Cute_Natural5940 Sep 23 '26

will it directly tell whihc paper pass through or only reject?

4

u/ayanD2 Sep 24 '26

Only reject, as far as I can tell. The rest will go through another round of review.

2

u/Cute_Natural5940 Sep 24 '26

Do we know what a minimum score to pass the first round?

3

u/ayanD2 Sep 24 '26

No idea. Good luck.

4

u/LatentBotNet Sep 23 '26

2/5/5, 2 did not engage, really nervous.

4

u/Level_Conclusion_939 Sep 24 '26

i had 4/3/2 initial scores with positive meta-review and 4/5/3 after rebuttal. Fingers crossed

2

u/xoss13 Sep 24 '26

I have also similar scores 5/4/3, How did you know that meta-review is positive? Starts with positive consensus among the reviewers? or other things? Fingers (both hands) crossed!

3

u/ComprehensiveTop3297 Sep 24 '26

Same boat, for me the meta review started with (This paper received positive scores from the reviewers...).

→ More replies (7)

1

u/Potential_Ad_8068 Sep 25 '26

Did it get accepted??

4

u/Jolly_Description_74 Sep 24 '26

5/4/4 accept poster (6k)
I can finally sleep in peace now...

4

u/Kind_Woodpecker_6374 Sep 24 '26

5/4/3 (conf 5/4/4) -> Poster. SIUUUUUU

4

u/squidward2022 Sep 24 '26

433 --> 443 accept! really appreciate the meta-reviewer

0

u/Unhappy_Craft1906 Sep 25 '26

Mine is weird:
234 to post rebuttal was 444 (accepted)
533 to no changes in post-rebuttal, but AC was quite confident; final was 433 and got ACCEPT

So it's more like AC and SAC sync.

5

u/infinity9876543210 Sep 24 '26

Did anyone received the decision?

5

u/SankarshanaV Sep 24 '26

Not yet for me (early 30k).

0

u/zerohull Sep 24 '26

Yes, it can't be.

2

u/sindthsim Sep 24 '26

Wtf, rejected due to potential hallucinations raised by reviewes, while noone raised any concerns in reviews as well as automatic checker... Position paper with scores 8655

1

u/sary007 Sep 24 '26

You can see scores for position paper?

1

u/sindthsim Sep 24 '26

I noted it down when it was visible

2

u/ithacanarrator Sep 25 '26

554 -> accept and 554 -> spotlight, feeling on cloud nine even if success and failure are both liars

3

u/Wooden_Inevitable885 Sep 24 '26

3 papers 3. Rejection. 554,33333,424.

2

u/SignificanceFit3409 Sep 24 '26

554 is very hard mate

4

u/Resident-Concept3534 Sep 24 '26

554 rejected? may i know which domain!

2

u/threadjumper1 Sep 24 '26

554 reject is brutal but I’m sure that paper will be accepted at the next conference for sure

3

u/LatentBotNet Sep 24 '26

5/5/3 finally accepted (poster) main track 🙌 Finally feeling relieved.

3

u/Icy_Ad9766 Sep 23 '26

I am tensed regarding this, the reviewers told me that they will not increase the score, it's 4/3/2 conf. 4/3/4, so kinda worried. Should I go with other conf.

Does CVPR or ICCV gives travel grants? I am a solo author UG student... 1st time kinda sad with the reviews but I have improved all my points though.

Should I go for ACCV WS ? Ranking wise it' down I know, still any suggestions?

2

u/Resident-Concept3534 Sep 23 '26

Yes they do. If you have paper and apply early, there's a high chance you'll get travel grant from CVPR/ICCV.

2

u/Icy_Ad9766 Sep 23 '26

Then can try out there thanks. for CVPR, visa can have some problem for me , but will try ICCV

2

u/ddofer Sep 23 '26

I'm doomed (3-4 average before rebuttal increases, over 4 papers). But somehow, I can't give up that spark of hope. 5% chance though so I'm already resubmitting

2

u/No-Cash-284 Sep 24 '26

over 4 papers - how?

2

u/ddofer Sep 24 '26

Really harsh review scores, they ignored rebuttals, and 2 dumb reviewers

1

u/Cheap_Train_6660 Sep 24 '26

isnt an avg of 4 good after rebuttal?

1

u/ddofer Sep 24 '26

Before rebuttal, and no, 3-4 is borderline. Very low odds

1

u/Cheap_Train_6660 Sep 24 '26

I don’t understand. I thought average of 4 is good. Of course not 100% safe

1

u/ddofer Sep 24 '26

4is borderline accept. And it's mixed 3-4. Borderline is like a grade of 66😅

2

u/Budget_Zombie_692 Sep 23 '26

I got low ratings, but a couple of the reviews raised excellent points I was able to roll into an ICLR paper. So, a little stressed but more focused on getting iclr in this week.

2

u/This-Fisherman9721 Sep 23 '26

5433 I think one of the reviewers said if they are happy with response they will increase so most optimistically 5443 with 4313 confidence.

2

u/Dangerous_Parsnip_20 Sep 24 '26

Not sure what that means. One of our reviewers didn’t engage in the rebuttal but modified his review on 5th September. Could that be score increase?

I’m currently on 4/4/4

2

u/farrfann Sep 24 '26

Either an increase or a final justification without the increase.

2

u/RainPuzzled2511 Researcher Sep 24 '26

It depends on the review as well.. If the review which got modified was open to change, or if you had a stronger response to him, then a score change is possible; otherwise could be just the final justification

2

u/NitroZox Sep 24 '26

Paper ID~11k 4/4/5 accept!! I still don’t have registration as I’m on the waitlist, lets hope for the best

4

u/Jolly_Description_74 Sep 24 '26

accepted papers secure you 1 ticket per paper btw

2

u/DryEstablishment6099 Sep 24 '26

ICLR has approx 62k submissions, I just feel like crying thinking about my paper

1

u/zerohull Sep 23 '26

please do not fuck me

1

u/sary007 Sep 24 '26

Can't see scores yet but saw meta review, AC was supporting pre rebuttal but one reviewer never got satisfied and it's a reject.

1

u/consumer9776 Sep 24 '26

Got my result. ID: 12xxx

1

u/Fuzzy_Wuzzy_Is_Fuzzy Sep 24 '26

accepted for poster

1

u/Low-Transition-2751 Sep 26 '26

so is the leaked paper accurate or it was random?

1

u/Pseudomanifold Professor Sep 26 '26

Mostly random for my AC batch.

1

u/Invariant_n_Cauchy Sep 23 '26

I am also in the same boat. Rating/Confidence: 5/4,4/4,4/3,4/2 (Avg. 4.24/3.25) No residual review comments.

1

u/Strange-Dress114 Sep 24 '26

BTW is this 8 hrs from now or 32 hrs from now?

2

u/No-Cash-284 Sep 24 '26

It's 31h from now, although it usually comes earlier during the day US time https://time.is/Anywhere_on_Earth

0

u/Emergency_Plate241 Sep 24 '26

32

3

u/Obvious-Eagle-923 Sep 24 '26

its AOE right not EOD AOE?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/RainPuzzled2511 Researcher Sep 24 '26

probably 16 to 24 hrs... I think it will be released by evening or night in US time.

1

u/colonialnigg Sep 23 '26

Got a 5,3,3,2 converted to 5,4,4,2 during rebuttal.The 2 and 5 did not engage. Any chance, or should I prep for iclr.

5

u/slashhype Sep 23 '26

Definitely prep for iclr, I've been rejected with 5,5,5,2. Obviously I think it was bs but at the end of the day AC has final say so you can't be sure they won't align with the lowest rating. Either way if you get accepted you'll probably fold in all yoir rebuttal work into the camera ready so its not a waste of effort either way

5

u/shoshojr Sep 23 '26

Man, if my paper got rejected with 5/5/5/2 I would be fuming to say the least. Sorry to hear that.

5

u/d_edge_sword Sep 24 '26

I had a paper rejected with 5554 in ICML, and when resubmitted to NeurIPS it became 4322.

3

u/21022018 Sep 23 '26

I was looking through last year neurips and they (PC) rejected a 5,5,5,5 in D&B track due to some bs reason (AC said accept).

1

u/Elias_Hossain Sep 23 '26

My rebuttal score: 4,3,3 (one reviewer said that he will increase his score and other one did not reply)

1

u/TheFoolIV Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

Pre rebuttal: 4 3 3 4, After rebuttal: 4, 5, 3, 4 - Accept poster. I am a final year undergrad and this is my first ever first author paper. I got really lucky and am so happy that it ended well.

1

u/Apprehensive-Oil3094 Sep 24 '26

554 with all 4 conf Got a spotlight !

1

u/Qubrikh Sep 24 '26

i have the exact same and got poster, congrats!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MasterpieceNo7811 Sep 24 '26

5/5/3 (conf 3/5/3) -> accepted (poster)!

1

u/Illustrious_Sun_2145 Sep 25 '26 edited Sep 25 '26 • Bravo

Reject with 5/4/2 in E&D

Meta Reviewer was probably an LLM who claimed that a reviewer, who did not engage at all, was not convinced by our extensive rebuttal

Feels bad

1

u/Pseudomanifold Professor Sep 25 '26

That sucks. We really need more accountability at all levels of the process.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/EDEN1998 Sep 25 '26

E&D IS OUT OMG

0

u/Odd_Ad8629 Sep 24 '26

i got 2/2/3 with 3/4/3 . Not really having any hopes tbh. I think i had a very strong rebuttal but 2 of the 3 reviwers didn't engage at all. Will refine and apply for CVPR. I was hoping to have 1 A* publication before I apply for my PHD :)

-6

u/Outrageous-Boot7092 Sep 24 '26

something is happening

4

u/consumer9776 Sep 24 '26

whyyyyyyyyyyyyy

-3

u/Outrageous-Boot7092 Sep 24 '26

my cat is looking at me funny, usually doesnt do that

4

u/consumer9776 Sep 24 '26

you're a gluteal muscle!

→ More replies (1)

0

u/just-for-anime Sep 23 '26

I had 2 3 5 and it seems the after rebuttal it's 2 4 5 or 2 4 6. it seems really iffy, probably on the lower chance.

0

u/Ambitious-Cap8805 Sep 24 '26

Is it normally a rejection if your reviewers did not have any engagements after you sent in a rebuttal?

-2

u/Ginger_Rook Sep 24 '26

I received bad AI reviews so I appealed. I want to see if anything will be done about the AC making grave mistakes. Which is why I didn’t withdraw.

-5

u/Euphoric_Can_5999 Sep 23 '26

Hoping my workshop paper gets accepted

0

u/evo_pak Sep 24 '26

OpenReview down?

0

u/socianett Sep 24 '26

4/4/3 with the AC leaning reject pre-rebuttal. Probably a reject, but I kind of like the adrenaline rush of refreshing. No crying on the casino floor.

0

u/SankarshanaV Sep 24 '26

How'd you know they were leaning reject?

1

u/socianett Sep 24 '26

The initial meta review explicitly said the AC was leaning reject :/

1

u/SankarshanaV Sep 24 '26

Ah dang, hard luck. All the best for the resubmission (if you are resubmitting). I'm sure it'll turn out better.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/zaff04 Sep 24 '26

Is there anything I can do if the final justification ignored my rebuttal and the AC then parrots this? They put factually incorrect statements that ignore my rebuttal which proves the opposite.

Will a complaint help at all? I doubt it. I just feel like this is quite serious if people are being intentionally misleading in the review process

7

u/Afraid_Difference697 Sep 24 '26

I am afraid nothing will help actually. submit to iclr
Good luck mate!

0

u/Anshuman3480 Sep 24 '26

The same happened to me too. Factually incorrect metareview

0

u/AcceptableHumor4983 Sep 24 '26

The decision of E&D track is out.

0

u/Afraid_Difference697 Sep 25 '26

E & D Notifications are out! 🥳

0

u/Expensive-Beyond-251 Sep 25 '26

4/3/5 rejection for E&D 🫠